Printable View
I don't think Newcomb has attempted to pocket anybody in this game. Closest thing is probably me but saying "youre unlikely to be the d1 chop" really isn't much.
I don't think Newcomb has asked any irrelevant questions that he doesn't actually care about the answers to.
more of the story comes in here where I am surprised that Mont didnt get vested for this :pQuote:
Originally Posted by Montmorency
oh yeah this reminds me about something i forgot to bring up in my last wall because im dumbQuote:
Originally Posted by Sunbae
when i did ask him to explain his scumread on me he clarified something i had gotten wrong and then gave me a prompt about something he was thinking about but i don't really feel like he used that to solve me much at all
idd, hes not been really pockety except maybe towards ladd (which is probably a good look if anything) but i think there's still issue with his play
Does Hollowkatt give one iota of care about who wolves are in this game?
now if rask isnt vested I wonder about this comment on the might move thing since it looked like Rask was pretty confident that Cuth was wolf.Quote:
Originally Posted by Raskolnikov
im not sure but i think he's town anywayQuote:
Originally Posted by Sunbae
why is this conditional on him not being vested?Quote:
Originally Posted by Cape90
i just realized that that was a really stupid question
I was thinking along the lines of "oh rask is gonna die anyways if he has vest"Quote:
Originally Posted by katze
however, if they are indeed town with vest, they should answer :p
Basically I have reasons to feel good about:
Cuth, Dobby, Zack, Neb, sleep
You've got mont/rask that killed a wolf
I just think as of right now newc is villagery
zack has defended cape pretty hard and i trust him
cuth seems to be big on ender v
so like, out of dolby, hollowkat, katze, csargo is there 3 wolves?
seems unlikely
So am i wrong on newcomb?
possibly, but i dont *want* to be wrong on newcomb and i dont *want* to just shrug and write him off just to see his alignment
is zack wrong about cape?
is cuth wrong about ender?
did i clear sleep too lightly? i dont think so, ladd pressed there kinda hard and ended there.
did zack get me? i dont think so, i really liked his snap back at ladd and overall posting?
did someone bus ladd? maybe?
i was going to say taht i think me/hkatt/csargo/dolby is probably 4 villagers then i looked at the list above and was like "okay so wheres the mafia" and now im realizing that it's one of these games
vote: csargo
actually my reason to townread this slot is pretty bad come to think of it
So now I sit here and try to concoct a feel good grouping
I feel good about Dobby.
Dobby feels good about Dolby.
I feel good about Cuth.
Cuth feels good about Ender.
I feel good about Zack.
Zack feels good about Cape.
I feel good about Sleep.
Sleep also feels good about Ender.
Who feels good about Hollowkatt?
Who feels good about Katze?
So then I take a step back and say "ok, it's one of those games which means just stop beating your head into a wall and instead just ask 'who is trying to solve the game today'.
So now we just wait and see who that is as the day progresses
why are those 4 all probably town? especially dolbyQuote:
Originally Posted by katze
You're wasting your timeQuote:
Originally Posted by katze
you do, deep down, i believe in youQuote:
Originally Posted by Sunbae
i dont rly think hk/ladd are w/w and also think hk had some really villagery d1 postsQuote:
Originally Posted by zack
csargo i liked some of the questions he was asking d1 and there was something timing related i also liked but dont remember so im voting there
dolby i kinda explained earlier
Quote:
Originally Posted by katze
csargo, you're villa then?
luckily for me i have plenty of it to wasteQuote:
Originally Posted by Csargo
sunbae if i told you i'd vote whoever you wanted me to vote who would you tell me to vote
the obvious answer is whoever ur voting rn but idk who that is, if anyone
I'm not voting anyone. I think if you read my posts I've been rather up front about where my head is at and why I'm pretty stuck at the moment. Think the correct play is to just wait and see what happens over the next 12 hours.
Indeed, also Visor came to me in a dream.Quote:
Originally Posted by Sunbae
I don't know what the optimum play is here, so you can all get mad at me if you want, but it's probably preferable for you all not to investigate someone who's a dead man already.
My mind is kinda split between two worlds right now: the one where newcomb is v and the one where newcomb is w.
If newcomb is a wolf I'll probably just punt Cape into the sun and tell Zack sorry. Ladd and Newc shading me/sleep after we pushed Cape would be the reason.
If newcomb is a villager I might go after you.
And you're not the backup csargo?
yea fair enough. im p stuck too and just haven't written all that much of my brain thoughts out and i was hoping me asking you directly would give you a eureka moment or somethingQuote:
Originally Posted by Sunbae
i think there's decent odds he's a villager just by virtue of being unaligned w/ ladd, even if i still take issue with a majority of his postingQuote:
Originally Posted by Sunbae
Nah, no reason to be mad. Was hoping you were villa, glgl.
I'm sorc. Thought it was best to target a villager that wasn't being cleared by anyone. If I target a poe wolf they just blast the top villager and it's bad, hitting a villager in that spot clears out poe better and can still hit that same poe wolf (or a better one!). Figure it's correct for me to claim now since even if you're a wolf we have a backup and it can't be stopped.
I was given a vest, I'm just a vtQuote:
Originally Posted by Sunbae
I felt so bad for Zack once I realized what was happening and he was wrong for very right reasons lol. That opener was fake af
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sunbae
Spoiler Alert, click show to read:
:bow:Quote:
Originally Posted by Sunbae
read this thread no less than 4 times during the last 24 hours
kinda mad at myself for it lol