Pirate Ship Mafia [Concluded]

If this is a question of mechanics, the three-tiered investigation systems works like so, with a few wrinkles:

1. What you were doing that night
2. Susceptibility (and only that)
3. True affiliation

That explains sigurd then. And pizza, I don't see any posts by Seamus for the past 3 days.

Ah, I see. Still, I am suspicious. Sigurd, excellent mafia player that he is, would know those rules. He'd also be likely to know that he would most likely be investigated starting the first night, so that he could participate in evil mafioso activities on night two.

What have you been up to, Sigurd? You've been rather non-talkative through PMs and in the thread. Something in my gut makes me rather suspicious of you.

CR

Vote: Askthepizzaguy

:antlers:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rudolph

Seamus was my protection group partner (the other two were YLC (n1) and gibson (n2) both of who I had worse feelings about, unlike Seamus who is probably innocent. (YLC dropped out though, that explains his actions - gibsons was vig killed, so nothing conclusive yet)

Why do you want to kill the buddy who I have a good feeling about Pizza?

---

Vote:Kukrikhan

More opinionated than usual.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by a completely inoffensive name

I'm going to wait to vote for a bit until there is a clear person we are bandwagoning on since no one seems to have any clue what is going on or who is mafia.

---

Good advice. But it seems the bandwagoning has already started.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Louis VI the Fat

@Subotan - I was probably wrong. See Rabbit's post above. Most likely the English special officer ('godfather') investigated.* One lieutenant converted. And one lieutenant was free to do to whatever perfidious business it is they do. Possibly, join a vig group.

---

Ah I see. I just forgot how the British faction worked.

Vote: Lord Winter

Explain your vote. :stare:

Some one give a tally so it is clear who we are ganging up on.

Vote: ACIN

Make one yaself, ya lazy dog.

vote:Lord Winter Argh! In true pirate fashin' I be joining that there bandwagon! Yarr - Argh!

VOTE: LORD WINTER!

Who ever heard of a pirate bein' a Lord? I be bettin' he's one o' them British guv'nors't thinks 'e can hide in plain sight! And then he ain't explainin' his votes! He must be a mute, too!

LORD WINTER'S A MUTE BRITISH GUV'NOR WHO'S HIDIN' IN PLAIN SIGHT! LET'S SEND 'IM OFF THA PLANK! YARRR!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Chaotix

VOTE: LORD WINTER!

Who ever heard of a pirate bein' a Lord? I be bettin' he's one o' them British guv'nors't thinks 'e can hide in plain sight! And then he ain't explainin' his votes! He must be a mute, too!

LORD WINTER'S A MUTE BRITISH GUV'NOR WHO'S HIDIN' IN PLAIN SIGHT! LET'S SEND 'IM OFF THA PLANK! YARRR!

---

A spicy meatball if ever I saw one.

FoS: everyone wagoning on Lord Winter

Your all mafia... Or lazy townie:smash:
I would've done the same if I couldn't think of anything to say

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by pevergreen

Vote: ACIN

Make one yaself, ya lazy dog.

---

Why are you voting for me in all my mafia games! ******* A man.

Vote: pevergreen

Haha, I get what's coming to me after viggin' Quintus in Capo.

Still, find who killed me and keep an eye on them. I forget the mechanics, if townies can become mafia by killing or what; in any case, they are doing more harm than help if they are randomly killing in a game like this.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TinCow

Vote: Lord Winter

Explain your vote. :stare:

---

Random vote as no one else had voted yet. I don't see how that makes me mafia.

Quote:

---

vote:Lord Winter Argh! In true pirate fashin' I be joining that there bandwagon! Yarr - Argh!

---

Unvote: Yaropolk
Vote: A1unit

Bandwagoning as well as trying to keep a low profile without contributing anything.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by A1_Unit

vote:Lord Winter Argh! In true pirate fashin' I be joining that there bandwagon! Yarr - Argh!

---

unvote:Kukri
Vote:A1_Unit

unvote, vote: A1_unit

I'm glad other people are finding him suspicious now.

I will forgo Rule #1 for now.....this bandwagon stinks of scum:inquisitive:
Vote:A1_Unit

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy

unvote, vote: A1_unit

I'm glad other people are finding him suspicious now.

---

What was it you found suspicious about him earlier?

I'm matching the way he sounds to psycho mafia.

Yeah, he's pretty suspicious. Vote:A1unit

It should be noted that it's supremely silly to vote someone for bandwaggoning in this game. That would be saying there's 20 or so mafia, there's been tons of bandwagon votes.

