Re: The Black Hand (finished)
Quote:
Originally Posted by Major Robert Dump
nah its all cool, now that i look back at emails i even see that Doc suggested he not go invisible, which should have set off alarms for me, but i was too lame to think that we had a mole in the mafia, even though i knew we would have a mole in the masons. Prolly in the future, as long as everyone knows what the roles are, it would make for a long, grueling fun game. Had i even suspected a mole in the mafia I would not have been as cordial to my teammates, except for the fact that between the 3 of us we only got to have 2 kills, so we would obviously have to vote and coordinate somewhat
Actually the invisible thing was just confusion from my part :oops:
The way these games usually work is that they are (relatively) symmetric, so if one side has a spy you can bet the other side has one too. Besides, there would have been 4 mafiosi otherwise which would have been an awful lot compared to the (pretty) small number of villagers.
I didn't think Kommodus would be immortal at night though, I feel that was a rule we should have been told about. If the game was played further I would have suggested that we should kill Kommodus again...
Re: The Black Hand (finished)
I guess I should explain myself as well.
It started off like any other mafia game, and my first posts had to do with the usual mafia/doctor/detective stuff, how to fake out the mafia, etc...
Once again, I ripped on the mafia, hoping they would get mad and kill me (as I had no special role) so that helpful people would have better chances to remain alive.
"A_friend's" PM changed everything (doc_bean has already posted the PM and most of you all should have got it, so I won't bother reposting it).
Frankly, I was surprised that nobody had made it public by the time I did. My post of "Anyone else get a weird PM from "A_friend"? :inquisitive:" was just to cut the 'hush-hush' that was so obvious. I knew he had made true on his claim, as my PM was a [FW] message (meaning he had sent it to multiple people) and he was private messaging 20 minutes after I received my message.
When Dutch_guy inquired into the PM, I became more inclined to listen to this "friend" but then this PM just showed me that we (villagers) had to kill everyone he named and him.
https://img283.imageshack.us/img283/7131/1nr7.jpg
The fact that he actually thought that because Dutch_guy remained ignorant of the PM "proved" his honesty struck me as quite stupid, even compensating for the fact that being a mafia lowers intelligence. For God's sake man, you told us that you were not going to send the PM's to the people you called Masons and Mafia! ~;p
It was sort of a dilemma for me. I couldn't ignore him, but I wasn't convinced and his proof was terrible logic. I decided it was best to kill both mafias and all three masons as well as "A_friend" himself.
I voted for Don first, but told the villagers not to kill MRD yet. I wanted to keep him alive, for if both of them were dead, this "friend" would get rid of his rivals.
I had planned for us to lynch Don, and have the detective investigate everyone named by "A_friend" for another opinion on their roles when the game abruptly ended.
Now it all makes sense, and actually, it was quite a fun game for its brevity. I know that a lot of people didn't even get to post, but at least for me, it was fun. :grin2:
We should thank doc_bean by the way, he made it so interesting. :beam:
Oh, and I'm happy with my action of making "A_friend" public. :yes:
(one thing I didn't pay attention to is the underscore in A_friend"... makes sense now though...)
Re: The Black Hand (finished)
Well, it certainly was a good idea Sasaki, and would've played out well had doc been a little more cautious in telling the people the truth, and communicated to them the urgency of not repeating verbatim what he had said, or just played Kommodus as a sucker.
Reenk...you remind me of this guy...
CR
