Writeups may not be that good, but I'm getting through em.
Split's writeup is now up. You can also access them from the opening post.
Tuuvi's writeup is now done.
Riedquat's is now done as well. I will do the other three later tonight.
Printable View
Writeups may not be that good, but I'm getting through em.
Split's writeup is now up. You can also access them from the opening post.
Tuuvi's writeup is now done.
Riedquat's is now done as well. I will do the other three later tonight.
The write-ups are horrible.
Day over. Orders in. The rest of the write ups will be done later tonight. Sleep tight. :evilgrin:
White_Eyes:D death is now up. 3 more to go. And Seon has been lynched.
Tally:
2 Arjos (Seon, Salmonsoil)
3 Seon (ATPG, Arjos, DaveShack
2 Nightbringer (LazyMcCrow, BSmith)
Alive 8/17:
1. SalmonSoil
2. LazyMcCrow
4. Arjos
7. Nightbringer
8. Jarrema
9. DaveShack
12. Askthepizzaguy
16. BSmith
Dead 8/17:
5. Monty: Lynched Day 1
15. Lewwyn: Killed Night 1
14. Splitpersonality: Lynched Day 2
10. Tuuvi: Killed Night 2
3. Riedquat: Lynched Day 3
13. White_Eyes:D: Killed Night 3
11. Kagemusha: Lynched Day 4
6. Atheotes: Killed Night 4
17. Seon: Lynched Day 5
What'd I tell you quackers? There was a psychiatrist, and you killed him.Quote:
The town did just that, and at the end of the day, the sheriff announced that Splitpersonality was the chosen lynch target, “Well, would you look at that, the psychiatrist is a murderer then. Alright then, get him.” Split, named so for his ability to get into the mind of any person in the town, was quickly grabbed and dragged onto the podium. Scrambling he tried to break free, but the deputy had him in his grip.
Not only that, but the Sheriff is clearly scum, a Serial Killer. He would have activated once you took out the scum team, but now he'll just win as shadow scum without killing anyone because there's no way you are getting the next (and last) three lynches all right.
GIVE IT UP, SHEEP. YOU CANT PROTECT YOURSELVES.
YOU ARE WEAK.
:no:
Let me ask you something, who prescribed to you the drugs you are using, the deceased psychiatrist or was me? I don't remember but eh, I don't remember being a doctor while alive either... anyway, if you could share a bit of that...
Call it morbid curiosity.
Who should we lynch, Monty mah boy?
Whatt????Quote:
Originally Posted by Montmorency
Don't mock me, Sheriff!Quote:
Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy
I have a strong feeling that Salmonsoil and BSmith are innocent, while Crow and Pizza are clearly enemies.
:bow:
And if you should be wrong, would you then be eating Crow?
*big fake laughter*
Sorry for my absence everyone. To make up for it, here is my grand achievement! A compilation of the voting histories for everyone's convenience, color coded to show who is still alive.
On an unrelated note, I find it interesting that ATPG has placed such emphasis on saying he has never lurkde as a mafia, while also emphasizing that he has only lurked because of extenuating circumstances.
I'm not claiming it is an act, but could he be using IRL circumstances to strengthen his claim to innocence by doing this?Quote:
Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy
Day 1:
Monty: 2 (ATPG, Tuuvi)
ATPG: 1 (split)
Nightbringer: 1 (Monty)
White Eyes: 1 (Lazy)
Lewwyn: 1 (Salmonsoil)
Split: 1 (Arjos)
Lazy: 2 (Bsmith, Nightbringer)
Atheotes: 1 (Riedquat)
Salmonsoil: 1 (Lewwyn)
Arjos: 1 (Jarrema)
Day 2:
Tally:
Kage: 1 (ATPG)
Seon: 2 (Lazy, edse)
Salmon: 2 (Daveshack, Split)
Split: 3 (Kagemusha, Jarema, Nightbringer)
Jarrema: 1 (Riedquat)
Atheotes: 1 (Arjos)
Nightbringer: 2 (BSmith, Atheotes)
ATPG: 1 (Tuuvi)
Daveshack: 1 (Salmon)
Day 3:
White_Eyes:D: 4 (edse, Arjos, atheotes, LazyMcCrow)
Riedquat: 4 (Seon, SalmonSoil, Jarema, White_Eyes:D)
Nightbringer: 1 (Riedquat)
atheotes: 1 (Nightbringer)
Day 4:
Nightbringer: 2 (LazyMcCrow, BSmith)
Kagemusha: 3 (Arjos, Seon, atheotos)
Day 5:
Tally:
Arjos: 2 (Seon, Salmonsoil)
Seon: 3 (ATPG, Arjos, DaveShack
Nightbringer: 2 (LazyMcCrow, BSmith)
Currently:
Alive 8/17:
1. SalmonSoil
2. LazyMcCrow
4. Arjos
7. Nightbringer
8. Jarrema
9. DaveShack
12. Askthepizzaguy
16. BSmith
Dead 8/17:
5. Monty: Lynched Day 1
15. Lewwyn: Killed Night 1
14. Splitpersonality: Lynched Day 2
10. Tuuvi: Killed Night 2
3. Riedquat: Lynched Day 3
13. White_Eyes:D: Killed Night 3
11. Kagemusha: Lynched Day 4
6. Atheotes: Killed Night 4
17. Seon: Lynched Day 5
Rhetorical question, or do you have an opinion on it yourself?Quote:
Originally Posted by Nightbringer
I've been posting more as my RL circumstances have made it possible to do so. I'm not sure what relevance it has as to my guilt or innocence. Activity due to RL does not affect what role I was randed, I agree with that much. But why is that your focus?
Am I or am I not guilty? State a position.
I don't feel I know how you normally act well enough to judge, it just seems odd (meaning guilty) to me that you are going through so much effort to explain your absence. Following this by stating that you are always active as mafia makes ti seem to me like you might be using your RL absence to alleviate suspicion that you are mafia. Why else go through so much work when there wasn't much pressure on you?Quote:
Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy
Basically, it feels like an overreaction to small pressure on you.
HE'S THE SHERIFF
How do we know this?Quote:
Originally Posted by Montmorency
In response to his, the first point is quite valid, although on day 1 I think it is hard to make anything of votes. As to #2, I always over-explain things and make myself look scummy.Quote:
Originally Posted by BSmith
Reading too much into my behavior. I always respond to direct inquiry or suspicion. I don't duck it and pretend I'm not here. It's also not a lot of work for someone like me. I've written more text than some well-known novels simply hosting games, and my walls-o-text are legendary. I haven't actually lifted more than a finger in this game.Quote:
Originally Posted by Nightbringer
It seems weird to me that you'd describe my behavior in this manner, when it doesn't begin to take into account who I am. A generic case made against someone who is hardly generic strikes me as sloppy.
To turn the line of inquiry around, you dropped off in activity and haven't done much actual scum-hunting, only to return for the middle-endgame with a case that doesn't make sense to me. There's just the slightest, faintest hint of poo in the air.
And what's with this "I find it interesting" stuff?
Good lord, man... townies should never phrase things this way. It gives me the creeps.
Well, I haven't played in quite a while, and never really played much, so I don't really know the intricacies of how you play. All I am doing is trying to point out things I see, and let players who are more competent see if there is anything of worth in it. That is why I phrased it as a question.Quote:
Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy
As to my drop off in activity, I forgot to come check over here when going on the .org. I got used to pms reminding me of things I forgot in hotseat games so once this game slipped my mind it took me a few days to remember.
:inquisitive:Quote:
Good lord, man... townies should never phrase things this way. It gives me the creeps.
Mafia can make all the blunders they like. :wink:
Kage writeup is now up.
Atheotes writeup is up.
Okay, I'm only behind on two writeups now. :tongue:
Nightbringer has been killed. Begin Day Six.
Alive 7/17:
1. SalmonSoil
2. LazyMcCrow
4. Arjos
8. Jarrema
9. DaveShack
12. Askthepizzaguy
16. BSmith
Dead 9/17:
5. Monty: Lynched Day 1
15. Lewwyn: Killed Night 1
14. Splitpersonality: Lynched Day 2
10. Tuuvi: Killed Night 2
3. Riedquat: Lynched Day 3
13. White_Eyes:D: Killed Night 3
11. Kagemusha: Lynched Day 4
6. Atheotes: Killed Night 4
17. Seon: Lynched Day 5
7. Nightbringer: Killed Night 5
We have two shots left, if we didn't hit any of them so far.
5:2 -1 (lynch) = 4:2 -1 (murder) 3:2, (lynch or lose)
Vote: Arjos
9 posts, one vote per round, votes every round. Indicates he's very interested in the game, not so much interested in discussing who needs to die.
Just shows up to kill someone, then leaves. I don't get a whole lot of townie vibe from that. But there's more:
Votes Split due to name, not a real reason, which presents nothing to argue against.Quote:
Originally Posted by Arjos
Votes Atheotes for being quiet. Hard to argue with that, but atheotes is always like that.Quote:
Originally Posted by Arjos
Easy target.Quote:
Originally Posted by Arjos
Easy target. Nothing to argue against here.Quote:
Originally Posted by Arjos
Everyone Arjos voted for is dead. Not many comments made against anyone else left alive. Essentially, Arjos has the dreaded Mafia ESP.Quote:
Originally Posted by Arjos
Main criticism I have is that everything that Arjos presents as a reason, or non-reason, for his vote are simple statements which refer to facts, but do not argue why someone is scum. It goes right from the fact to the conclusion.
Split's name references mental illness- conclusion, he's scum.
Atheotes is quiet- conclusion, he's scum.
WE avoids WOG- conclusion, he's scum.
Kagemusha agrees about WE voting, WE murdered - conclusion, he's scum.
Seon's vote moved- conclusion, he's scum.
None of these things are arguable points, except the conclusion. Since there was no reasoning presented, there's nothing to debate.
That, plus the fact that Arjos hasn't commented on pretty much anyone besides the folks he's voted for, votes every round but doesn't move his vote and doesn't contribute to the discussion, tells me that Arjos has a motive of killing folks one by one, doesn't want to argue or debate about the voted candidate, doesn't want to leave himself open for criticism due to his own votes, and possibly indicates a nervous/guilty psychological state which spans the entire game.
Arjos is not behaving like everyone else, and it doesn't feel natural to me either. In my opinion, his reasoning and behavior both serve as concrete evidence of a guilty psychology. As such, he must be eliminated before we can continue.
I would vote for him if I could ATPG.
In any case, I think it unlikely ATPG is scum at this point. Killing me was likely done to try to incriminate him since I was trying to target him. Unless it is a double bluff, but that can just go on forever.
Of course, the scum also dislikes activity, so maybe I was killed off just for starting to speak, whether it was because I had anything good to say, or just because I got other people to react, meaning more activity in general. This would support the scum being apparently inactive people.
ok
I do not have enough psychic energy left to think now.
As a placeholder vote, that will stay if I have no better idea, vote: Arjos
Who has any case on day one?Quote:
Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy
As I said, I can't tell what they are up to, just writes vote: x and disappears...Quote:
Atheotes is quiet- conclusion, he's scum.
Very oversimplified: he voted hours past the end, with the most flimsy reasonining I've ever read...Quote:
WE avoids WOG- conclusion, he's scum.
People agreeing on silly stuff, do that for an easy way out: for example Diana agreed about lynching you as host in Darkling...Quote:
Kagemusha agrees about WE voting, WE murdered - conclusion, he's scum.
Again, he unvoted many times basically with the only reason: "oh goodie, a wagon!"...Quote:
Seon's vote moved- conclusion, he's scum.
I commented on your off-character behaviour and since then you've been more active for a start...Quote:
That, plus the fact that Arjos hasn't commented on pretty much anyone besides the folks he's voted for
But if you want to know more:
- Crow and BSmith are a merry stubborn duo, whole game all they wanted was Nightbringer dead; what that makes them I don't know, usually townies are narrow sighted and adamant...
- Salmon, I've played with him only once, can hardly point out a pattern...
- Jarema and DS are pretty much giving concise reasons about their votes and then split, just like me, what does that makes us? Active players posting their views behind their votes, people open to arguments or mafia? Don't know, that's the game...
- ATPG, wasn't ATPG, now he survived 'til mid-game and wants me dead...
Could really the openly united duo being a mafia duo? Is bloodlust Salmon one of the vets? Are any of those blending in (Arjos, Jarema and DS) mafia? Is ATPG working on the fact that there haven't been many arguments in the game so far, exploiting it for the "last phases somewhat valid" argument to lynch opponents?
Hell I know! Who am I, the source of all knowledge? XD
I take great pleasure from that :)Quote:
Arjos is not behaving like everyone else, and it doesn't feel natural to me either.
In the end, can't really say whether you lurked or not...
Monty lately has a thing about getting lynched on day 1 as mafia and he wants you dead, but gah...
Vote: DaveShack
Of all people, he voted only twice in intervals to avoid the 3 in a row rule and with the following reasons: there's still chaos and this is better than the other case...
Among all, he's the one striking me as the "nothing here, vote elsewhere"...
Blatant spam: Hall of fame.... 2011.... be there or be nowhere.
Visor, perhaps a round extension would be in order, if we don't get more voters. This is nuts.
Daveshack is incredibly quiet, with only 3 posts, one of which is his sign up, however this seems way to dangerous for a scum, and seeing as we really need to lynch scum right now I can't vote for him.
I agree that Arjos seems a bit suspicious, but actually ATPG's argument on this page grabs my attention more. Using Arjos's day one vote, which was nothing out of the ordinary, as part of an effort to incriminate him. Seems like he is trying really hard to make his argument appear stronger just by piling up 'evidence'.
As Nightbringer said, his own death could be intended to either incriminate of prove innocent ATPG.
vote: ATPG
FoS: SalmonSoil for using WIFOM as an actual argument for a lynch. :rolleyes:Quote:
Originally Posted by SalmonSoil
It's always hilarious when people use this sort of non-reasoning.Quote:
Originally Posted by SalmonSoil
A better argument would be, "Pizza is the Sheriff, and th Sheriff is an SK, so I should vote him."
Wait, non-reasoning, what? I was referring to what Nightbringer said. Nightbringer said he was probably killed to incriminate Pizza, or it could be a bluff to draw attention away from Pizza. That was what I was trying to say, Nightbringers murder is neither conclusive evidence for or against Pizza being scum, and is thus not reason enough to disregard him as a suspect.Quote:
Originally Posted by Montmorency
In other words, it doesn't mean anything?
It's a counter argument in advance, I wanted to explain why I disregarded that event.Quote:
Originally Posted by Montmorency
The way the post was structured made it seem as if that was the rationale behind the vote.
:bow:
Vote: Arjos
Self-preservation, and the pizza dude's analysis makes sense.
Forgot to bold. Vote: Arjos
For shame. :shame:
Round extended by 24 hours.
Apologies afk for the entire weekend, many thanks for the extension.Quote:
Originally Posted by Visorslash
But why is the lynch bait killed every time?
vote: ATPG
Beg your pardon. Can you elaborate on who is or has been lynch bait?Quote:
Originally Posted by LazyMcCrow
I know you didn't just do a flyby and leave. Finish your thought, if you would please.
Do you know what? I could, but it actually doesn't matter. You are mafia and so is Arjos. He is taking one for the team in order to get you through the final day.
<object style="height: 390px; width: 640px"><param name="movie" value="https://www.youtube.com/v/1ytCEuuW2_A?version=3&feature=player_detailpage"><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"><param name="allowScriptAccess" value="always"><embed src="https://www.youtube.com/v/1ytCEuuW2_A?version=3&feature=player_detailpage" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowfullscreen="true" allowScriptAccess="always" width="640" height="360"></object>Quote:
Originally Posted by LazyMcCrow
Couldn't resist.
:) Good answer.Quote:
Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy
Incidentally, I have more of a history of supporting teammates lately. I refer you to Giraffeboards where I, as mafia, argued against the lynch of my entirely deadweight and completely useless *inactive* mafia partner, on a team of four, because I argued, he was most likely going to be an inactive townie. I also didn't bus my two active partners either. I could have gained creds from lynching him and him flipping scum, but I decided having the extra partner to count toward outnumbering the town was more advantageous.
Bussing is a bit predictable, but even worse, it gains me nothing especially in this situation; I would gain no townie cred from lynching Arjos-as-scum, as scum, because it's a no reveal game. I could have chosen not to support it, especially in such a low-voting situation. I could have gone after DaveShack or yourself or whatever.
In theory, if I am mafia, Arjos isn't my partner. Who would be the next person on the list you'd suspect of that?
Also, I see you lurking, Monty. Nothing to add to this discussion, you crazy corpse?
I'm online now, but I almost always leave my PC running.
Just to throw people off?
Anyway, the game is already lost. Pizza, Crow, and Daveshack are the scum.
WOOOOT!!! I WIN AGAIN, BABY!!!Quote:
Originally Posted by Montmorency
wait, three?
Sheri-i-i-i-i-i-i-f!
Daveshack. So that...makes... him innocent?Quote:
Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy
I'm not sure what that makes him, to be honest.Quote:
Originally Posted by LazyMcCrow
There's such a lack of discussion on this extra day, that I'm willing to discuss who my pretend mafia partner is and who it most likely would be, out of sheer boredom.
Yeah. I think it is you and Daveshack. Be back in an hour or so. I must go play King of Tokyo.Quote:
Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy
Day over. Arjos lynched.
Begin Night Six.
Alive 6/17:
1. SalmonSoil
2. LazyMcCrow
8. Jarrema
9. DaveShack
12. Askthepizzaguy
16. BSmith
Dead 10/17:
5. Monty: Lynched Day 1
15. Lewwyn: Killed Night 1
14. Splitpersonality: Lynched Day 2
10. Tuuvi: Killed Night 2
3. Riedquat: Lynched Day 3
13. White_Eyes:D: Killed Night 3
11. Kagemusha: Lynched Day 4
6. Atheotes: Killed Night 4
17. Seon: Lynched Day 5
7. Nightbringer: Killed Night 5
4. Arjos: Lynched Day 6
DaveShack, we've been outed, buddy.Quote:
Originally Posted by LazyMcCrow
I recommend you kill him with the machete tonight, I'll do the honors of playing the bagpipes at his funeral.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Visorslash
ON SNAP, PIZZA WINS AGAIN!!! WOOOT WOOT WOOOOOT
Play the freaking victoly music.
I am an unstoppable mafia GOD!!!!
Oh noes, foiled by my own maths. Better lynch me. :shame: The shame, the shame.Quote:
Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy
Now I must do the pouty face.
<object style="height: 390px; width: 640px"><param name="movie" value="https://www.youtube.com/v/yWDQjoXYgOo?version=3&feature=player_detailpage"><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"><param name="allowScriptAccess" value="always"><embed src="https://www.youtube.com/v/yWDQjoXYgOo?version=3&feature=player_detailpage" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowfullscreen="true" allowScriptAccess="always" width="640" height="360"></object>
We all know your WIFOM is huge pizza, you can stop waving it about now. :)
As to the actual vote, I have no idea, there is so little to go off. Maybe go after lurkers?
Now I see Nightbringer lurking.
NB, what are your thoughts on the remaining alive people?
Holy Hivemind, Batman.
I need to get to sleep, i'll share them during the day tomorrow.
Works for me. I have a feeling I will need someone to talk constructively with, because I sense that tomorrow will be a beat up on pizza fest.Quote:
Originally Posted by Nightbringer
Wait, am I? <checks PMs> Umm, nope. Not saying a lot -- check. Plain vanilla me, as usual. :bow:
Stupid forum won't let you imbed stuff bracketed byandCode:<
. It was supposed to include aCode:>
. :wall:Code:<checks PMs>
Dammit, that didn't work either. :wall: :wall:
If the forum won't let you inbreed "stuff" against bars, it's for good reason...Quote:
Originally Posted by DaveShack
Alive 6/17:
1. SalmonSoil
2. LazyMcCrow
8. Jarrema
9. DaveShack
12. Askthepizzaguy
16. BSmith
Here is my opinion:
Salmon = possible scum, idk really.
Lazy = unlikely scum, he was too stubbornly against me and was verbose about it. He wasn't just using my lynch baityness, he was really going after me, which seems like more of a townie move.
Jarrema = Seems normal enough to me.
Dave = strikes me as just inactive, rather than lurking
ATPG = THE WIFOM! He is being ATPG, which could mean anything, but the level of WIFOM seems like an unnecessary risk for a scumbag, even if they are determined to be active.
BSmith = I think he is a good possibility. He seems to have been lurking to me. He started off quite, just voting without any real additional text. Nice and uncontroversial, especially since I was pretty much lynch bait. And since I died, he has dropped off the map. Does he now lack anyone who is easy to target?
Here is his post history if anyone is interested.
Quote:
Originally Posted by BSmith
Quote:
Originally Posted by BSmith
Quote:
Originally Posted by BSmith
Quote:
Originally Posted by BSmith
Quote:
Originally Posted by BSmith
Quote:
Originally Posted by BSmith
That is your analysis? Are you serious? :stare:Quote:
Originally Posted by Nightbringer
I accidentally hit post instead of go advanced. :wall:Quote:
Originally Posted by Riedquat
Sorry then, I was thinking you were stealing my thoughts :clown:Quote:
Originally Posted by Nightbringer
I for one appreciate the analysis Nighty and actually agree with it for the most part.Quote:
Originally Posted by Nightbringer
BSmith has been killed. Begin Day Seven.
Alive 5/17:
1. SalmonSoil
2. LazyMcCrow
8. Jarrema
9. DaveShack
12. Askthepizzaguy
Dead 12/17:
5. Monty: Lynched Day 1
15. Lewwyn: Killed Night 1
14. Splitpersonality: Lynched Day 2
10. Tuuvi: Killed Night 2
3. Riedquat: Lynched Day 3
13. White_Eyes:D: Killed Night 3
11. Kagemusha: Lynched Day 4
6. Atheotes: Killed Night 4
17. Seon: Lynched Day 5
7. Nightbringer: Killed Night 5
4. Arjos: Lynched Day 6
16. BSmith: Killed Night Six
Time you posted something super-townie, pizza - like the previous days?
vote: SalmonSoil
Bout friggin time.Quote:
Originally Posted by LazyMcCrow
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nightbringer
Well that pretty much blows your theory out of the water. :yes:Quote:
Originally Posted by Visorslash
I’m usually pretty quiet in the beginning of games. That coupled with weekends being bad for me and posting means that I missed a couple of Day phases this game, including the last one. Yesterday was Night and I didn’t have much to add to the discussion, so I just didn’t post. I’m not one for spamming up things.
Do you mind my asking why?Quote:
Originally Posted by LazyMcCrow
I'm tellin ya', you've lost the game: too much scum to go around.
Don't mind at all. My vote on you is because I'm fairly sure that 'lurky' Daveshack is as innocent as I am, which leaves two out of the remaining three of you need lynching asap. Moreover - Your polite enquiry does nothing at all in my mind to exhonorate you - merely adds more kindling to the fire. Who do YOU think is scum?Quote:
Originally Posted by SalmonSoil