XCOM Mafia [Concluded]

Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief:
Manasi's seemed townier to me so far.

Show and tell?

Originally Posted by novice:
Are you really, though? Backburner lynchbait, perhaps.

Idk what this is supposed to mean in terms of me or Manasi.

I was surprised, yes.

Originally Posted by Winston Hughes:
This early D1 post from Manasi really jumps out in light of yesterday's events:

Because he didn't post himself clear and she still voted Pizza? Or for a different reason?

oook. I'm so glad I didn't get dayvigged, because I didn't read up before I started to post.

Originally Posted by Manasi:
BARTO PLEASE

You're my favorite.

Don't do this.

Oh, I am doing this.

Your reaction is too similar to the one last game where I vigged you. Goodbye.

Originally Posted by Manasi:
Anyway, I have this thing I've been procrastinating on that my boss wants to look at tomorrow afternoon so I will probably not be ITT until around 2 EST tomorrow weeeeee. <3

Oh, really? What a convenient excuse. You know what they say about players who announce their absences in advance, don't you?

Originally Posted by Dp101:
Also if I was scum I'd be tilted/10 at this turn of events.

What a strange postulate to make.

Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy:
I take back what I said about taking back what I said about Bsmith being lazy.

He's just a wolf.

Sooh now significantly less wolfy than Manasi and I figured one was inside of them. Lynch one is a wolf, resolves the other town.

Here's how you can tell Novice is a wolf, if you blatantly ignore what I said before:

Novice: Normal
Novice: dip dip dip
Novice: ain't got much to say

That's wolfy.

(!)

Originally Posted by Csargo:
Just like every other day...

She hasn't stopped being wrong, you know. Manasi continues to fail to address anything levelled at her

Originally Posted by Montmorency:
Correct music btw:

Galgasång

Kerpele, that's a good one.

Originally Posted by novice:
Given what we know now that's a very sinister suggestion.

It's very sinister to propose a thunderdome between a proven Innocent and yourself, my good sir?

Originally Posted by novice:
That's pretty uncharitable.

It is?

Originally Posted by Montmorency:
GH isn't lock town, and GH only claimed at SoD today.

Wait. See here:

Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief:
I'm reheating pizza right now.

That was posted before the night phase ended, Monty.

Originally Posted by Montmorency:
I see novice has entered full tilt mode, grasping at any which straw. This would seem to be what you lynched Pizza over.

Originally Posted by Dp101:
The first is IMO very unlikely. XCOM has no way to revive people, whereas the aliens have multiple units that can bring people back as zombies.

The second half of this is the scummiest and most ineffective method I have ever seen of discrediting someone. In fact, I think it's so bad that Vote: Montmorency because this cannot stand.

OK, Manasi and novice as my top scums, possible ‘thunderdome’, in MU parlance, between Dp101 and Montmorency, let us not ignore BSmith.

Originally Posted by Sooh:
oook. I'm so glad I didn't get dayvigged, because I didn't read up before I started to post.

????

Originally Posted by El Barto:
????

Which part are you not getting?

There was an event. I called it a dayvig. Glad it wasn't me or I might have broken the game.

Originally Posted by Sooh:
Which part are you not getting?

There was an event. I called it a dayvig. Glad it wasn't me or I might have broken the game.

:sweatdrop:

:bow:

:on_corner:

Originally Posted by Logic:

Originally Posted by novice:
Okay at least he recanted the suggested postponement of the thunderdome.
I can understand the call for a thunderdome too from a townie perspective, although of course scum would love it too. One thing's for sure, scum would prefer Pizza to lose the thunderdome, and go for a 2-for-1.

Call me grasping at straws, but this rings hollow.

Originally Posted by novice:
The temptation to resolve Pizza ASAP is a strong one.

And ten minutes later GH and his reanimated atpg both die?
:on_huh:

Originally Posted by El Barto:
And ten minutes later GH and his reanimated atpg both die?
:on_huh:

I thought that quote was describing Novice's opinion of Monty's thoughts from yesterday? I think it's just a coincidence that that conversation occurred soon before the GH probable vig.

