I figured that someone would cry WIFOM. Whatever, first votes rarely catch the mafia so I don't feel real hurt. Best of Luck to y'all. I still think that Sarathos is guilty.
Printable View
I figured that someone would cry WIFOM. Whatever, first votes rarely catch the mafia so I don't feel real hurt. Best of Luck to y'all. I still think that Sarathos is guilty.
And why is that again?Quote:
Originally Posted by Waldinger
An explanation there would be nice too. If it's a random vote, fine- but let's not try to make it like you have some inside information when you don't.Quote:
Originally Posted by Ichigo
His retaliation vote against Beefy. Sarathos strikes me as the kind of person who would do that as a mafioso. Anyways, it probably is for the best that I'm going to get lynched. I'm already in two big games and the IH. Just do me the favor of lynching Sarathos next round.
Who knows what I have? :shrug:Quote:
Originally Posted by Xiahou
I know you don't have anything because I'm innocent- duh. Being way too cagey...Quote:
Originally Posted by Ichigo
vote: Ichigo
I will strike you, but not as mafia.....Quote:
Originally Posted by Waldinger
Plus my vote wasnt really a retaliation vote, it was more an annoyed vote at Beefy dodgey reasoning. Also your reason wasnt much better, so I still fail to see how I am mafia.
No, it was a retaliation vote.
Xiahou, you are over-reacting....mafia...
Youve been playing mafia with me for many many games now Sarathos...
And you would know that I believe round 1 is joke. Im not trying to lynch you, eat you or bully you in anyway.. If you read the past games my reason in round 1 was always dodgey. (Some may argue that its always dodgey...) But dodgeyness of my reason in round 1 is intentional.
:2thumbsup: implys that its an joke and your over reacting way too much.
There fore my vote stands. I do know you got a habit of over reaction. But it seems way too scummy especially in round 1.
Think it this way....
Vote= love:laugh4:
Round 1 is random...You dont need to state that.
Unvote: Sarathos, Vote: Xiahou
HoS: Beefy
Xiahou over defensive.
I stated that as well. Why didn't you vote me for it?Quote:
Originally Posted by pevergreen
Unvote ; Vote : pevergreen
What's that, you are the secret role?Quote:
Originally Posted by Sarathos
vote: Sarathos
Because beefy was more suspicious at that point.Quote:
Originally Posted by Andres
It was a response to that Pever.Quote:
Originally Posted by Sarathos
Sarathos is more of over defence then Xiahou at this point.
Unvote: Andres
Vote: Xiahou
I suspected Xiahou from the start, he'd be someone to send in such a kill.
Now that he gets all defensive and makes retaliation votes, he should be lynched IMO.
Clearly just a feeling but better than a random vote.
Question to the host
Did the mafia actually oredered to kill the host or was that part of the game?
If the host was killed by the mafia did he write the kills?
Why would he do that? Why would any mafiosi do that?Quote:
Originally Posted by Husar
I think this was meant to be by the host, not something that was decided by the mafia.
That'd be my guess. Why would the mafia essentially waste a kill?Quote:
Originally Posted by Andres
I'm not being defensive- get a clue people -I was being proactive. I basically asked Ichi to admit his vote was random. Being innocent, I knew for certain that he had no information on me, but instead of saying he just made a random vote he makes some veiled reference to possibly "knowing" something about me. If he does, let's hear it- there's only 1 mafia in this game, yes? Reveal and end the game.
His original vote reasoning was crap "I think you're guilty", and then he goes on to suggest that he has some sort of information to base that on. Very scummy behavior. Had he just said it was a random rd1 vote, it would've been a different matter.
Edit: If you people think actually trying to base my vote on something rather than sheer randomness is scummy, then lynch me and be done with it. :shrug:
If I wanted to keep a low profile, I could've easily vote for someone who already had votes against them and no one would've thought a thing.
How exactly was Beefy being suspicious?Quote:
Originally Posted by pevergreen
I asked a similar question to our gamehost and the answer indicated that it was sent in like this and since the gamehost found it funny, it was executed like it was sent in.Quote:
Originally Posted by Andres
Since that's the best clue I have, I'm thinking about who would make such a joke. If you can come up with someone else, tell us. :2thumbsup:
Voting so far
------
Xiahou 3 (ichi, pevergreen, husar)
Ichi 2 (craterus, xiahou)
Beefy
Sarathos 3 (beefy, waldinger, factionheir)
pevergreen 1 (andres)
Warmaster
shlin
FactionHeir
Husar
Andres
Craterus
Waldinger 2 (sarathos, caius)
Garcilaso
--------
I'll end voting around 5 or 6pm EST when I get home from work.
(All kills are mafia chosen, kill write ups are mine with any amount of input from the mafia that they choose)
Don't forget my vote for Waldinger :inquisitive:
Then we have a 3-way tie... ~:rolleyes:
Why not you? You're using this whole thing to put yourself in a very un-scummy light. You talked to the host about it, therefore it couldn't have been you that sent it in right? Sure... :rolleyes:Quote:
Originally Posted by Husar
Regardless, as one of the few votes that actually has any rhyme or reason to it- mine stays.
:inquisitive:Quote:
Originally Posted by Xiahou
You're bouncing off the wall el capitan. I was gauging how you would react. Being proactive and blowing things out of context are two different things my friend. My vote will stay.
Aw, sorry I thought it were you and Andres who tried to make it look like the kill was a joke by the gamehost. :shrug:Quote:
Originally Posted by Xiahou
As one of the votes that has a reason, my vote stays as well. :laugh4:
edit: Maybe we should look in another direction:
Unvote: Xiahou
Vote: pevergreen
Xiahou convinced me in the chat not to vote him, for now...
Unvote: Sarathos, Vote: Xiahou
your first response to someone voting for you sent chills down my spine. It just seemed incredibly scummy.
Voting
------------
Xiahou 3 (ichi, pevergreen, waldinger)
Waldinger 3 (sarathos, caius, shlin)
Ichi 2 (craterus, xiahou)
Sarathos 2(beefy, factionheir)
pevergreen 2 (andres, husar)
Two way tie, quick run off between Xiahou and Waldinger. First to get seven votes dies
My vote stands.
vote: Waldinger
I deem Xiahou to be more innocent than you are.
Awwww!!!! I just want to suicide and get the round over with but I know that my death is a waste of a lynch because I'm innocent.
"I, Waldinger, swear that I am completely innocent. yadayayaya!!!"