Family Guy Mafia - The Teddy Snatcher [Concluded]

Fine

Vote:ATPG


Unless of course you're playing the character of death, and everyone who votes for you dies... Or some other cruddy mechanism.

Yoyoma, that's at least creative thinking.

What would Death's role be in this game, I wonder. Vigilante or mafia I'd suspect.

Beefy, please explain your reasoning further. I would like to know how it makes no sense to make a mafia survive a lynch, or have an ability dealing with lynches. In fact, how do you know that ATPG in fact is only saying it will not be wasted? Are you sure that the ability he is saying he has will let him live through it? I mean, honestly, he could ACTUALLY BE LYING about what his ability does.

Cool! Only problem is I'd be dead.

LOL

So? We have no clue as to the nature of the mafia this game, so it's best not to draw conclusion about a topic you do not fully know about, otherwise you will make stupid mistakes. The town is allotted 24 hours to discuss things for a lynch, it can use that time to seriously scrutinize all available data from all available players. And I want Beefy to answer my question, now, or he better be working on "Noble Sons" :brood:

Answer me Beefy, answer me without having another speak up for you.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy

Cool! Only problem is I'd be dead.

LOL

---

I think ATPG is Death.....only way he could survive a lynch or killing.....:juggle2:
My role is

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

..........I am not saying for fear of YLC....:clown:

Edit: weird how your asking for a defending role then.....might you be kidnapped still???:grin:

Coward, I'll find out one way or another when I make you squeal :evilgrin:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by YLC

Beefy, please explain your reasoning further. I would like to know how it makes no sense to make a mafia survive a lynch, or have an ability dealing with lynches. In fact, how do you know that ATPG in fact is only saying it will not be wasted? Are you sure that the ability he is saying he has will let him live through it? I mean, honestly, he could ACTUALLY BE LYING about what his ability does.

---

If he indeed have a ability to survive a lynch then he cannot be mafia.. Because how else is are the towns supposed to take out the mafia if he cannot be lynched?

Also if he dies then good.. We have one mafia down.. If not one very unhelpful townie gone

If he lives then we clearly knows one player is innocent don't we?

I think its far more better to lynch ATPG then lynch some random... who could be detective or something.

If we don't lynch ATPG now and he ends up being a mafia... :no:

BTW YLC.. I need confirmation of your battle plans. Unless you sent me already and completely forgot about it

Oh and I wasn't working on noble sons... I was on facebook:clown:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Beefy187

If he indeed have a ability to survive a lynch then he cannot be mafia.. Because how else is are the towns supposed to take out the mafia if he cannot be lynched?

Also if he dies then good.. We have one mafia down.. If not one very unhelpful townie gone

If he lives then we clearly knows one player is innocent don't we?

I think its far more better to lynch ATPG then lynch some random... who could be detective or something.

If we don't lynch ATPG now and he ends up being a mafia... :no:

---

It would be great if everyone read this post. It's about the joys of using reason.

EDIT: I remind you this gambit doesn't work very well if I don't get a defender covering my butt tonight when it's murder time.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Beefy187

If he indeed have a ability to survive a lynch then he cannot be mafia.. Because how else is are the towns supposed to take out the mafia if he cannot be lynched?

Also if he dies then good.. We have one mafia down.. If not one very unhelpful townie gone

If he lives then we clearly knows one player is innocent don't we?

I think its far more better to lynch ATPG then lynch some random... who could be detective or something.

If we don't lynch ATPG now and he ends up being a mafia... :no:

BTW YLC.. I need confirmation of your battle plans. Unless you sent me already and completely forgot about it

---

It's possible he can survive a lynch, but only once. There are strategic and gameplay and mechanics reasons for the possible inclusion of such an ability, so do not come to such quick judgments.

Not always does death reveal, so do not feel comfortably without true utter confirmation from the host.

And I sent those battle plans a log time ago, along with my orders concerning Sara.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by YLC

It's possible he can survive a lynch, but only once. There are strategic and gameplay and mechanics reasons for the possible inclusion of such an ability, so do not come to such quick judgments.

Not always does death reveal, so do not feel comfortably without true utter confirmation from the host.

And I sent those battle plans a log time ago, along with my orders concerning Sara.

---

Well so far I seen mafias who can survive vigilante kills but never a lynch.

Also Dont know what "death" is as I havnt seen family guy.. :shame:

Regarding orders.. Copy that. I shall work on it soon as I can :2thumbsup:

In the PMs we got from Aries I think at least one of the Mafia have a ability set up like this

Quote:

---

objective: make the most out of your innocence

overall analysis
lynch defense: 80%
mafia defense: 70%
extra ability: Kill one player each night

---

My guess is Pizza guy is testing his luck:beam: (and those are not my scores or ability's, I edited it of course:2thumbsup:)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by White_eyes:D

In the PMs we got from Aries I think at least one of the Mafia have a ability set up like this



My guess is Pizza guy is testing his luck:beam: (and those are not my scores or ability's, I edited it of course:2thumbsup:)

---

That's a very clever assumption.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Why would the mafia have "mafia defense" though? You have 70% as the entry there.

Your post made me go back and look at my role, and apparently I didn't read the damn thing properly. I don't have the ability to survive one lynch. I have the ability to survive infinite lynches.

Well now I look both guilty and like a jackass. :shame:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy

That's a very clever assumption.
Why would the mafia have "mafia defense" though? You have 70% as the entry there.

---

Why do you think I put it there?:clown:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Because I knew you would notice it......:grin:.....now the question is, am I innocent or Mafia?:smash:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by White_eyes:D

Why do you think I put it there?:clown:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Because I knew you would notice it......:grin:.....now the question is, am I innocent or Mafia?:smash:

---

I don't buy it. I think you were just giving examples. The odds still favor innocent, but one of us is guilty and I know it's not me. Lynch me and you'll know.

We could always lynch you afterwards and see how that claim of yours holds up, too. Worst case, we prove two people are innocent. Best case, we kill a mafia.



Edit; by the way I had that "death incarnate" title since YLC's resident evil game. I'm not "Death".

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy

I don't buy it. I think you were just giving examples. The odds still favor innocent, but one of us is guilty and I know it's not me. Lynch me and you'll know.

We could always lynch you afterwards and see how that claim of yours holds up, too. Worst case, we prove two people are innocent. Best case, we kill a mafia.



Edit; by the way I had that "death incarnate" title since YLC's resident evil game. I'm not "Death".

---

How do we know that? how else can someone survive a lynch? and how do you know that one of us is guilty? I could have made a mistake on the example and leaked some of my ability's you know:clown:

Quiet White Eyes, about things you seem to be willing to be ignorant of. I will say I feel like ATPG is Steward though, and such a role would be fitting for him too.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by YLC

I feel like ATPG is Steward though

---

I have to wonder why he would steal teddy bears though.....but then again this is family guy so....:shrug:

edit: if the Mafia has the defender or role blocker on his side you are screwed....(I hope you make it though this round Pizza Guy because I am starting to get the impression that your innocent because by the sounds of things your ability's are like mine....):smash:

Well YLC guessed it, so here it is. Yeah, I'm Stewie. Contradict me if I am lying, speak up.

I can't be lynched because I am... ugh... so adorable.

I wouldn't steal my own teddy bear, first of all. And the writeups clearly indicate someone else did it. I would almost call that a confirmed innocent, but I think that nothing short of several lynches will convince some of y'all.

knock yourselves out. Just defend my pasty white baby butt when it comes time for murder... (giddy at the thought of roleplaying) ...you incompetent twits!!!!

:grin:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy

Well YLC guessed it, so here it is. Yeah, I'm Stewie. Contradict me if I am lying, speak up.

I can't be lynched because I am... ugh... so adorable.

I wouldn't steal my own teddy bear, first of all. And the writeups clearly indicate someone else did it. I would almost call that a confirmed innocent, but I think that nothing short of several lynches will convince some of y'all.

knock yourselves out. Just defend my pasty white baby butt when it comes time for murder... (giddy at the thought of roleplaying) ...you incompetent twits!!!!

:grin:

---

I still say we lynch him anyway. Just to make sure he is Stewie.

What are you White_Eyes?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Beefy187

I still say we lynch him anyway. Just to make sure he is Stewie.

What are you White_Eyes?

---

If I tell you YLC well likely start a chain of events to kill me:sweatdrop:

Edit: Mafia or not.....:shrug:

Are you Death? Even though I dont even know what that character is? :beam:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Beefy187

Are you Death? Even though I dont even know what that character is? :beam:

---

If I was, then I would not worry about those 'Chain of events'......:juggle2:

I will say no more until more have been said from someone other then ATPG, White_Eyes, YLC and my self.

Now I shall look more into Wikipedias family guy article :beam:

I'd only try to kill you if you became a bother (again). It really doesn't matter, one way or another, I will find out, I'll make you squeal, I'll make you the one to cough it up and delight in your sorrow as you weep from your broken mind at the failings and inadequacies of your pathetic existence and how much you fail...

...Hmmm, methinks I became carried away with this vendetta a bit, shake hands and call it even White Eyes?

Who on earth would protect Stewie? This makes no sense.

I could see Brian protecting Lois from lynch, or the old guy protecting Chris. However, there is nobody out there who has a vested interest in Stewie being kept alive.

Hmm lets see... its my teddy, and we are trying to catch the dude who stole it.

Won't make much sense if I am dead.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy

Hmm lets see... its my teddy, and we are trying to catch the dude who stole it.

Won't make much sense if I am dead.

---

It also wouldn't make any sense for mafioso to rat out their leader by claiming to be detective now would it? :smash:

I don't buy it.

Or this could be utter bollocks and NO ONE IS STEWIE. No one would be able to contradict you, and it seems to provide some cover. Hmmm...and Lois would protect Stewie, methinks.

:clown:Maybe we all just want the pleasure of lynching ATPG, but without the consequences...:grin: