Capo de Tutti Capi - II [Concluded]

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by norwegian nerd

Well seeing as I only can only really trust 2 people, my self and my buddy. And that neither of us are really gaining any support voting does nothing. The only other person I have RP'd with is countarach though I have no reason to trust him over anyone else. So I will not vote for I have no reason to vote for anyone only a reason not to vote.

---

What makes you think you can trust your buddy? Are the two of you the same person?

Select: Kommodus

I don't think this is really that big of a decision. All we're doing is protecting someone from night kills for two night phases. I think Kommodus is a good choice because

A) If he's a townie it's in our best interest to keep him alive.

B) If he's mafia, this puts him in the spotlight where he might slip up. :yes:

Aye, the seat of the director is a crown of thorns.

When you post here in this thread, it is like viewing a harbour, plain and vast - quite peaceful and welcoming - but home to a great amount of activity and secrets that go very deep beyond the surface.

A paranoid feeling.

Select: Husar

Because... he is a likeable chap. :2thumbsup:

select: Andres

He seems less crafty than GH.

Kommodus isn't a bad choice, but I wonder how useful Holmes will be in this game.

CR

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Pannonian

What makes you think you can trust your buddy? Are the two of you the same person?

---

I would be foolish not to trust the one person I know I can trust.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by norwegian nerd

I would be foolish not to trust the one person I know I can trust.

---

So how do you know you can trust him? Have the two of you compared role PMs?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Pannonian

So how do you know you can trust him? Have the two of you compared role PMs?

---

I know I can trust him because the gamemaster told me I could trust him and if I don't trust the gamemaster there isn't much point in playing a game of mafia.
What makes you belive I shouldn't trust him?

Guys, methinks we've found our first lynch. Post 68 in case he edits it out.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by norwegian nerd

I know I can trust him because the gamemaster told me I could trust him and if I don't trust the gamemaster there isn't much point in playing a game of mafia. What makes you belive I shouldn't trust him?

---

Norwegian, why don't I buy you some red and some white paint, and then you stand still while I draw with my brush, a nice wide bullseye on your chest?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Glenn

Norwegian, why don't I buy you some red and some white paint, and then you stand still while I draw with my brush, a nice wide bullseye on your chest?

---

Well you are welcome to buy me paint though I don't see myself painting a bullseye on my chest.

@Panonnian, why so quick for a lynch? Trying to take the heat off your own guilty conciensce?

Come on lads, no jumping on new players. Give Norwegian a chance.

However, Norwegian, I am afraid the one thing that can save you now is for your buddy to step forward, or for you to name him. Knowing a fair bit about how mafia games are played here, I think this is the only thing that will keep you alive anymore. Sorry, sucks to be new.

Norweigian, sorry to say this, but you're just asking to get killed on the first day even if you happen to be innocent

As for the director, I don't really care mainly because I don't think the director of the first day or so can really make a difference unless it becomes blatantly obvious that a certain group of people are constantly wanting one individual to be the director to protect him

Select: RoadKill

Seriously. When was the last time I was mafia. Thats right never.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by norwegian nerd

Well you are welcome to buy me paint though I don't see myself painting a bullseye on my chest.

@Panonnian, why so quick for a lynch? Trying to take the heat off your own guilty conciensce?

---

Well, given the roles in the game, I'd guess that you're a Made gangster, and the buddy whom the gamesmaster told you you can trust is your Don. Or perhaps you're the Luca in the family. You're not the Don, as the Don would know the IDs of his Luca and his 2 Mades.

If my buddy would like to post hist name his welcome to though that is his choice, for if you truly belive me to be mafia then for him to be my buddy he must also be mafia so if I reveleded my buddy then I would give you a second lynch target which is unfair to him if he does not so wish to reveal himself.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Pannonian

Well, given the roles in the game, I'd guess that you're a Made gangster, and the buddy whom the gamesmaster told you you can trust is your Don. Or perhaps you're the Luca in the family. You're not the Don, as the Don would know the IDs of his Luca and his 2 Mades.

---

or i could be a simple tonwie with just a good buddy?

I think that I'll Select: GH as it's the first day

Given the roles in the game, I'd say he was Romeo, and he speaks of Juliet, (Or Julian - ha!), or something similar.