I do love how many people are bandwagoning A1 Unit as punishment for bandwagoning. :laugh4:

No suspicion? Just extended OMGUS? Fine by me!

Vote: Lord Wintah

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Sasaki Kojiro

What was it you found suspicious about him earlier?

---

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy

Vote: A1_Unit

You don't sound like a pirate, mate. And I'm not even referrin' to yer woeful lack of sailor talk. I can't account fer what ye be up to last night, and the way ye be playin' the game smells of havin' a yeller streak runnin' down yer back. What are you hidin', you landlubber?

---

My original complaint was his abstain vote. Add that to the senseless bandwagon on Lord Winter, and a guarded reply to private communications. The problem I have with it is that he seems to be trying to avoid controversy at all costs.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Sasaki Kojiro

It should be noted that it's supremely silly to vote someone for bandwaggoning in this game. That would be saying there's 20 or so mafia, there's been tons of bandwagon votes.

---

If you and ATPG are finding it suspicious....(Like oil and water:laugh4:)

Then something is up.....plus I just find the bandwagon out of place....and he IS trying to fly under the radar...:juggle2:

Unvote: ACIN, Vote: A1_Unit
Why not?

I was pressuring for an explanation on LW, which we now have. Amazing how fast bandwagons start in this game.

Unvote; Vote: Abstain

Ahoy there, me hearties!

I be askin again because it seems ye not be hearin me.

Will a couple of ye vote for Sigurd? I be havin' a bad feeling about him, and I think a little pressure would do the crew good.

I be askin' not for a bandwagon or even a lynch at this time, just some votes to put him near the top of the lynch list.

CR

Graaaaaarrrrr
A bandwagon looks like fun.

Unvote: A1_Unit, Vote: pevergreen

Vote: Sirgurd, under orders of me captain.

THE CRAZED RABBIT "Captain" be giving you all orders...:whip:
https://i43.photobucket.com/albums/e...9/100_0154.jpg
Unvote:A1_Unit Vote:Sigurd

Sure why not, Vote Sigurd.

Vote: Sigurd

WHY... THE... FLAPJACK... NOT? :dizzy2:

unvote, vote: Sigurd

If I work real hard, I might vote for everyone this round.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Chaotix

VOTE: LORD WINTER!

Who ever heard of a pirate bein' a Lord? I be bettin' he's one o' them British guv'nors't thinks 'e can hide in plain sight! And then he ain't explainin' his votes! He must be a mute, too!

LORD WINTER'S A MUTE BRITISH GUV'NOR WHO'S HIDIN' IN PLAIN SIGHT! LET'S SEND 'IM OFF THA PLANK! YARRR!

---

UNVOTE

VOTE: LORD WINTER SIGURD!

Who ever heard of a pirate bein' a Lord Berserker? I be bettin' he's one o' them British guv'nors privateers't thinks 'e can hide in plain sight pretend 'e's a quartermaster! And then he ain't explainin' his votes silence! He must be a mute, too!

LORD WINTER'S A MUTE BRITISH MAVEN GUV'NOR PRIVATEER WHO'S HIDIN' IN PLAIN SIGHT N' MASQUERADERIN' AS A QUARTERMASTER! LET'S SEND 'IM OFF THA PLANK! YARRR!

Actual quote:

Diana Abnoba: (watching football) Anything going on in the pirate game?

Askthepizzaguy: Yes. It's comically disastrous.

If'n the Cap'n don't trust his own hand-picked ossifer, who am I t' be contestin' it?

vote: Sigurd

Speak up, Sir.

Vote: Sigurd

If thats what captain wants

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Crazed Rabbit

I be askin' not for a bandwagon
CR

---

:juggle2:

Unvote: pevergreen; Vote: Sigurd

MUTINY..against the quarter master?

Ye cannot mutiny against the quartermaster, especially if the Captain be askin' for ye votes.

Sasaki be right, though. There be enough votes on Sigurd for now. Let us here him talk.

CR

unvote, vote: The Stranger

He's been suspiciously quiet.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy

unvote, vote: The Stranger

He's been suspiciously quiet.

---

:dizzy2:

Vote: Andresthecunning aka andrestheNOTsocunninganymore?

How strange!

vote: The Stranger

Myrddraal has been suspiciously quiet as well.

Oh God, this is turning into another "AndrestheNOT SO Cunning" moment. :laugh4:

I want his opinion. I'm threatening him with a lynch if he doesn't chime in.

