I think an axe might of done a little more then just slit his throat.Quote:
Originally Posted by Zain
And I will Vote:Abstain, cause after 3 kills anyone could be guilty, or all.......
Printable View
I think an axe might of done a little more then just slit his throat.Quote:
Originally Posted by Zain
And I will Vote:Abstain, cause after 3 kills anyone could be guilty, or all.......
Vote Sigurd. Why is our mafia hunter so silent?:inquisitive:
Actually it was Moros/Gertgregoor who did that; his trademark was to say/write arrivederci with all of his kills. This time, we have Tu quoque.Quote:
Originally Posted by Andres
Anyway, hm...
Personally I suspect that at this point, there's at least one mafioso just sitting back, biding his time while watching the town debate.
Vote: Brave_Sir_Robin
He lurked his way through The Spinache Pie Conspiracy, and I want to make sure he doesn't get away with it in this game.
Also,
I'm not sure why a vigilante would kill on the first night. We may have a serial killer on our hands.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tran
Finally, FoS: FactionHeir. For being third on the bandwagon, of course! :2thumbsup:
FoS: Sarathos For killing me
FoS: Twilightblade That kill description of me is just like you
hmmm, latin. If I'm not mistaken, Warmaster Horus has something with latin...
Yes, but just to remind everyone, you have to be really careful when and how to use kill descriptions in your analysis. The only time I can remember it working was in Mafia IV when I nailed discovery1, and even that was actually pure luck.Quote:
Originally Posted by Andres
It can help to look for regional words and phrases to narrow down the mafia's location; for example, I think it was Sigurd in Mafia VII who pointed out that the word "Bismarck" was used only in the US; sure enough, our mafiosi were American. Beyond that, kill descriptions aren't very useful as evidence; most arguments degenerate into WIFOM.
I suppose the other thing to consider is that it isn't always the mafia who write the descriptions. Its optional from the one game where I was a non townie.
Vote Abstain
As I had said in all other large games, no point lynching an innocent townie :yes:
Vote:Shlin.
How do you know a player's a townie or not? I mean, if we didn't lynch anyone, well... We'd never get the bad guys, would we? And one person abstaining can have other persons abtaining which can lead to the bad guys hiding longer because of that.
Lynching innocent townies is the sinew of a Town victory.
Hm, why not Sarathos and Hepcat? They voted abstain too...:dizzy2:
Siguuuurd? Where are thou? This lurking reminds me of your earlier mafia tactics.:whip:
Vote: Warmaster Horus
For attacking shlin for abstaining even though several other people also abstained.
Because he's/you're (to BSR and Shlin respectively) the last one I saw. I made that post about 20 minutes after coming home from school, and didn't have time to read the whole thread. And:
-Third to abstain, could it equal the third on the bandwagon theory?
-I can't vote all three of 'em. So I chose the one I saw abstain the most recently.
Vote: gibsonsg91921 :wink:
No real reasoning involved. It's pot luck at this stage?
Yeah, yeah...Quote:
Originally Posted by Kagemusha
I am a little busy with an article I am writing for the Gahzette. The deadline is tomorrow. Be a little patient will ya? The family men have limited hours to play around. As soon as I am finished I will contribute... after the weekend mind you.
hmmm... having a quick look at the kills I notice that Zain was quite quick in posting.
vote:Zain (for now)
I will have a good read through the thread Sunday.
Sigurd answered, so who elseis being quiet?
Unvote: Sigurd Fafnesbane
Vote: Caius
I get the feeling some people don't post enough and so far suspicion still seems to be rather random.
haha craterus nice reasoning. well, ive been voted for having too many numbers, for lurking, for insisting im not mafia
Wow, I'm so inactive in this I'm suprised I haven't been bandwagoned yet
Can I opt for "all of the above"?Quote:
haha craterus nice reasoning. well, ive been voted for having too many numbers, for lurking, for insisting im not mafia
:shrug: I can't help it if I'm active...Quote:
Originally Posted by Sigurd Fafnesbane
Ok, I just thought about a tally being useful etc and something struck me...
This is from the beer and old people mafia, but according to Sigurd, the "third on the bandwagon rule" always applies...Quote:
Originally Posted by Sigurd Fafnesbane
Quote:
Originally Posted by greaterkhaan
Quote:
Originally Posted by Crazed Rabbit
Unvote: CaiusQuote:
Originally Posted by Sigurd Fafnesbane
Vote: Sigurd Fafnesbane
I'm sorry mate, but you might want to be more careful about your own rules. ~D
Why do all of those have something to do with me? :confused:Quote:
Originally Posted by Husar
Bwahahahahaha!
Vote: Sigurd
Yes, I realize that this also puts me third on the Sigurd bandwagon.
Tally anyone? I think it's a three way tie...
My initial instinct is that Sigurd and Crazed Rabbit are the mafia. I'm thinking that Sarathos is the vigilante/serial killer who killed Pevergreen.
I make it:
Zain: 3
Sigurd: 3
Kommodus: 2
FactionHeir: 2
shlin28: 2
Dutch_guy, Crazed Rabbit, greaterkhaan, BSR, Warmaster Horus, gibson: 1
Abstain: who cares?
Voting will stay open for another 2 hours.
I've had a brainwave, or something like that.
unvote: gibsonblahblah
vote: Stig
Don't ask me why, but there's my early prediction for a killer patient.
Unvote: Vote: Sigurd
You get me lynched for the same reason that you FoS'ed someone else. Unfair treatment!
New tally is:
I think. I hope. :undecided:Quote:
Originally Posted by Craterus