In case you hadn't noticed, Jabbz, there's only ~15 minutes to the deadline.
Printable View
In case you hadn't noticed, Jabbz, there's only ~15 minutes to the deadline.
Just got back, here for the final 15.
Need me to do anything real quick?
No probs. Post away friend, reads are appreciatedQuote:
Originally Posted by Jabbz
If you did post that I didn't see it
Ok, now Cuth/Barto ?
I'm currently strategically for going Barto since he's contributed the least out of Zack/Cuth/GH/Barto and they seem to where we're actually currently at.
Am I even making sense?
And ftr the pulling back from Zack is mostly because Visor seems Villagery as hell Turbo-read-styles to me right now and wanted to give Zack another day.
Am I crazy?
I think you only have 15 minutes or so fyiQuote:
Originally Posted by Jabbz
I posted more about him later that dayQuote:
Originally Posted by Schema
At that time.you asked he had nothing at all so idk why you care
Nah, we're good with what you've given us.Quote:
Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief
Nah I agree with give Zack another dayQuote:
Originally Posted by Cass_
You're making sense and don't sound crazy to me.Quote:
Originally Posted by Cass_
yeah seems fine
Barto's on my list of people to shoot, so I'm 100% okay with his lynch should our Chancellor go that route.
What's your case against him?Quote:
Originally Posted by Schema
Honestly, if someone can explain to me why Cuth is scum beyond attacking Visor or voting a claimed PR I could consider going there.
Both those options seem like suicide to me if Scum and easy pickings for votes against him if he's Town.
thoughts on cuth/me/bartoQuote:
Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief
those are the possible lynchees other than yourself
it's not that he did those things, it's howQuote:
Originally Posted by Cass_
there was no logical progression
Monstr, this is probably total tinfoil but you sketch me out. Generally <3Quote:
Originally Posted by Monstrbro
Ily though
Stop smoking so much pot thenQuote:
Originally Posted by Cass_
No more crazy than the rest of us.Quote:
Originally Posted by Cass_
Let's put it this way. @Visor
I have LESS desire to lynch Zack than others. I haven't had time to read back through D2 to build a case on his overt towniness or scumminess, and so what I have to go on is my impression. If it were me in your shoes, I would too be giving him another day but keeping an eye open.
I think the fact that both the GH and Cuth wagons have been nice and full and going all day means that there's something there to pursue.
Renewed interest in Barto not bad, either.
In order of personal preference:Quote:
Originally Posted by Zack
- Cuth will provide resolution to the most things
- Barto's been around but hasn't been as much in the thread, not sure if this is a mafia tell for him or not but it probably isn't a good sign. See my most recent post.
- You're most likely town IMO.
You want me to switch Zack for Cuth, Cass?
It seems like I'm in a very small minority thinking there's anything to be suspicious about with the Z man.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Zack
Ok, is that reason strong enough for you to make him scum?
For me it begs the questions
But what's the logic behind it as scum anyway?
And do scum go nuts going loudly illogical ITT D1 ?
I think this is part of why I'm pretty down on Zack. I get an omgus on day 1, and I did make a rather egregious mistake, which was the grounding of my vote against him in the first place. What I don't get is him being on my case for the next 96ish hours. I will give him credit for not focusing solely on me, but despite the arguments he's put against others for why they might be scum, some of which are fairly solid, he still has me at the bottom of his list with nothing new to add.Quote:
Originally Posted by Cass_
The other part is that he is just making the game less fun to play. He's raging at people for daring to question him. I'm totally down with getting indignant as town when people call you on stuff that you feel 100% doesn't make you look scummy, but this is well beyond that. To each their own and all that, but I find it hard to give credence to arguments that are rooted in ad hominum attacks, ignoring entire posts, and claims like "look at how much I've posted" when a large portion of his posts are like the inside of a twinky, all fluff and filler, and bad for you if you ingest too much.
That being said however, I think there are much better options on the board for day2 lynch. Mainly this is because while I don't care for his style, and there are certainly questions about his arguments, I don't find them inherently scummy, just not overly effective for town, and other posts of his are. I do find him questionable enough however that I wouldn't be sad to see him and his angry posts go away, especially if they showed a nice red tag in the process. On the other side, if he popped town, that's a crapload of confusing posts to go through to try to extrapolate his takes on others in looking for future scum.
I agree with this assessment in 9/10 cases btwQuote:
Originally Posted by Cass_
(Which is why I've been village reading cuth)
Differences from first tally formatted with underline and italics.
Blue Green Red DISTRICT ONE Rep Chancellor Lynch Schema Dp101 Cuth Cuthillius Dp101 General Hankerchief Renata Dp101 Montmorency Dp101 Dp101 GH Jabbz Dp101 BSmith dicetosser1 El Barto DISTRICT TWO Winston Hughes Winston Hughes Zack BSmith Winston Hughes Cuthilius Visor Winston Hughes Visor Csargo Winston Hughes Riedquat Winston Hughes GH El Barto Visor Monstrbro Monstrbro General Hankerchief DISTRICT THREE Montmorency Cass Cuthilius Al Sipsclar Cass Monty Cass_ Cass El Barto GeneralHankerchief Cass Cuthilius Zack Zack Cuthilius atheotes Cass GH
I'm saying null not because of who he is, but precisely because he has done nothing of note in either direction. Granted, he could be trying to differentiate from last game, but I'll call it similar to old town Barto.Quote:
Originally Posted by Zack
To directly answer the question, if/when he gets real cases going later on, examine them closely as that's where the real cracks should show.
Personally, no, I'd rather not.Quote:
Originally Posted by Winston Hughes
But if it comes down to it I'm probably voting Barto over both of them for strategy because none of them are clearly scummy.
I'd hero shoot at Zack but doubt and giving him time and *shrug*
Preferences please @all
yes clearlyQuote:
Originally Posted by Cass_
i mean it's a oversimplification of things but there's no time for anything else
Differences from previous tally, that is.
My issue is cuth makes a lot of bad in game decisions so him doing one isn't clearing
This is a logical choiceQuote:
Originally Posted by Cass_
Idk if it will be right but I believe in you
The Visor-Cuth interactions weren't alignment indicative for me for either of them. It was his EOD maneuvers. That said, they aren't everything either. For his interactions with me, I didn't like how quick he was to make a read on me since I tend to be a scummier townie. A pocket attempt or whatever, it was too decisive. Lacked proper paranoia.Quote:
Originally Posted by Cass_
Cuth has a few town points for how engaging he has been, and posting old games threads. I caught that after my vote on him.
No meta to go off? Ehhh... GH/Barto probably the safest shots?
so much for democracy ehQuote:
Originally Posted by Cass_