Pirate Ship Mafia [Concluded]

Printable View

Show 80 post(s) from this thread on one page

10-18-2009, 03:36
Splitpersonality

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Well I'm sure the captain can speak loads for me, of what I can do.

I'd rather that people reveal to people they're comfortable doing it to, not everyone may trust our captain with their full and unedited role PM at this stage, I'm just saying there are alternatives, but we shall see how things work out tonight before confirming anything :P
10-18-2009, 04:14
A1_Unit

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Well I've made all my info public and I have nothing to hide.:beam:
10-18-2009, 12:44
Joooray

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Quote:

Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief

*SNAP! CRACK!!!*

Finally, everybody looked up. The mast, which had taken a direct cannon hit a day and a half ago thanks to the Four Horsemen, was finally starting to give way. Everybody looked on in horror as dozens of splinters flew down, a rather large one impaling Joooray on the neck.

"Oh... oh God!" somebody moaned, as Joooray, gasping for breath, staggered around the ship. Of course, the splinter happened to pierce his carotid artery. He would be gone now regardless of whether he fell off the ship or not. Meanwhile, pandemonium had taken hold of the crew.

"EVERY ABLE SEAMAN UP THE RIGGING AND TO THE MAST!" Captain Rabbit bellowed, with his officers already rounding up the crew. "TIE OFF THE BREAK WITH ROPE! TIE HER TIGHT, LADS, SHE'S GOT TO LAST US 'TILL WE MAKE PORT IN NASSAU!!!" Everybody was in action at once, running to and fro, climbing, fetching rope, and yelling. Nobody noticed Joooray, still gasping for oxygen, pass out and topple over the deck.

Thirty tense minutes later, and it seemed as if the mast would hold out, Rabbit finally allowed himself a moment to breathe. "Bleedin' Horsemen," he muttered to himself, and retired for the night.

Day 8 tally:

Joooray: 8 (White_eyes, A1, DiY, Subotan, CDF, TinCow, Yaro, Split) :skull:
Reenk Roink: 6 (Joooray, Seamus, Blackadder, Kukri, shlin, Centurion)
Yaropolk: 1 (Reenk)
Cultured Drizzt fan: 1 (Louis)
TinCow: 1 (ACIN)

Abstained: 1 (Crazed Rabbit)

Wohoo .. at least I had a fun write up. Thank you, GH. :bow:

Also, does anybody notice how none of the officers who were oh SO convinced of me being scum not voting for me. That's some really smelly fish right there.

As I said, I will be found innocent in 3 days and you guys will have wasted another lynch. Go town! :shame:

Quote:

Originally Posted by White_eyes:D

I spotted a "Not" in Jooray's Role PM:beam:

We have similar Quotes....but Jooray's is different:inquisitive:
Unless GH made a mistake...I am willing to bet its a Maven "Cover role":inquisitive:

Well, you can still believe that I'm scum all you want. This role pm was send to LG, w&f and me. It is an actually townie pm as you will see in 3 days.

I cannot reveal anything because of being dead now, I guess. But from where I'm standing that ~Styx quote indeed doesn't look too good for you actually. :smash:
10-18-2009, 13:04
White_eyes:D

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Quote:

Originally Posted by Joooray

But from where I'm standing that ~Styx quote indeed doesn't look too good for you actually. :smash:

More angry Scum:no:
10-18-2009, 13:39
Joooray

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Quote:

Originally Posted by White_eyes:D

More angry Scum:no:

Hey, I'm not saying you are scum, I'm just saying last time I heard about that ~Styx quote it was scum-related. :juggle2:
10-18-2009, 14:09
pevergreen

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

:laugh4:

Oh this is classic.

I guess I'll reveal now.

The quote at the top of your role pm?

Determines how you can (if at all)be converted.

The styx one is maven only.

The terrible loyalty is not at all.

Unsure of the other two.
10-18-2009, 14:28
Centurion1

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

so whats incorruptible than pever. i know do you?
10-18-2009, 14:34
pevergreen

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Read my post again...