In any case, Seamus will probably wince when he reads what Norwegian wrote, and we can all be safe in the knowledge there is at least one hidden agenda out there.

HOWEVER.

Being a junior member, there could be something more sinister here if he is another member who changed identity just for this game.
Or he could be a junior member who was very quick to take to the role of Serial Killer.

So, it would be well advised not to vote for him, as he will either be a pitied new member who ruined his role, or a Serial Killer who will thwart you.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by norwegian nerd

If my buddy would like to post hist name his welcome to though that is his choice, for if you truly belive me to be mafia then for him to be my buddy he must also be mafia so if I reveleded my buddy then I would give you a second lynch target which is unfair to him if he does not so wish to reveal himself.

---

:daisy:

meh, select: FactionHeir
Who else.

Select: Kommodus

Even though there's no way of confirming his innocence, I'd rather elect someone who if innocent will do the Town good than someone completely random.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Pannonian

Well, given the roles in the game, I'd guess that you're a Made gangster, and the buddy whom the gamesmaster told you you can trust is your Don. Or perhaps you're the Luca in the family. You're not the Don, as the Don would know the IDs of his Luca and his 2 Mades.

---

I'd be willing to bet all the family members know one another, so saying he knows one other person who he can trust is hardly a reason for thinking he is mafia. Just seems like a wrong assumption to me. :shrug:

Select: Kommodus

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Glenn

There is no need for all this suspicion as of yet!

Criminals are going to slip through in any case in the first round - certainly, and it is a common fault in previous games for people to spend far too long gazing into the words of others for clues when it is impossible to tell friend from foe.

Sasaki, Andres, the General, Myrddraal, and the likes of these are prime candidates because nobody else is known to the public - and no one of them can be labelled any more suspicious than any of the 70 people playing.

However, I am going to recede slightly, as I don't want feuds and bitterness to begin over this simple argument.

Finally, Scottishranger, the Stranger is right - if you praise and support GeneralHankerchief in the way you have done, simply because of his idea to help the Townsfolk, you deceive yourself as readily as though who suspect everyone too easily.

---

Meh, did you read the rest of the post, it does not really matter who is the director. Yes, it gives them immunity for a few days, but then again, so does just not posting for a few days in such a large game. No one will really notice, nor care.

I am fine with whoever being the director. As I have never participated in such a large game or even a game at the org, I do not know the particular tendencies of your players.

Unvote: General

Select: Sasaki
Why not? :shrug:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ichigo

I'd be willing to bet all the family members know one another, so saying he knows one other person who he can trust is hardly a reason for thinking he is mafia. Just seems like a wrong assumption to me. :shrug:

---

Looking at the rules, in particular those for the succession when the Don is dead, it does imply that the Mades (of whom the Luca is one) know each other, unless they are kept in the dark at the start and only informed by Seamus when the time comes. We could ask GH about this, as it would relate to his previous game's experience and not this game's, and thus it wouldn't be technically breaking any rules. Perhaps Seamus can clarify this point.

One option would be for norwegian's buddy to step up, for both of them to state their roles and their relation to each other, and for us to lynch one of them. If the investigation proves they were telling the truth, then the other will be a confirmed pro-townie who can be protected for the rest of the game. And given that players are supposed to play for a team win, sacrificing one townie in order to guarantee the innocence of the other should be a price worth paying, especially since townies can upgrade once they've participated in enough night actions.

But if norwegian is unwilling to open up, then the best course would be to lynch him, given what we know of the game.

Norwegian.... Count Arach would not happen to be this friend of yours, would he?

You are not a new player, given your previous posts on the forum here, but have joined for the sake of playing Mafia.
So you do know more than it was first reckoned, and you also, rightfully, should know better than to so blatantly hint at your role.

I don't credit anything you have said, and I shall not vote for you on any matter.


Pannonian, the odds of him being a Serial Killer are as even as any, if he were one, and an intelligent one, he would act in a way which would have him surely lynched.

No countarch is not my buddy, He posted on a differnt forum to gauge interst in this mafia game
http://z2.invisionfree.com/herdstone...howtopic=13625 True, I joined to play mafia but you can ask Countarch how often we play mafia on the forum I came from.

As to my buddy, it is not my place to say.

Hey :)

I got interested in playing Mafia from reading two of general handkerchiefs mafia games.

So Select:GeneralHandkerchief.

Joe