Gotta have more Mafia [Concluded]

SSNeoperestroika was found beaten to the death with a baseball bat. His body was found floating in the nearby lake with the bloody bat on the shore.

Crazed Rabbit reported a robbery of his home.

Killed(6):
Discovery1 (Bus Driver)
Silver Rusher (Italian Mafioso + Romeo)
gertgregoor (cop)
Kommodus (mason)
GeneralHankerchief(cop)
SSNeoperestroika(mayor)

Suicide(1):
Drisos (Juliet)

Left Town(1):
Divinus Arma (Jerry)

Executed(3):
Orb (Chinese Mafia)
Zalmoxis (doctor)
Lemur (Tom)

Alive (12):
Reenk Roink
Crazed Rabbit
Cowhead418
Ice
Tiberius
evil_maniac_from_mars
Wonderland
Ignoramus
B_Ray
Sigurd Fafnesbane
doc_bean
Dutch_Guy

Voting begins.

What? What was robbed from my home? Hopefully not my precious beer. Uh, though I wouldn't have any of that since I'm not 21 yet....

Crazed Rabbit

Well this reasoning worked for Orb, so I guess it's worth another shot, best chance we have anyhow...

One kill + 2 mafia -> maybe held up by the robber ?

vote: Crazed Rabbit

guess Ill jump on the band wagon...

vote: crazed rabbit

edit: bolded

What's going on here?

There was one death last time, and I wasn't robbed. Now there's one death this time, and since I got robbed, I'm getting bandwagoned? Why am I being suspected?

Remember, the theif can't stop a mafioso from killing someone. Lynching me because I was robbed will not get you a dead mafia member.

I vote: doc_bean, as he was very quick to jump on me for no real reason at all.

Crazed Rabbit

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Crazed Rabbit

What's going on here?

There was one death last time, and I wasn't robbed. Now there's one death this time, and since I got robbed, I'm getting bandwagoned? Why am I being suspected?

Remember, the theif can't stop a mafioso from killing someone. Lynching me because I was robbed will not get you a dead mafia member.

I vote: doc_bean, as he was very quick to jump on me for no real reason at all.

Crazed Rabbit

---

Your reasoning is very solid. doc_bean saw a chance to accuse you based on past reasoning that worked. However, the shoe doesn't seem to fit this time around. I vote doc_bean.

What's the difference between then and now ? If you have a better idea (that's not me) then I'll change my vote.

And I posted so quickly because I had other stuff to do that day. Sheesh, with accusations like this it's no wonder I can leave the org for half a week and find only 2 new posts in the mafia game.

EDIT: Sasaki said the roles weren't exactly the same as on the wiki, so the thief could stop a mafia member, that's still what I believe happened to Orb
EDIT2: also Cowhead follows CK's rather flawed logic (really, I posted too fast ?) and then decides blaming me is a good plan, maybe the mafia is still a little bitter about me getting one of theirs lynched ?

I don't know why you all are voting against doc_bean...

He was the one that expanded on the work of the heroic beer-borrower and found Orb guilty.

Certainly there was flawed logic this time, but that doesn't make him guilty at all. In fact, due to his previous action, I would say that he is the least likely among us to be a mafia...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Reenk Roink

I don't know why you all are voting against doc_bean...

He was the one that expanded on the work of the heroic beer-borrower and found Orb guilty.

Certainly there was flawed logic this time, but that doesn't make him guilty at all. In fact, due to his previous action, I would say that he is the least likely among us to be a mafia...

---

I agree. He helped us find the mafia, using reasonable logic. Look at my vote to see who I think is gulity...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by doc_bean

What's the difference between then and now ? If you have a better idea (that's not me) then I'll change my vote.

And I posted so quickly because I had other stuff to do that day. Sheesh, with accusations like this it's no wonder I can leave the org for half a week and find only 2 new posts in the mafia game.

EDIT: Sasaki said the roles weren't exactly the same as on the wiki, so the thief could stop a mafia member, that's still what I believe happened to Orb
EDIT2: also Cowhead follows CK's rather flawed logic (really, I posted too fast ?) and then decides blaming me is a good plan, maybe the mafia is still a little bitter about me getting one of theirs lynched ?