Its ok Cent I already know your true role. :wink:
10-18-2009, 14:41
Death is yonder

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Quote:

Well, you can still believe that I'm scum all you want. This role pm was send to LG, w&f and me. It is an actually townie pm as you will see in 3 days.

And how do you know that...?

:inquisitive:

Only 3 people have your role? Interestink...

:inquisitive:
10-18-2009, 16:36
Joooray

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Quote:

Originally Posted by Death is yonder

And how do you know that...?

:inquisitive:

Only 3 people have your role? Interestink...

:inquisitive:

We have been over this. :inquisitive:
GH mistakenly send our townie pm to 4 persons openly, he then said he would not tell if he had rectified the mistake or not. Unfortunately we could not do any good with the situation, because Sasaki decided to make us his arch enemies and killed LG and w&f within no time. :shame:
10-18-2009, 17:19
Centurion1

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

sure jooray....
10-18-2009, 18:09
taka

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Quote:

Originally Posted by Joooray

We have been over this. :inquisitive:
GH mistakenly send our townie pm to 4 persons openly, he then said he would not tell if he had rectified the mistake or not. Unfortunately we could not do any good with the situation, because Sasaki decided to make us his arch enemies and killed LG and w&f within no time. :shame:

I confirm to the above, me jooray LG and W&F were originally a protection group until pizza asked to borrow one of ours.

i think the capt'n knows about this as i told him in one of the earlier pms
10-18-2009, 18:18
Joooray

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Quote:

Originally Posted by Centurion1

sure jooray....

:laugh4:

Fine don't believe me, but that's the way it is and I wasn't aware that it was something I was talking about since it had come up already some time ago and was then already discussed quite in-depth.

And come on, you can't make something like this up. :sweatdrop:
Also finally LG and w&f turn out to be honest able seaman and the only people I have been guilty of associating with were those two. How does that make me scum then?? :dizzy2:

So anyway ... it's a little late to defend myself. The ship wanted me dead and now they have to live with the dire consequences. (one townie dead when it could have been mafia :laugh4: )
10-18-2009, 19:11
Askthepizzaguy

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Hey Joooray if it's any consolation, I believe you.
10-18-2009, 19:24
White_eyes:D

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Quote:

I’m sailing away, set an open course for the virgin sea/I’ve got to be free, free to face the life ahead of me…
~ Styx

Seems pretty basic to me...:shrug: No people being depressed like yours...:inquisitive:

Quote:

We are all in the same boat in a stormy sea, and we owe each other a terrible loyalty.
~ G.K. Chesterton

"Terrible loyalty"? I would say your the Maven-convertibles if anything:laugh4:
10-18-2009, 19:56
A1_Unit

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

What do quotes matter when both mafias are almost dead and are not converting? However the person with the rapier ( I think he's the british officer) and the Pirate Tale Killer (Maven, Serial Kiler?:shrug:) seem to be the last threats aboard. But we need to be carefull and not vig kill each other unless we are sure the target is scum.:yes:
10-18-2009, 20:43
Yaropolk

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Quote:

Originally Posted by White_eyes:D

Seems pretty basic to me...:shrug: No people being depressed like yours...:inquisitive:

"Terrible loyalty"? I would say your the Maven-convertibles if anything:laugh4:

I'd say quite the opposite:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dictionary

ter⋅ri⋅ble /ˈtɛrəbəl/ Show Spelled Pronunciation [ter-uh-buhl] Show IPA
Use terrible in a Sentence
See web results for terrible
See images of terrible
–adjective
1. distressing; severe: a terrible winter.
2. extremely bad; horrible: terrible coffee; a terrible movie.
3. exciting terror, awe, or great fear; dreadful; awful.
4. formidably great: a terrible responsibility.
10-18-2009, 20:52
Louis VI the Fat

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Quote:

Originally Posted by Joooray

Also, does anybody notice how none of the officers who were oh SO convinced of me being scum not voting for me. That's some really smelly fish right there.