This is a list of our current votes:

Manasi - 4 (Sooh #1464, Autolycus #1506, Winston Hughes #1514, El Barto #1560)

novice - 2 (GeneralHankerchief #1508; Logic #1513)

Logic - 1 (novice #1559)

Montmorency - 1 (Dp101 #1536)

Other votes - Dp101: Autolycus, #1497, later unvoted

not voting - 7 Askthepizzaguy, BSmith, Csargo, Cuthillius, Fredwood, Manasi, Montmorency

novice includes, in his vote in #1559, an anaphoric reference to #1547:

Originally Posted by novice:
Follows Pizza, says he will stop doing that and reassess, finds GH very suspicious, is happy with his vote on me.

Could be trying to get Csargo:

Originally Posted by Csargo:
I'd like to lynch one of these people today:

novice, Logic, Manasi, Barto.

to follow.

This happened right after GH was cleared as townie, so I'll put my tinfoil hat on in order to prevent humanic conspiracy theories.

Originally Posted by Dp101:
I thought that quote was describing Novice's opinion of Monty's thoughts from yesterday? I think it's just a coincidence that that conversation occurred soon before the GH probable vig.

Argh! x-post!

Read on about why I am suspicious of novice's posts and the timing of atpg's death.

*read above

Originally Posted by El Barto:
Argh! x-post!

Read on about why I am suspicious of novice's posts and the timing of atpg's death.

I did, and I really don't see what you are seeing. Novice's stated reason is that Logic admitted to sheeping, resolved to stop sheeping a now-dead town, and decided to go after another now-dead town. Seems like a perfectly natural case to me.

Timing! The point is in the timing. novice didn't actually argue that until both GH and atpg were dead.

Well, those were musings anyway. Just remember atpg's posts on novice and mull them over.

Originally Posted by El Barto:
:on_corner:


And ten minutes later GH and his reanimated atpg both die?
:on_huh:

So, Barto, how do you propose to solve this problem?

I know some of you were considering a sooh/Manasi thunderdome, but support for that that seems to have fallen off. I think novice is much more likely wolf than anyone, and I am willing to put my neck on the line for a Logic/novice thinderdome.

If novice is not going to be the lynch today, the next best case scenario is Manasi.

I know at least @Csargo would like to lynch Manasi and novice as well, but he also wants to kill me and El Barto, so I don't know helpful he can be.

Originally Posted by El Barto:
:on_corner:


And ten minutes later GH and his reanimated atpg both die?
:on_huh:

Barto puppeted by Csargo

Anyway, novice was referring to the events of EOD2 to be fair.

Originally Posted by El Barto:
This is a list of our current votes:

Manasi - 4 (Sooh #1464, Autolycus #1506, Winston Hughes #1514, El Barto #1560)

novice - 2 (GeneralHankerchief #1508; Logic #1513)

Logic - 1 (novice #1559)

Montmorency - 1 (Dp101 #1536)

Other votes - Dp101: Autolycus, #1497, later unvoted

not voting - 7 Askthepizzaguy, BSmith, Csargo, Cuthillius, Fredwood, Manasi, Montmorency

novice includes, in his vote in #1559, an anaphoric reference to #1547:


Could be trying to get Csargo:

to follow.

This happened right after GH was cleared as townie, so I'll put my tinfoil hat on in order to prevent humanic conspiracy theories.

GH is dead, voting novice, would vote Sooh over Manasi. Easy to call it scummy for novice, or even to call it scummy for Manasi using it as a pressure release on her own wagon, but in fact I think we can say GH or Cuth were the most obvious mafia vigs around as PR claimants.

Originally Posted by El Barto:
Timing! The point is in the timing. novice didn't actually argue that until both GH and atpg were dead.

Novice's post immediately following gives the appearance that he didn't see the dayvig until after he made the Logic post.

Originally Posted by El Barto:
Well, those were musings anyway. Just remember atpg's posts on novice and mull them over.

No vote just yet? Or are you still happy with either Manasi or novice?

You can remove GH from the votes on Novice.

I'd like to see again why Monty and Logic each have a vote please.

Originally Posted by Montmorency:
No vote just yet? Or are you still happy with either Manasi or novice?

Huh?

I don't have time to be as awesome as I have been in previous days, sorry for that, I'm super tired from work and have to work early in the morning again. I'm not terribly bothered that Manasi is the top wagon, but I'd prefer probably Logic/novice at this point. I don't think either has been as townie as Pokemon game tbh, which is concerning to me. I'd rather lynch there.

Vote: novice

Official Tally as of #1581

----

Day 3 ends in:

----

4 Manasi (Sooh, autolycus, Winston Hughes, El Barto)

2 novice (Logic, Csargo)

1 Logic (novice)
1 Montmorency (Dp101)

----

Not Voting: BSmith, Cuth, Fred, Monty

Not Posting: Manasi

----

If you notice anything wrong, PM me.

Originally Posted by Csargo:
I don't have time to be as awesome as I have been in previous days, sorry for that, I'm super tired from work and have to work early in the morning again. I'm not terribly bothered that Manasi is the top wagon, but I'd prefer probably Logic/novice at this point. I don't think either has been as townie as Pokemon game tbh, which is concerning to me. I'd rather lynch there.

Vote: novice

Neither have been as townie is your argument here?

Can you go into specifics on one of them? Preferably the one you want lynched the most.

Originally Posted by Sooh:
Huh?

I'm asking if Barto is still happy with either novice or Manasi being lynched, or if he's preferring to put one off for another day.

As for me, with the assumption that we aren't devastatingly off-track, two primary wagons between Manasi and novice have best potential for spew.

Vote: novice

Originally Posted by Logic:
So, Barto, how do you propose to solve this problem?

I know some of you were considering a sooh/Manasi thunderdome, but support for that that seems to have fallen off. I think novice is much more likely wolf than anyone, and I am willing to put my neck on the line for a Logic/novice thinderdome.

If novice is not going to be the lynch today, the next best case scenario is Manasi.

I know at least @Csargo would like to lynch Manasi and novice as well, but he also wants to kill me and El Barto, so I don't know helpful he can be.

Originally Posted by Montmorency:
Barto puppeted by Csargo

Anyway, novice was referring to the events of EOD2 to be fair.

I'll reread tomorrow.

And Csargo has no extremities up my rectum, thank you very much.
No vote just yet? Or are you still happy with either Manasi or novice?[/QUOTE]
Ahem?

Originally Posted by El Barto:
First things first. vote: Manasi

Now I'm off to read the thread.

Don't you read? I even posted my tally with my vote in it.

Originally Posted by Sooh:
You can remove GH from the votes on Novice.

I'd like to see again why Monty and Logic each have a vote please.

The one on Logic is a thinly-disguised OMGUS. For the other one, see #1536.

Originally Posted by Sooh:
Neither have been as townie is your argument here?

Can you go into specifics on one of them? Preferably the one you want lynched the most.

Go find my iso of Logic. I don't have time to indulge you Sooh. :| But basically yeah, I don't think either has played like the last game, that doesn't make them scum, but it doesn't look good to me.

It's good to see you branching out though. Maybe you'll vote me by the end of the phase, what a world that'll be.

Originally Posted by :
Don't you read? I even posted my tally with my vote in it.

I'm referring to you sussing novice, and what it means relative to the Manasi vote. Yesterday, for example, you started on Manasi and finished on novice.

Originally Posted by Csargo:
Go find my iso of Logic. I don't have time to indulge you Sooh. :| But basically yeah, I don't think either has played like the last game, that doesn't make them scum, but it doesn't look good to me.

It's good to see you branching out though. Maybe you'll vote me by the end of the phase, what a world that'll be.

Wow.

Great sarcasm. Really going to help people solve the game.

Originally Posted by Sooh:
Wow.

Great sarcasm. Really going to help people solve the game.

Vote:Sooh