---

Well, it's just that only one person was killed last round too, so your logic is flawed this time. However, I have changed my mind somewhat. There really is not much to go on anyone right now (which is kind of strange this late in the game). Evil Maniac from mars was wrong in both his accusations, so he is either a bad cop or a mafia. There is only one way to find out for sure.

Unvote: doc bean
Vote: evil_maniac from mars

I will go with doc_bean’s theory on this one. It worked once and it could work again. Besides, I believe EMFM is a cop even though he is the paranoid one.
Vote: Crazed Rabbit

Wow, I'm still alive? Isn't it some tradition to knock a guy off when he leaves for 3 days?

As for the vote.. I have to agree with the reasoning of doc_bean.

Vote: Crazed Rabbit

Guys, let's look at this logically.

Last time, there was one death, and I was not robbed.

This time, I was robbed, and the number of deaths is the same.

The number of deaths is the same, whether or not I was robbed! I'm not the cause of the deaths!

Remember, just last time, everyone ganged up on Zalmoxis after that one death and we killed an innocent. You guys won't kill a mafia by lynching me.

Crazed Rabbit

I still find it difficult to imagine how getting Robbed means you're a mafia, maybe the fact he called the police to report a burglary actually saved his life.

Keep in mind, there also was but one kill last round.

:balloon2:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Orb

-snip- Sasaki

---

QUIET, YOU!

Sasaki said he lost his PM's, perhaps he lost some info about the kills/robbery ?

Personally I think there isn't a psychopath but that there is a vigilante. Just one that was a little to eager at first :idea2:

Four kills at first.

Two mafia branches: 2
Psycopath: +1
Vig.: 1

The first time there was 1 attempted kill (Tiberius) and 2 succesful kills (2 mafia + vigilante ?), Drisos commited suicide because his love died. I don't remember there ever being four kills :help:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Orb

-snip-Sasaki

---

I really think you should stop breaking the rules of this game, Orb.

Apologies, Sasaki said he'd remove overly speculative posts from the dead. Although I'm using no more knowledge than a common man.

He can delete these if he wants to.

Well I posted a couple of links pointing to pages describing roles of the game and that got deleted, I don't see why those wouldn't.

Vote count:

Crazed rabbit: 4
doc_bean: 2
emfm: 1

Still 5 people not voting. C'mon people.

Vote: Crazed Rabbit

Vote:evil_maniac from mars

:balloon2:

Dangit, this is the last time I report a robbery.

Crazed Rabbit

Um, guys. If there is one person more innocent then doc_bean it's Crazed Rabbit.

1) If he was the mafia, he would have been held up, and there would be no kills.

2) There was a kill.

3) Crazed Rabbit is not a mafia.

Thanks for the support Roink, but I don't know how much good it'll do. Oh well.

I guess I'll vote for EMFM, in a last attempt not to get lynched.
Unvote: doc_bean
Vote: EMFM

Crazed Rabbit

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Reenk Roink

Um, guys. If there is one person more innocent then doc_bean it's Crazed Rabbit.

---

You have to give us some good arguments to support this claim. Why should we trust you on this?

Well, here's my post from earlier:

Quote:

---

Guys, let's look at this logically.

Last time, there was one death, and I was not robbed.

This time, I was robbed, and the number of deaths is the same.

The number of deaths is the same, whether or not I was robbed! I'm not the cause of the deaths!

Remember, just last time, everyone ganged up on Zalmoxis after that one death and we killed an innocent. You guys won't kill a mafia by lynching me.

---

Bandwagoning me because I was robbed makes no sense.

Crazed Rabbit

It seems that thinking CR couldn't have done the murders because he was held up isn't exactly a popular idea amongst the other villagers...

Quote:

---

You guys won't kill a mafia by lynching me.

---

That's - as you are well aware of - the Cliché defence. Needless to say we're going to need proof.

:balloon2: