Gift: Northnovas (1) Tiberius (1) 3rd not sure yet ...
Printable View
Gift: Northnovas (1) Tiberius (1) 3rd not sure yet ...
Gift: Northnovas(1)
I doubt that the mafia would let each other have 0 presents. Him and Tiberius both recieved 0 presents last round. Tiberius seemed to bandwagon a bit last round. that is why I'm not giving him any presents.
Gift: Kommodus(1)
I want to see this new and improved version of Holmes in action. It was pretty effective in my game.
Gift: Andres(1)
Thanks for all those presents last round but could you explain why you decided to use all three of yours on me when I already had two which meant that I was pretty safe.
Gift Northnovas (1)
agree with woads and fangs logic here
Gift: Kommodus (1)
Have to keep Holmes around
Gift: Woad and Fangs (1)
I think he's inoccent and he dosn't have any presents.
Reasons everyone :yes:
Should we as a town start deciding a lynch? I would favor Factionheir or tiberous for previous scummy behavior. (see my last post)
Ever since I have been mafia once everyone seems to think I'm scummy.
Don't you bandwagoning here yourself?Quote:
Originally Posted by Lord Winter
scummy, scummy...
Think 3rd gift will have CA:
Gift: Northnovas (1) Tiberius (1) CountArach (1)
To a certain extent, isn't bandwagon inevitable at a certain point though? I'm just trying to go off what we have.
I havent fully decide who i want to give the other one to but Ill give
Give: Charge(2) and why do people think Im scummy?
Well at least they don't judge you as scummy as myself because you at least got some presents. I got none :cry:
A very good point. So I believe we can let Northnovas off and consider him innocent.Quote:
I doubt that the mafia would let each other have 0 presents. Him and Tiberius both recieved 0 presents last round. Tiberius seemed to bandwagon a bit last round. that is why I'm not giving him any presents.
Give: Northnovas 1
Give: Woad and Fangs 1
Give: FactionHeir 1
Ive decided to give my last gift.
Give:Andres
What is your oppinion on what is going on?
So one with no presents in R1 is innocent while other is not? Bcs of bandwagon? hmmmm, I really doubt that it can be used as proving someone's guiltiness, it would be veeery risky for them to leave one without gifts, and why do it in round 1?Quote:
Originally posted by CountArachQuote:
Originally posted by woad&fangs
I doubt that the mafia would let each other have 0 presents. Him and Tiberius both recieved 0 presents last round. Tiberius seemed to bandwagon a bit last round. that is why I'm not giving him any presents.
A very good point. So I believe we can let Northnovas off and consider him innocent.
(so we lost 1 guy already :brood:)
We must start something like voting discussion - otherwise almost no chances mafioso will be lynched . If we start it, there is possibility of picking up mafioso as target - they can abandon him or may not, anyway it is better. Though choice should be careful as there are a lot of them too to choose 'wrong' guy..
Who who disagree or will keep silent, are definitely mafiosos
As CA wanting discussion too, I think he's our guy..:)
What do people waiting for?
p.s.
my possible sudden death next night won't help mafia much :D
Tally
Northnovas: 4
Charge: 3
Andres: 3
Kommodus: 2
woad&fangs: 2
Ichigo: 1
FactionHeir: 1
Tiberius of the Drake: 1
CountArach: 1
0:
BSR
Omanes
Draco Leman
kamikhaan
Lord Winter
Peasant Phill
take: Northnovas; Give: Peasant Phill
Give: FactionHeir, Peasant Phill, Lord Winter
Note on the 0 Lord Winter was the only one to vote (give) so far of that group.
Give:Omanes and kamikhaan
Awww, dang!
Its only me and BSR left who have no presents, yet.
Well, I guess that's alright as long as someone gives me one soon.
Give: Lord Winter (1)
Give: BSR (1)
I don't really see the point of giving anymore presents since I couldn't give myself one and everyone else except BSR already has one so it wouldn't make a difference who I give them too.
Which brings me to my first point: Just b/c someone doesn't receive a gift doesn't mean they're innocent, it just means they probably weren't high enough on the mafioso target list or they weren't even on the list to begin with (if they are part of the mafia team). So if everyone had zero or one gift, only the people on the list would get lynched not the mafiosos. But, hey, what do I know?
One final note:
Hmmm, Andres has not posted why he gave woad & fangs 3 presents yet and hasn't given any out and somehow he is still able to receive 3 presents. This does not bode well for the townies if we just randomly give out presents (I know, I'm a hypocrite since my giving is random at this point) or shower people who had zero gifts the previous round with gifts and do all this flip-flopping.
Take: Northnovas Give: Draco Lemen
Thank you for adding your 2 cents to disscusion. I'd rather lynch a lurker then someone who is perticapating for now. Not saying that Northnovas is lurking, I just needed a present from some where.
I was fearing I would be forgotten. Thanks guys.
I have still no clue who to protect or who not to protect (this system requires much more time to stay on top of things.
So give (3): Komodus like last time
Ok, looks like I'm not too late, so...
Give: Ichigo (2)
From what I remember, his instincts and experience are very effective at sniffing out the mafia. Of course, he might be guilty but I'd rather he not be lynched yet.
Give: Charge (1)
For getting some good discussion started.
And finally,
FoS: Peasant Phill
Dude... in W&F's game you were extremely skeptical of me, but now you've given me all your gifts twice in a row (even though I've never been in danger of being lynched). Is it, perhaps, the "safe" way to go, freeing you from having to make any real choices? :inquisitive:
I'm writing at this far too early in the morning, but anyway: votes are closed, I'll tally tomorrow. The night phase has begun ~:)
http://users.on.net/~purdsa/temp/mafiad2.png
kamikhaan has been lynched.
The night phase will end at around 2030 AEST (1030GMT)
:cry:
I died on New Years?
Sorry about my lack of activity over the previous round.
From observations so far, the next round, I strongly advise against protecting Andres. His inquisitorial self has melted away, only posting fairly off-topic remarks. When he does vote, he also fails to supply a reason, which worries me a little.
Charge is another player I am suspicious of. His fairly long post here isn't how I remember him, but then again I've only ever observed him as a mafioso, so I suppose this variation could be explained by that. He also seems to be attempting to place CountArach in the frame with very little evidence - a common mafia tactic.
kamikhaan was lynched even though he had more presents than either WH and shlin? How is that possible?
The former was lynched and the latter was nightkilled (as indicated by the red name up top) :whip:Quote:
Originally Posted by FactionHeir
I'm going to have to partially extend both this night phase, and the next day phase, due firstly to the fact that I don't yet have orders from everyone for this one, and rl commitments for the day phase. I'll let you know the exact times tomorrow ~:)
Oh, soWH wasno one has been night killed this night. (yes)
And khan lynched because the lowest anyone had was 1 present.
d1: WH lynch.
n1: shlin kill.
d2: khaan lynched.
n2: [waiting for orders from some parties and thus not ready to release]
khaan was lynched because of the people on the equal lowest presents (of players alive), he was highest on the mafia's christmas hitlist ~:)
Btw, I had 2 presents, but your table shows me with 1. But its reassuring to know I'm lower on the list :grin:
O! Probably you forgot your previous role here :laugh4: , so far my roles 3/1 town/mafia as you know;Quote:
Originally Posted by Omanes Alexandrapolites
however your suspicion against me and CA, seems very scummy to me. BTW, can you explain 3 gifts you had gave Andres on round 1, and now claiming him mafioso?
I can explain my activity simply bcs I'm townie- I have nothing to hide abd current things are clearly against us..
Sapi, can you make small adjustment to rules - that players can't give double, triple gifts to the same person (eg only 1-1-1)?
that will at least not allow mafia to give each other 3 presents, thus making them unlynchable..
I just cant see how town can get rid of even a single mafioso! :wall:
ah well, I thought it's who stands closer to the left corner of the table :sweatdrop:Quote:
khaan was lynched because of the people on the equal lowest presents (of players alive), he was highest on the mafia's christmas hitlist
Really? I'll have to take more care in counting then :wall:Quote:
Originally Posted by FactionHeir
Charge, I believe that the rules are balanced at this point ~:)
Hmm, interresting, verrrry interresting.Quote:
Originally Posted by sapi
FOS: Andres
Couple reasons: First, Omanes is quite right about Andres' behaviour its quite off. He's acting quite lackadaisical, much like he accidentally did a previous time he was mafia.
Also, because I think he's one of the few people who would target me so highly. I'm honored, Andres.:bow:
Also, thanks, Sapi, for proving my innocence.:beam: