Select: Reenk Roink
Don't fix what ain't broke.
Printable View
Select: Reenk Roink
Don't fix what ain't broke.
Actually I said that a mafia's chances of attacking a don is 4/73 seeing as I doubt a mafia family would attack their own don peverQuote:
Originally Posted by pevergreen
my mathcraft is fine
do I really want to know? your track record isn't all that awesome:no:
What if we already accidentally killed a don by lynch?
Double A if you query was aimed at pever and my posts, we were talking about the odds on night 1
Tally:
AVSM: 4 (woad&fangs, El Diablo, YLC, Rhyfelwyr)
Sigurd: 1 (Shinseikhaan)
Beefy187: 1 (Lord Winter)
Askthepizzaguy: 1 (Chaotix)
Abstain: 4 (Askthepizzaguy, Moros, Twilightblade, splitpersonality)
SELECTION:
Reenk Roink: 7 (gibsonsg91921, Lord Winter, Reenk Roink, LittleGrizzly, Chaotix, Twilightblade, TinCow
Askthepizzaguy: 6 (Askthepizzaguy, Beskar, El Diablo, YLC, Double A, splitpersonality)
abstain: 2 (Moros, Rhyfelwyr)
Oh ok then.Quote:
Originally Posted by Twilightblade
Select ATPG
Vote AVSM
ATPG got a couple of "mades" and FH. He offered his head if he was wrong.
We wasn't.
****************************
SORRY FOR THE REPOST, LAST ONE WAS EDITED DUE ME PUTTING SPOILERS AROUND MY VOTE RATHER THAN BOLDING. :oops:
I hate that phrase, sorry Tin Cow, but you just pulled out the phrase I hate the most. If people stuck to that phrase, we would all be living in a forest without technology, after all, why bother with fire or the wheel, when you got hair and arms+legs.Quote:
Originally Posted by TinCow
I mean, why bother getting a better director?
ATPG has too much power over too many groups as it is. I don't want him to be invulnerable as well. Is that a good enough reason for you?Quote:
Originally Posted by Beskar
Select: Reenk Roink
I still do not trust ATPG.
Well with his power has come some positive results, if he was invulnerable he could maybe even double his scum-finding efforts.
The only real reasons I can see for not wanting ATPG as director are.
1) You really like reenk. Like too much.
2) You're scum, trying to keep reenk in there instead of Pizza.
3) You think pizza is starting his own crazy mafia family or something likewise.
Select: Reenk Roink has done everything town required(killed both on tie)and writes hillarious endings.Vote:Abstainuntil something is proved.
I think it's a perfectly legitimate position to not want me as director, that's why we are voting.
Select: Reenk Roink
ATPG has gotten a made and an innocent killed. One strike, one ball.
From the write-up I would suggest that Reenk's attacker was Eastern European/Communist/Russian (pick whichever works for you...). It also seems that there was only one attacker. Diana certainly seems to have been very lucky given that one of ATPG, Shlin or Glyphz didn't show up to protect her (or couldn't). I don't see why ATPG would assign himself to protect one of his supporters were he in a position to know that his participation would result in a failed protection so the suspicion falls on Shlin, part of the Pever debacle, and Glyphz, who on ATPGs word has also been part of two failed groups.
Select: Reenk Roink
ATPG has enough influence already without needing protection, if he wanted he could easily organise a protection group for himself, and Reenk is doing a more than adequate job.
Vote will be cast later pending further pondering.
Quote:
Originally Posted by spL1tp3r50naL1ty
Perhaps
4) 'You' have worked or interacted with Reenk in this game and think he is generally working for the good of the town....
Not that I don't nessecarily think ATPG is... but im more sure Reenk is....
I've not worked with reenk, so I don't really know personally.
I'm not arguing that he's a bad director, or not working for the town. I just think that we would all bennefit from ATPG being in there, even for only one term.
it's only fair everyone gets a chance in the big chair :clown:
So you'll be voting me in after ATPG so everyones gets a chance right ? ~;)
Im not making Reenk director for life... Im happy with his work so far and I slightly trust that hes a townie... so whats the harm in giving him 2 more rounds...
If the situation changes my selection will change with it....
Better explanation, you didn't use the dreaded phrase. :beam: Think of how much Pizza can do if he didn't have to look after himself, he can use his powers to help the town like he has been doing.Quote:
Originally Posted by TinCow
Also, Split personality has hit it on the head.
Maybe I will LG, depends on how your writeups are :wink:
I'll have to free up my protection squads for tonight anyway. If I don't get selected after the FBI results come out, then it will be pointless because I'll have to triple protect myself.
It's too much of a burden to the town to have all that protection power on me. No role is worth that. I'd rather protect 3 protown roles and take my chances.
Select: ATPG for obvious reasons. Yes, we are working together, we combined our protection groups, so we could cover more town, and pro-town roles from night actions. :idea2:
And of course, I usually love his write ups in his games, he hosts.
Vote: Abstain for now until we get results back.
Iv talked a bit more with ATPG than Reenk, (meaning I have actually conversed with ATPG). That, plus Iv more trusting of him now too, hes gotten actualy results.
Also, please remind me, whats the reason for voting AVSM?
Apparently he's gotten a guilty result.
Criminal result, no one can account for his night actions. I'd like to add that he's been unresponsive to private messages, and he's never really defended himself that I can recall.
Hullo.
I am a criminal. I have no qualms revealing that. However, I haven't been doing anything at all in the night. If I had tried to kill someone, it'd be in the write-up, and there's no reason for me to hide protections from the town.
Oh well.
Eh? If you killed someone it would be in the write-up? And it does appear you are hiding from us.Quote:
Originally Posted by A Very Super Market
Why haven't you participated in any group actions? If you are an unaffiliated wise, participating in protection groups might have helped your case.
This leads me to believe you just want to get offered a position in one of the families. What is your response to that?
Looks to me like ATPG has a separate goal of eliminating Communists. I've read my role PM and the rules, and as far as I can tell, killing the Communists is totally unnecessary for a town victory. ATPG has already killed a townie, probably just because the guy was a Communist. Thus, ATPG, while likely largely aligned with the town, is also focused on doing things that aren't necessarily in the town's best interests. You'll also note that the Communist investigations are totally useless in spotting mafioso.Quote:
Originally Posted by Beskar