The Catilinian Conspiracy [Concluded]

Beskar, how would you feel if Johnhughthom was put to death? And, would you support such a measure?

I'm guessing my failure to lodge a vote last round has drawn your attention? I expected Cicero and Catalina to make a bigger contribution to the game than they did last round and didn't get a chance to vote after my comment saying I was waiting for them to post.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by johnhughthom

I'm guessing my failure to lodge a vote last round has drawn your attention? I expected Cicero and Catalina to make a bigger contribution to the game than they did last round and didn't get a chance to vote after my comment saying I was waiting for them to post.

---

Then I suspect you have time to comment now. Who should be put to death?

I'll tell you my opinion on that if you enlighten me as to why Beskar would have a strong opinion on whether I should be put to death.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by johnhughthom

I'll tell you my opinion on that if you enlighten me as to why Beskar would have a strong opinion on whether I should be put to death.

---

I believe whether he has an opinion at all regarding your death remains to be seen. Which is why I posed the question.

If you wanted to draw a quiet player out you would ask a general question on the game, you asked Beskar a very specific question which leads me to think you suspect a link.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by johnhughthom

If you wanted to draw a quiet player out you would ask a general question on the game, you asked Beskar a very specific question which leads me to think you suspect a link.

---

:wink:

Bah, I could strangle whoever put a roof over your head...








:clown:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by johnhughthom

Bah, I could strangle whoever put a roof over your head...

---

You've given me reasons to leave my vote where it is, because you seem incredibly adept at reading my mind, and to be frank, only mafia know how to do that.

Tell me why I think Beskar is suspicious. While you're at it, what number am I thinking of?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy

Tullanium

---

Shiesh.. people are so bloodthirsty... Or am I just missing something?

I have no use for exiling Crassus' murderer. The guilty parties should be put to death.

Those that crave leniency are either cowards or co-conspirators, in my opinion.

Autolycus asked me yesterday if I knew anything about God Emperor, which makes me wonder if he was the source of that message in the write-up.

Any idea what Auto was looking for, GE?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Winston Hughes

Autolycus asked me yesterday if I knew anything about God Emperor, which makes me wonder if he was the source of that message in the write-up.

Any idea what Auto was looking for, GE?

---

No not at all. I haven't been in contact with anyone privately about this game yet

Anyone else think it was weird of the mafia to try and kill Csargo, even though he is unkillable till his men die?(It was clearly stated in the OP):confused:

Either the most clever plot ever or a random kill gone wrong, leaning more toward random and not playing much attention to this game.:idea2:

Exilium:Joooray since he seems to fit the bill...(ignores that that could be over half the players at present):sweatdrop:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy

I have no use for exiling Crassus' murderer. The guilty parties should be put to death.

Those that crave leniency are either cowards or co-conspirators, in my opinion.

---

Do we know for certain he is guilty? because if we do then by all means, lynch him

I just don't remember him being guilty, to me it just sounded like trying to start a bandwagon... If you have any evidence you could always post it you know, share whats going on with the rest of us...

EDIT: If you are trying to get him to talk which may be the case then go ahead, I just didn't understand your reasoning

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ByzantineKnight

Do we know for certain he is guilty? because if we do then by all means, lynch him

I just don't remember him being guilty, to me it just sounded like trying to start a bandwagon... If you have any evidence you could always post it you know, share whats going on with the rest of us...

EDIT: If you are trying to get him to talk which may be the case then go ahead, I just didn't understand your reasoning

---

I note that after his failure to vote yesterday, even after prodding, he has failed to accuse anyone again today. Although he ponders much on the reasoning for my vote, he does not ponder much on who is guilty. Or if he has, he isn't showing it.

I also note that using the democratic process to administer justice seems just, it also necessitates bandwagoning to accomplish anything. One vote hardly constitutes a bandwagon anyway. Have you any better ideas for bringing the ones responsible to justice, feel free to mention them.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by White_eyes:D

Exilium:Joooray since he seems to fit the bill...(ignores that that could be over half the players at present):sweatdrop:

---

So, does this imply that you think me stupid enough to try to kill someone I know is well protected? That's an outrage, my good sir. I may be past my prime, but my head still works well, my friend.

Anyway, I don't think we will have much to go on this time around. Those foul murders will certain know how to cover their behinds.
But I'm also intrigued by the implied connections between Sen. Beskar and Sen. john. Could you elaborate, my good Sen. pizza?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy

I also note that using the democratic process to administer justice seems just, it also necessitates bandwagoning to accomplish anything. One vote hardly constitutes a bandwagon anyway. Have you any better ideas for bringing the ones responsible to justice, feel free to mention them.

---

I misinterpreted your tone as trying to get a bandwagon on him and/or a bloodthirsty desire to lynch him without anything other than suspicious behavior

Otherwise I have no objection to who you accuse or how you accuse them... Except as I stated before, I believe Exile is the better of the two options for the town...

I would still like to hear from God Emperor about why he wouldn't have the best interests of the republic at heart

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Joooray

But I'm also intrigued by the implied connections between Sen. Beskar and Sen. john. Could you elaborate, my good Sen. pizza?

---

I would most certainly elaborate, but right now I am enjoying the awkward silence presented by the right honorable senators Beskar and John, especially from John.

The quiet is almost musical to my ears.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ByzantineKnight

I misinterpreted your tone as trying to get a bandwagon on him and/or a bloodthirsty desire to lynch him without anything other than suspicious behavior

Otherwise I have no objection to who you accuse or how you accuse them... Except as I stated before, I believe Exile is the better of the two options for the town...

I would still like to hear from God Emperor about why he wouldn't have the best interests of the republic at heart

---

If you refer to the message posted for all to see, then surely you must be jesting.

Since it has been only one night, it is not an anonymous message from some would-be investigator informing us that the good Emperor is a slime mold in disguise, because there wouldn't have been enough time for such a report to have been properly gathered.

What you see, sir, is a lie. A lie for what purpose, I do not know, but it is clearly a lie. Why you focus so on this lie leads me to believe that you yourself wrote it.

Do explain why you give any thought to this foolishness.

Actually, a thought crosses my mind:

The first reads-

Quote:

---

"Exile not the man who would be king, lest he return in triumph."

---

And the second reads-

Quote:

---

"Don't trust God Emperor. He does not have the best interests of the Republic at heart."

---

I believe that Csargo wrote the first one, and Sasaki wrote the second one.

Quote:

---

Cicero is Csargo

Catiline is Saskai

---

It is possible that Cicero and Catiline have the ability to post messages for us to read.

Csargo, given such an ability, would probably be advocating for outright imprisonment and death of those voted, in an authoritative manner. Sasaki, given such an ability, would cause confusion, suspicion, and mayhem for his own amusement.

What do I win?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by God Emperor

hmm.. It would appear that a person has the ability to to enter text in the writeup, similar to the telepathy ability in parasite.
Anyway, I think Romanic might be right, and we must therefore each day phase make sure that a tie does not occur.
Personally I don't like bandwagons in the start of the game, so I am going to Vote Exilium TheFlax for the late bandwagon vote

---

Let me get this straight, you're accusing me of bandwagonning a player who hasn't even shown up yet, because I wanted to see how Exilium worked, while a player that had been contributing was, to be the best of my knowledge at time, on the way to being executed. Why select me over the third voter on DiamondEye? Do you think he had a better reason to vote?

I don't believe exiling people is a good idea. I think I've already stated that, but I'll say it again just to be sure. The possibility of them joining Catiline when recalled is more than enough for me to think it's a bad idea.

At this point john or Joooray are good choices for the lynch. Tullanium: Johnhughthom

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Joooray

So, does this imply that you think me stupid enough to try to kill someone I know is well protected? That's an outrage, my good sir. I may be past my prime, but my head still works well, my friend.

---

I just about unvoted you for this but your missing a vote on someone. Too many people are "towing the line" as my netural-mind friend as says. Vote for someone and the vote comes off.:bow:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy

I believe that Csargo wrote the first one, and Sasaki wrote the second one.

It is possible that Cicero and Catiline have the ability to post messages for us to read.

Csargo, given such an ability, would probably be advocating for outright imprisonment and death of those voted, in an authoritative manner. Sasaki, given such an ability, would cause confusion, suspicion, and mayhem for his own amusement.

What do I win?

---

I believe you are right. To refer to a comment you said earlier about the second message that dovetails into what you are saying now, sure it is misdirection, but it doesn't make someone less suspicious in my mind. I think these types of messages should generally be ignored.

I think you should leave it on W_E. His response to it was strange imo.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheFlax

Why select me over the third voter on DiamondEye? Do you think he had a better reason to vote?

---

I wanted to exile him to see how it worked...we needed a majority for death for it to even work anyway:shrug:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy

If you refer to the message posted for all to see, then surely you must be jesting.

Since it has been only one night, it is not an anonymous message from some would-be investigator informing us that the good Emperor is a slime mold in disguise, because there wouldn't have been enough time for such a report to have been properly gathered.

---

You know... I really didn't think of that :blush:... I saw Diamond Eye post about not exiling Catalina and I assumed that the rest would be trustworthy...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy

What you see, sir, is a lie. A lie for what purpose, I do not know, but it is clearly a lie. Why you focus so on this lie leads me to believe that you yourself wrote it.

Do explain why you give any thought to this foolishness.

---

Unless the basic role of detective has changed in this game then you are right and it doesn't make sense... *sigh* I'll get used to these games again yet

But anyways, since the posted message is a lie we can assume that God Emperor is a townie, right?

Not really, no.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by White_eyes:D

I wanted to exile him to see how it worked...we needed a majority for death for it to even work anyway:shrug:

---

I'm not questioning you WE, I'm just wondering if GE is making a lazy vote or if he has some sort of reasoning behind his vote.

I'll even up the ante, until you reply God Emperor:

Tullanium: God Emperor

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by White_eyes:D

I just about unvoted you for this but your missing a vote on someone. Too many people are "towing the line" as my netural-mind friend as says. Vote for someone and the vote comes off.:bow:

---

Fair enough. I shall Tullianum: Beskar. For one he should be pressured to be active, also he has been put in connection with john and I don't want to bandwagon him.

I would vote Sasaki as his silence is unnerving, then again it wouldn't work and also with him being thrown out he may be refrained from letting his voice be heard at this point. This would also give credibility to Sen. pizza's claim that one of the messages is his doing.