The officers? The officers didn't name you as scum. The Fab Four and Pizza did.

(But I fear my 'I knew Jooray was scum all along but Sasaki would have none of it!!1' was taken more seriously than it was intended. :embarassed:)

Me I went for Reenk because he's talking rubbish. But I decided to give him one more night to prove himself. My vote was on CDF to pressure him. Then the round ended already.

~~-~~-~~-~~:pirate:~~-~~-~~-~~

Quote:

Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy

Hey Joooray if it's any consolation, I believe you.

Quote:

People remaining from ATPG's original suspect list:

a completely inoffensive name
Joooray
miotas
Subotan
A Very Super Market

:book:
10-18-2009, 20:58
Askthepizzaguy

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

I put Joooray off of my suspect list, if you check. Due to him getting the same townie PM as others who were proven townie. Even edited the post saying something along the lines of "keep forgetting Joooray's alibi".

But no matter. I'm sure there was a reason we lynched him, right?
10-18-2009, 21:02
Louis VI the Fat

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Quote:

Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy

I'm sure there was a reason we lynched him, right?

Bandwagonning, players not sending in their orders so we didn't get our detective results, our focusing in previous rounds on the English first instead of the final Maven, and time constraints after first having to spend all day trying to establish what happened during that messy night.

Such is life. :beam:
10-18-2009, 21:18
White_eyes:D

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Quote:

Originally Posted by Yaropolk

I'd say quite the opposite:

Quote:

~ The thing I hate about an argument is that it always interrupts a discussion. ~ G. K. Chesterton

I don't think you can beat me with this Yaropolk:bounce:

Jooray was scum and I will stick by it till the end of the game....you all know how I guessed split was emergent scum:clown:
10-18-2009, 21:19
Reenk Roink

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Lynching Joooray was dumb, the only scummy thing he did was vote for me at the end to save himself.

I don't trust the officers aboard this ship whatsoever. CR I have been in contact with a bit more often recently, and he seems more trustworthy (maybe he just does a better job than Louis of acting like a decent and loyal Pirate) but his officers just go forth and run the show flinging poop on others while being coated with the most poop.

You may have gotten lucky to be caught investigating like a good boy on n4 Louis, but I'm watching you... :brood:

My guess is that Yaropolk and Louis are the last two bad guys.
10-18-2009, 21:23
Subotan

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Quote:

Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy

I put Joooray off of my suspect list, if you check. Due to him getting the same townie PM as others who were proven townie.

Any twit could have posted that, since it was practically public knowledge by the time he had released it.
10-18-2009, 21:27
White_eyes:D

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

I need to admit....I don't trust you Reenk:no:

You are acting WAY to paranoid to be a Pro-town....I could be wrong....but when you played as "The Watcher" you really kicked :daisy:.

I am having a bit of a hard time believing that you don't feel the need to share the results:inquisitive:
10-18-2009, 21:31
Reenk Roink

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Quote:

Originally Posted by White_eyes:D

I need to admit....I don't trust you Reenk:no:

You are acting WAY to paranoid to be a Pro-town....I could be wrong....but when you played as "The Watcher" you really kicked :daisy:.

I am having a bit of a hard time believing that you don't feel the need to share the results:inquisitive:

Fillet Royale had an anonymous letter system, you've got to be kidding me if you're going to compare the two situations... :rolleyes: And weren't you there in Prometheus when I shared all the results like a good boy? :rolleyes:

I've shared them with CR and told him NOT to tell his officers. Now if he does, his loss, as he blabbed to me to the whole town in the first place.

I don't follow these leaders because my decisions and ideas are the ones I like the most. :snobby:
10-18-2009, 21:36
White_eyes:D

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Yeah.....I see your point...:juggle2:

Well its all good then...:yes: But your still too dangerous....look how you 360'ed my wanting you dead...:sweatdrop::laugh4::laugh4:
10-18-2009, 21:53
Askthepizzaguy

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Quote:

Originally Posted by Subotan

Any twit could have posted that, since it was practically public knowledge by the time he had released it.

:inquisitive:

No, my friend, I think you misunderstood what I was saying.

As I recall from this very thread, Joooray was CC'ed the same able seaman pm as a few other townies, which was stated by the other townies who had his name up on the CC along with theirs. So the case isn't me being a twit, it's me pointing out that there were other dead now-proven townies who can vouch for him getting their same PM in one volley of PM deliveries. That's all. The only way he's guilty is if he was recruited. Because I highly doubt GH sent 6 mafia PMs and due to the mistake said "ha ha, starting mafia, one of you is no longer mafia. Now forget who your partners were. Forget. For-get...."

Once the mafia have their starting PMs, it's difficult to change this. You'd have to strip all of them of the status of being mafia and start over. No one mentioned this happening, and a townie would have reason to suggest that they were mafia until a host error took that away from them.

So even if joooray were mafia, which I'm not convinced of, he's still not the main target. I'm not saying this to go "ha ha wrong", I'm saying this as a reminder to give it some thought before we vote. As for bandwagonning, I am not sure how you lynch a mafia without several people voting for the correct target, which constitutes a bandwagon.
10-18-2009, 23:07
Louis VI the Fat

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Quote:

Originally Posted by Reenk Roink

Lynching Joooray was dumb, the only scummy thing he did was vote for me at the end to save himself.

I don't trust the officers aboard this ship whatsoever. CR I have been in contact with a bit more often recently, and he seems more trustworthy (maybe he just does a better job than Louis of acting like a decent and loyal Pirate) but his officers just go forth and run the show flinging poop on others while being coated with the most poop.

You may have gotten lucky to be caught investigating like a good boy on n4 Louis, but I'm watching you... :brood:

My guess is that Yaropolk and Louis are the last two bad guys.

Whatever.

You claim pro-town, you claim investigator, so share your results then with the town roles you've no doubt discovered.
Also, the English are gone. On N4 there were only single killers. So if you 'caught me investigating' (I doubt it) you know it wasn't me so you have your proof that I am not scum.

:playingball:

Quote:

Originally Posted by First Mate and the Non-Investigating Investigator

Reenk: 'Looky! I am an investigator. But I've been protecting the first two two nights!'
Louis: 'Sorry, but the very Watchstander role you claim doesn't allow you to do protections'
Reenk: 'Oh. Oops. Erm...I mean, uh...I did send in two protectiop orders which probably would've failed then!'
Louis: 'GeneralHankerchief's first night result would've told you that your protection failed. So there's no way you would've send in protection orders the second night again'
Reenk: 'Please people! Don't listen to Louis! He is full of poop!'

:inquisitive:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pirate and the Suspicious Person Caught Investigating

Watchstander: 'Reenk's been caught investigating, but he hasn't shared results with anybody'
Pirate: 'Maven can investigate too. It's in the rules....'
Reenk Roink: 'I'm a Watchstander! I've been protecting and doing investigations twice!'
Pirate: 'A Watchstander? And only two investigations?'
Reenk Roink: 'Oh, sorry. I mean three times!'
Pirate: Trice?'
Reenk Roink: 'Oh sorry. I mean five times!'
Pirate: 'Care to share results then?'
Reenk Roink: 'No! I do not share my results with anyone! And please, nobody trust the officers! They are full of poop!'
10-18-2009, 23:17
a completely inoffensive name

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

I don't know why but I am sticking behind Reenk, maybe its because I am paranoid also and I don't want a fellow cautious person to go needlessly.
10-18-2009, 23:33
pevergreen

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Quote:

Originally Posted by White_eyes:D

Seems pretty basic to me...:shrug: No people being depressed like yours...:inquisitive:

"Terrible loyalty"? I would say your the Maven-convertibles if anything:laugh4:

You serious?

Both myself and ATPG had the styx quote.

Show 80 post(s) from this thread on one page