Printable View
Kill: Ichigo
Too eager to volunteer to die :inquisitive:
The way I read this it makes no difference if the mafia loses a goon (as sasaki indicates that the godfather then gains nightkill power) so I'm suspicious of anyone who volunteers to die that easily.
Err, you say that for someone kill Sapi for you or you are sugesting Sapi is the goon?Quote:
Originally Posted by pevergreen
Sapi - It would have been nice if you'd given the Cop some warning of who you're killing, as already suggested.
Also, Ichigo volunteered once to die, but you volunteered twice to kill.
Who is the cop?Quote:
Originally Posted by HughTower
We don't know, but obviously he should investigate people that aren't killing or dying, so he needs to be given warning to get his PM across to Sasaki in time.
Ichigo has been killed by sapi. He was a townie.
It is now night.
*************
It is now day.
HughTower has been found dead. He was a townie.
Ichigo
Ultrawar
Caius
Sir Boo
pevergreen
CountArach
Kukri
BK
CR
Xiahou
sapi
HughTower
Perhaps we should have Sapi volunteer to perish this round, as he hasn't perished like the killer of yesterday and may be a don. Any word from our cop on who the goon is?
And where's Ultrawar, and why hasn't he responded since my accusation?
Let's not rush this people.
CR
Quote:
Originally Posted by sapi
Could you explain how that makes me eager to die sapi?Quote:
Originally Posted by Ichigo
UltraWar is innocent.
How do you know?Quote:
Originally Posted by Caius Flaminius
1. He's the cop, orQuote:
Originally Posted by ByzantineKnight
2. Ultra revealed a PM to him, and he believes it, or
3. He's guessing.
Given his usual conservative play-style, I go for 1 or 2, with heavy reliance on 1 (he's the cop). He dosen't usually make definitive, assertive statements like that.
Put it this way - that's exactly what i'd do if i was a mafia goon - get myself killed off so i'd never have to prove my innocence.Quote:
Originally Posted by Ichigo
Sorry (considering that i was wrong), but with little information I had to make a decision that i believed would be in the best interests of the town, and that was it.
@CR - while you could have me die, it'd be a better idea, imo to try two people at once by having someone else both kill and die (because killing = not the goon, and dieing reveals the role)
That would be a stupid thing to do if you were mafia since you would be proven guilty because Sasaki tells you if they are townie or mafia. I think would be the best choice to kill at this point since your reasoning is faulty.:thumbsdown:Quote:
Originally Posted by sapi
:no:
Going along with it would be stupid - volunteering would not ;)
You arent playing Monks and Masons, I reveal a chat log that incriminates him, then he makes all these accusations that I'm fraiming him. I almost get lynched, but when my bro backed me up and was proved pro-town, he got lynched. And now he is still trying to get me lynched even though he is anti-town role...Quote:
Originally Posted by KukriKhan
He likes to spread disorder, I would lean towords him being mafia...
He certainly seems to be doing so :inquisitive:
So he's your vote for the kill/lynch?
I'm reserving judgement until i hear from him, though of course in this game you don't have to :laugh4:
Just thought of a cool idea! Zombie kill :laugh4:
Zombie kill: all the mafia so the town wins :grin2:
:laugh4:
If only :thumbsup:
Ya.Quote:
Originally Posted by sapi
I agree - but i won't kill - i got enough of an earful from Ichigo about the last one :laugh4:
If no one minds (except Caius), I'll do it.Quote:
Originally Posted by sapi
Caius, what do you have to say to defend yourself??
Ichigo should choose someone to be a killer. That was the reward for taking a hit for the town.
That killer should then choose his victim with advice/suggestions from the town. If he has an reasoning for this, then so much the better. He should give warning so the cop is able to investigate someone who is not killing or shooting.
Sapi should no longer kill anyone - he has proven he is not the goon. But he could still be the Don.
We do not require volunteers to be killers - naming someone on whim to be the killer is a good way of drawing out people out.
Hmmm... 3 birds with 1 stone (cop + 2 suspects). Me like! Seems a good way forward. :thumbsup:Quote:
Ichigo should choose someone to be a killer. That was the reward for taking a hit for the town.
That killer should then choose his victim with advice/suggestions from the town. If he has an reasoning for this, then so much the better. He should give warning so the cop is able to investigate someone who is not killing or shooting.
Nothing yet
EDIT:CR is suspechous.He threw an accusation to UltraWar, when he is innocent.Believe me town, maybe i appear dead the next round.Dont make a foolish mistake.
I'll choose Kukri.
Thanks for your confidence, mate. :bow:Quote:
Originally Posted by Ichigo
But I haven't a clue who to kill. Maybe one of the better analyzers like CR or HTower could pick better. I'm still a little new to this mafia game thing (this is my 2nd), and I'd hate to be the guy who kills an innocent townie, further reducing our ranks in this potentially quick-to-resolve game type. There's only 6 of us townies left. If I kill the wrong guy (especially if it's the cop), that leaves only 4.
If you insist, OK; but I hope you don't.
Who does the rest of the town think should be killed, whoever the 'namer' is?
Analysis then:
Lurkers
Sir Boo - no posts since game began
Xiahou - 1 post since game began
Noticeable behaviour
Caius Flaminius - claimed Ultrawar is innocent & CR is suspicious for questioning him. Is CF a cop?
BK - has volunteered to kill once
Suspicious behaviour
Sapi - offered to kill twice, didn't give warning to town/cop who he was going to kill, & got his logic all wrong on suggesting that Ichigo's behaviour was Mafia like. He has killed & therefore he is not the goon or cop.
Others
Kukri
Rabbit
Conclusions
Leave Sapi alive (for the moment)
If he is Don (then as well as playing his part badly) he cannot nightkill while the Goon is alive. If he daykills a second time, then he should be purged.
Kill a lurker.
My preference would be Xiahou. He's experienced at Mafia & has posted on other threads recently.
Don't ask BK to be a shooter
He's volunteered already & we have to take something at face value for the moment.
I agree with Hughtower - though I would lean more towards offing Sapi, but Sir Boo and Xiahou are good choices, being lurkers.
What do you think of those three choices, Kukri?
CR
@HughTower, CR
I understand why you think me suspicious (and I'd probably do the same in your place). What you must remember is that the first goal for the town has to be catching the goon, and killing someone who obviously is not one is not the best way to go.
I'd be leaning towards lynching Xihou or Sir Boo, as both have been active in other games.
Someone die already - this game is dieing :inquisitive: