This round, voted Atheotes because he seemed like instead of moving on and carrying on discussion like a good townie, he consistently brought the topic back to Beskar, who he knew consistently gunned for him, and would probably never cease once he started, and he took advantage of it. This though, is not the main point, until this round, I didn't really suspect Atheotes or TM, but since I'm in the opinion that Atheotes is the mafia, it makes lots of sense that TM is too in retrospect, and this round, TM's been acting quite scummy, a drastic change in behavior.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Thermal Mercury
Vote:Beskar
You jumped onto the bandwagon, besides if he is always mafia then maybe its his time to be town. :balloon2:
You know Beskar, he guns for Atheotes anyway, why so overprotective? Looked to me in retrospect now like you were looking for an easy target, alongside Atheotes.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Beskar
vote: atheotes
FoS: Thermal Mercury
I bet it is those two. Why else did Thermal jump to atheotes' defense?
Loath am I to admit it, Beskar actually probably is right here. After all the times, it makes sense this game.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Thermal Mercury
Blame me? I voted for you because your reasoning was AWFUL and you blatently BANDWAGONED Athrotes, it isn't our fault Beskar, you sly man. Your trying to detract attention from yourself by blaming us, yet just last round you did a scummy vote to save your own skin, and killed a townie in the process, which is much more scummy than anything I've done.
Definitely voting for you again. :balloon2:
Vote: Beskar
Sounds like a mafia buddy in panic mode, underlined sections are the eyebrow raising ones. A few votes is hardly a bandwagon, a few drops in a puddle. Sounds a bit desperate to discredit Beskar because you know he will gun for Atheotes all game long.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Thermal Mercury
You want my answers so make sure to read this
I like the way you start your post by basically saying 'I'm a townie' Which usually means 'I'm not a townie'
Now then...lets look to your rule book, maybe you don't 'officially' qualify as a bandwagonner but you followed the persons vote in front of you mindlessly, that is bandwagonning behavior at the very least. Whether your little rule book says second or third to vote for someone makes it a bandwagon or not, your doing everything a bandwagoner would do, so stop playing fairly pointless games with what is and isn't a mafia game rule.
You vote for the same person the first person voted for about an hour after they vote. Which is piling the pressure, most townies spread there votes out, but by mounting his votes up you seriously increased athelotes chance of being lynched on no other logic than 'hes always mafia'. Using data from other games is poor logic and can result in a player losing interest in this game, if that is the only basis you vote for someone. Your vote was based on personal experience and our own silly grudges when it should have been a fresh slate! :whip:
I haven't been over protective of atheotes, you have been over-offensive to him, which is why I am defending him at all. This scummy mc sscummy comment is laughable, seeing as you have nothing on me other than defending a player that your harassing, you have nothing on me and no true reasons to believe I'm scummy, which is surely still an attempt on your part to detract attention from yourself. Maybe were both townies? either way going around saying whos who, when you blatantly have no clue, is ignorant in itself.
@Split: Townies aren't supposed to be afraid to die, Beskar didn't even bother to comment or say why he was voting centurion, but seemed more in a rush to vote for someone else before he got a majority vote himself. Perhaps, in his situation I may have protected myself over others if I know I'm innocent, but he didn't even seem bothered and was quick to place all the blame onto me & Athelotes, even though it was he that killed the townie, quite bluntly.
There isn't much else to say and whilst there isn't much evidence to go on in this game, I certainly don't see why I'm such a big suspect in comparison to Beskar, given that mostly everyone said they were going to vote for him this round anyway after his actions the day before. Furthermore, why beskar & me anyway? Why apply pressure just to us? No one is ruled out yet & so I fail why anyone else should feel there in a safer position just because they lurk most of the time.
As you can see I am putting effort into this game, if you wish to vote me out then fine, but I can't of tried harder to convince you of my actions. Furthermore whether you vote me out someone else or Athelotes it doesn't bother me an awful lot, go ahead and lynch atholates or me if you want to, that is no bluff because I am not his mafia partner and if you want to lynch we to prove that, then I am willing to die for you. Though I doubt Beskar is.
When I come on tomorrow I'll see how you respond, if it is still roughfully a draw, I will vote for myself as I will have failed to convince you who is the best lynch candidate
oh round ends soon, maybe not...
Second paragraph, contradicting his previous post to discredit Beskar, :juggle2:
Fourth paragraph, the right thing to do would have been to just ignore, let it pass, and concentrate on the discussion properly.
5th Paragraph talking to Split, Townies are suppose to save themselves, no matter what, you always know that anyone else could be the mafia and that your innocent.
6th Paragraph, you aren't a big suspect, only Beskar considered you one, why are you overreacting? In hindsight, this only exemplifies itself more prominently in the later rounds.
7th Paragraph, tempting the WIFOM... :whip:
Last paragraph, very bad townie behavior, its not very helpful.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Thermal Mercury
Ok, I will openly admit that I put the words (that were since edited out) I am a townie, and I criticized Beskar for saying that :wall: (It's hard not to on rants)
I do assure you though, while it would annoy me, vote me out if you wish at least then I can help the players along, with you in the knowledge I'm innocent, although I'm not forcing you to vote for me, just suggesting you follow your instincts. :bow:
unvote
vote: Atheotes
This is merely a gesture to show I in no way feel a need to protect atheotes, and it could at least prove whether Beskar's flawed theory that Atheotes is always mafia is correct or not.
Why the self doubt? Sounds over self explanatory too, like a mafia trying not to be suspicious. Although admittedly I do this at times as a townie too :sweatdrop:
Quote:
Originally Posted by
atheotes
hmm... looks like Beskar will keep voting for me till i get killed. i can save myself this round but he is just going to comeback and vote for me next round. :wall:
i am still contemplating on what to do... whether to self vote just to say "told you so" or behave like Beskar last round and save myself :juggle2:
The thing that's making me suspect the both of you? This nagging feeling? You've been detracting discussion and instead of heading back and ignoring Beskar, you've drawn the attention to him and constantly try to play the sympathy card to make people try and vote him to get a free death out of him, so you don't have to kill him, although evidently later you killed him for the WIFOM and because this idea wasn't turning out to be fruitful.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Thermal Mercury
If I survive the night I don't know who I'm going to vote for, Beskar is an obivous option, but my instincts lead to Death is Yonder.... :inquisitive:
Again, why with all the self doubt? You sound like a mafia trying to play a "scared townie" card.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Thermal Mercury
True, but I already said I was willing to die, if town did suspect me :bow:
WIFOM, more and more. Not helping your case :wall:
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Thermal Mercury
Why ATPG over say, me? I see some suspicious tactics creeping in, along with premature bandwagons (renamed since Beskar got his rule book out)
Vote: Death Is Yonder
Don't like how you voted and your reasoning, which is 'theres 7 players, 2 are mafia, atpg is probably one of them' with that logic, it could be any of us, so why him in particular?
Why more WIFOM and the self pity cards? And the self contradiction at the end of the post? :wall:
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Thermal Mercury
It may have been overblown, but under blown rarely gets noticed, and I did state in that post that I thought Beskar was probably townie, even though he was acting scummy....
I would vote for you but I don't want to completely overrun your chances incase you are innocent, as you were lurking and only stopped when you were voted for.
Death is Yonder doesn't scream scum to me anymore and is acting like many townies do.
I'm pleasantly surprised to see that I haven't been voted for yet :2thumbsup:
unvote
vote: Splitpersonality
You haven't been in the spotlight yet, while keeping the tally is helpful & trying to act like a fair townie (I.e keeping pressure on me & beskar last round) I have a feeling your intentions aren't so innocent after all, no one has suspected you yet, and to be completely honest, I'm suspicious of pretty much everyone equally, so I picked you because....
Sorry for the lack of reasoning, its a random vote, as much as I don't like making them. :bow:
Also
You are very busy ATPG & I don't expect much activity, you are giving more than enough activity given how busy you are. However you usually analyze behavior and rip players to shreds, instead you seem to be taking a back seat which isn't all that like you if I remember correctly... :whip:
You seem like a mafia popping in to avoid being called a lurker, and then fading into the shadows, although prominently your around in times when Atheotes is on the line to the noose.
Trying to play the helpful townie trying to find more helpful townies, you said I was doing something scummy, being called a lurker then popping in, then you said I wasn't screaming scum to you anymore? :inquisitive:
Then you say your suspicious of pretty much everyone equally? That means nobody is suspicious? Stop digging your own hole, please :wall: Your not helping your own case :no:
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Thermal Mercury
And for ATPG's convenience, my top suspects are:
Split
A Very Super Market
Death is Yonder
Atheotes
Askthepizzaguy
:laugh4:
Even as mafia, one must endear oneself to several active townies who might go with you and save your behind, to supplement the voting power. :inquisitive:
I cautiously note that myself, Atheotes and ATPG are on the low of your list... maybe because we're more predictable? Or maybe because we believed Atheotes... :inquisitive:
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Thermal Mercury
Well at this stage, voting me out could result in a mafia victory, sorry but I'm unable to shut up... :balloon2:
also ATPG, you may have more posts than me, but usually you have like 3 times the posts than the second person on the post bored.
You dig your hole deeper and deeper, how deep do you want it to go... :thumbsdown:
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Thermal Mercury
Well I already said I didn't expect as much activity seeing as your doing a massive battle royale, I guess I'm just picking at straws.
@Split:
True, the vote must be right this time, problem is I don't know who the right person is to vote for, which makes my vote awkward.....
:inquisitive::inquisitive:
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Thermal Mercury
Well when Death is Yonder voted for ATPG straight after atheotes did that reminded me of you number 3. Mafia voting for people (a person) they KNOW are innocent, but DiY changed his vote and let AVSM take over, plus nothing else about him seems suspicious.
I would go with option 1, pick the lurker and join the bandwagon, but seeing as I'm not that certain either way I don't want to be responsible for AVSM's lynching if he is innocent, which is why I'm keeping my options open, by voting for say AVSM, a bigger suspect? Its almost like I'm damning any other vote as he will have the majority.
It sounds stupid, I guess I just like leaving that job to someone else, so I can critize them for it next round :laugh4: :balloon2:
Don't want to be involved in... controversy perhaps? Again... your posts really beg some looking into :inquisitive:
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Thermal Mercury
So do you want me to vote for you? :thinking:
Despite Beefy saying mafia have a cover role, perhaps now would be a good time to reveal our pm's? It could be useful :balloon2:
No self initiative, afraid to receive flak for bad decisions, indecisive mafia. :inquisitive:
Quote:
Why would you be so apprehensive not to vote me? Either you are mafia trying to look innocent, or there is little argument for my lynch.
Posted by AVSM.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Thermal Mercury
Which is it, in your opinion?
Response. Indeed, why? :inquisitive:
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Thermal Mercury
follow your instincts :bow:
Follow yours? :inquisitive: