Small mafia game 'Guess what your role is' (aka 'role insanity') [Concluded]

It was Arjos.

Although I remember checking last night and it said Nightbringer again, I must've just opened the wrong message, and the sent items don't tell you the content, which is frustrating.

There's an option in General Settings to save sent pms.

Unvote

Memnon's story checks out, otherwise I wouldn't have received your role John :)

Fair enough, back to Vote: Zaccino then.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BSmith

vote: chaotix. I don't remember seeing your claim either, and your "placeholder" vote on one of the lead candidates is kinda suspect.

---

Well, that's because I didn't. And I don't plan on it, either. At least not until it's no longer useful.

I don't want to make you suspicious, but neither do I want to paint a target on my face. Really, knowing everybody's role is just great for organizational purposes, but I hope you've realized that by everyone claiming their own roles in-thread the mafia know exactly who to go for first.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by johnhughthom

Fair enough, back to Vote: Zaccino then.

---

No snarky one-liner? Zaccino is disappoint.

Nah, I'm waiting for one of the bandwagoners to tell me what my case is, can't make a snarky one liner without one.

Quote:

---

Well, that's because I didn't. And I don't plan on it, either. At least not until it's no longer useful.

I don't want to make you suspicious, but neither do I want to paint a target on my face. Really, knowing everybody's role is just great for organizational purposes, but I hope you've realized that by everyone claiming their own roles in-thread the mafia know exactly who to go for first.

---

Nonsense, if everyone reveals it will be quite easy to catch the Mafia in a lie. Anyway, there are only 2 or 3 nights left and JHT was always going to be the primary target.

Scum.

LYNCH CHAOTIX

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Memnon

Uh, question. Why should I be lynched? The Oracle thing makes sense and I don't think I'm scum. Although I do forget who I targeted last night with john, I know I targeted classical hero (who was replaced by john) and Nightbringer the night before, so I thought I had something to do with his death. Again, I don't know what's happening.

---

this is what i said "Since i am a doctor, i must have died because someone attacked me. If that is not the case, i would lynch Memnon and Robbiecon"

As it has been mentioned, i visited John and protected him. I died. you also visited John. if i were not attacked by a different person, the only way i could have died was if my role is such that i would die on a succesful protection (the other protection roles except the doctor are like that i believe). It would mean you were attacking John and i died in his stead. :shrug:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zaccino

Brilliant defense.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zaccino

Vote: Ishmael

---

Brilliant case.

3 Ishmael: Chaotix, DaveShack, Zack
3 Zack: johnhughtom, Arjos, Ishmael
1 Memnon: edse
1 DaveShack: robbiecon
1 Chaotix: BSmith
1 edse: Memnon

Why don't we lynch Memnon instead? It's 1/3 chance that atheotes would die in case of a successful protection. Memnon also has a hard time keeping his story together, changing it over time so that it best fits what others have said.

Tally:
Ishmael: Chaotix, DaveShack, Zack
Zack: johnhughtom, Arjos, Ishmael
Memnon: edse
DaveShack: robbiecon
Chaotix: BSmith
edse: Memnon

I am glad that everyone voted today.

As there is a tie, I randomly selected one of tied players.

Ishmael was townie! He was insane vigilante

Night begins


Living:
1. DaveShack
2. Edse
3. Chaotix
4. BSmith
5. Robbiecon
6. Memnon
7. Arjos
8.
9.
10.
11.
12. classical hero replaced by johnhughtom
13.
14.
15. Zaccino

Dead:
Montmorency: town, cop. Lynched day 1.
Nightbringer: town, jailkeeper. Killed night 1.
Visorslash: mafia, informant. Lynched day 2.
The King: town, curious guy. Killed night 2
Atheotes: town, doctor. Killed night 2
Ishmael: town, insane vigilante. Lynched day 3

Hang on, according to the tally on page 4 The King wasn't a member of the Visorslash lynch. So if I were Judge Dread, how come I killed him?

...just realised, must have been a bus driver or something. Give me a moment to work out if this means anybody is lying.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ishmael

Hang on, according to the tally on page 4 The King wasn't a member of the Visorslash lynch. So if I were Judge Dread, how come I killed him?

...just realised, must have been a bus driver or something. Give me a moment to work out if this means anybody is lying.

---

wait wait wait....
I will check if there is any mistake

Well
it was my mistake. You were really an insane vigilante.

Now, the strange part is how I confused it...

Yesterday, me and my wife had our wedding anniversary. And, we have 'tradition' of making each other some practical jokes during this day.
It seems that my wife (who knows mafia pretty well, and discussed this game with me before I started it) changed a little bit here and there in my word documents for this game (almost half of roles)... Fortunately, I also found old versions of these files in a catalogue named 'was this joke fun'

Now, I am only waiting for her to see what she published on her facebook account...

Your wife sounds like an awesome gal. :bow:

That is pretty hilarious :beam: (well, maybe not for The King).

The day when he died, everything was as it should. The 'mistake' was introduced yesterday and resulted only in wrong role name I posted (there were other changes in my data, but they didnt surface here).
I am only grateful that it was seen now, not after the night. Fun is fun, but there was possibility of spoiling whole game for you, my dear players.

Ahahahahah, no harm no foul ^^

exactly....no harm no foul :yes:

belated wishes!


i dont like the Chaotix and Daveshack votes....all in all some sloppy voting by the town.

jonhughtom was killed.

he was a townie! he was a skitzo.

Day 4 begins. Day will be a little longer, because I am going for a trip.


Living:
1. DaveShack
2. Edse
3. Chaotix
4. BSmith
5. Robbiecon
6. Memnon
7. Arjos
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15. Zaccino

Dead:
Montmorency: town, cop. Lynched day 1.
Nightbringer: town, jailkeeper. Killed night 1.
Visorslash: mafia, informant. Lynched day 2.
The King: town, curious guy. Killed night 2
Atheotes: town, doctor. Killed night 2
Ishmael: town, insane vigilante. Lynched day 3
johnhughtom (previously classical hero): town, skitzo. Killed night 3

Vote: Arjos

Following bandwagons blindly.

Vote: Memnon The only one I've got anything on.

I can add that in addition to edse and Memnon, DaveShack is also innocent.

Vote: Zaccino, the other two who voted for him yesterday are confirmed innocents, and he voted for the third today.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zaccino

Following bandwagons blindly.

---

Is that so Mr. Commuter?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Arjos

Is that so Mr. Commuter?

---

Yes, it's exactly what you've been doing. I don't really understand what pointing out my role achieves, either. That's what I claimed.

@robbiecon -- Where is it written that Arjos is a confirmed innocent? edse's the one voting for confirmed innocents, not me.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zaccino

Yes, it's exactly what you've been doing. I don't really understand what pointing out my role achieves, either. That's what I claimed.

@robbiecon -- Where is it written that Arjos is a confirmed innocent? edse's the one voting for confirmed innocents, not me.

---

Nowhere at all. I just feel of the two of you, that you seem the more likely to be mafia. The only other two options I could choose are Chaotix and BSmith, given my night results.

But you said I voted for a confirmed innocent.

Quote:

---

Vote: Zaccino, the other two who voted for him yesterday are confirmed innocents, and he voted for the third today.

---

And why do you think I am mafia? Put reasoning behind your statements.

I'm not going to put up a claim sheet just yet, this being an extended day.

However, there are two possibilities:

Robbiecon is lying, in which case he is a scum partner with either edse or Memnon. Think the Memnon visit to John, atheotes death, etc.

Robbiecon is town and not being interfered with, in which case there are 4 confirmed innocents and the likeliest scum team is Zack & Chaotix.

There are 2 or 3 lynches left besides this one, so do as you will.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zaccino

That's what I claimed.

---

Gah, so you did, that ruined my double check, grrrr...

Vote: robbiecon

Right now, either you or another I know is lying; worst case your death clears all those players and the last two lynches are a lock...