Don't question me on this!

Unvote: Lord Winter, Vote: TosaInu

Whats up with MRD? Why has he been so quiet.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy

I want his opinion. I'm threatening him with a lynch if he doesn't chime in.

Don't question me on this!

---

Why not?

Don't question it triple a

Stop trying to peve me off, you strand of green algae!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Double A

Why not?

---

Because I'm a busy man and I can't explain all my ingenious reasoning, which is clearly superior! I'm Askthepizzaguy, and you WILL follow meeeeeeeeee

Yes sir, sorry sir, won't happen again sir!

I am a little suspicious of Crazed Rabbit. I hadn't interacted with many, and n1 he never came up with a protection group when he planned on including me in one.

Is Crazed Rabbit even playing?

What is the case on Sigurd besides he didn't do a night action last night? I thought GH said a second investagation wouldn't reveal that sort of information anyway.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy

Is Crazed Rabbit even playing?

---

How can you not know who our capt'n is? That seems like something an English spy would say

vote atpg

Do not waste another lynch by voting for Sigurd IMO....

OMG, what are you guys doing, your all over the place. I don't even have any idea what the tally could poss. be. Vote: Abstain for now, until after the football games, then I can check my notes.

Back to proper conversation of the game?

This entire thing on sigurd seems a bit placed.

The investigation gives nothing, and we've got your feeling?

You arent confirmed town CR. More than likely you are, but even so.

British didnt kill last night, but recruited. I can't imagine it takes 3 to recruit. probably only one, like the writeup wasnt it?

So: 1 to recruit, 1 to probably check for more recruits and...HMMM.

You? Sigurd? (I think seamus is the other position? cant remember)

My money would be on you, if I had to pick. Only because sigurd was doing protections and i dont know who the third is

I don't really suspect CR or sigurd because they volunteered for a position which was bound to get them investigated.

I hereby declare this the least enlightening phase of any mafia game I have ever played. It is curiously like being hit in the head with a sledgehammer, and then being forced to watch a Michael Bay movie.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by pevergreen

Back to proper conversation of the game?

This entire thing on sigurd seems a bit placed.

The investigation gives nothing, and we've got your feeling?

You arent confirmed town CR. More than likely you are, but even so.

British didnt kill last night, but recruited. I can't imagine it takes 3 to recruit. probably only one, like the writeup wasnt it?

So: 1 to recruit, 1 to probably check for more recruits and...HMMM.

You? Sigurd? (I think seamus is the other position? cant remember)

My money would be on you, if I had to pick. Only because sigurd was doing protections and i dont know who the third is

---

First of all, it doesn't take three to recruit for the British. But if I read the rules right, the British can't kill and recruit in the same night (with their initial three players).

Secondly, I suspected Sigurd of being a Maven crew member, not being British.

CR

Oh right.

Well...uhhhh

Look, a mouse!

*runs away*

Aaaaar, ye sure ye don't want to play go fish with him?

Vote:Sigurd :dizzy2::dizzy2::dizzy2::dizzy2: Captain's orders.

:focus:

Someone should vig kill slashandburn tonight.

:laugh4: I knew the reference wouldn't be missed.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Sasaki Kojiro

Someone should vig kill slashandburn tonight.

---

Wonder who will do it.

Tally:
Lord Winter: 2 (A1 Unit, AVSM)
Sigurd: 9 (splitpersonality, White Eyes, Yaropolk, SSNeo, slashandburn, Chaotix, Kukri, Beefy, ACIN)
ATPG: 2 (Reenk, Captain Blackadder)
pevergreen: 1 (pevergeren)
A1 Unit: 2 (Lord Winter, Sasaki)
The Stranger: 2 (ATPG, Double A)
TosaInu: 1 (Tratorix)

CR

unvote, vote: A1_unit

Suspect from last round, as described above. Vote not needed on Sigurd.

You were voting for TS.

unvote: pevergreen, vote: A1_Unit

On someone that deserves it, methinks.

Bah, my vote is useless right on TS!

Must... plank someone! AAAAAAAR!

unvote, vote: A1_Unit

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TinCow

I hereby declare this the least enlightening phase of any mafia game I have ever played. It is curiously like being hit in the head with a sledgehammer, and then being forced to watch a Michael Bay movie.

---

Hmmmm. Almost siggable, though I thought the delivery was a bit forced. 8/10 :clown:

Anyway, Unvote, Vote: Askthepizzaguy. For starting this whole "voting for people who aren't in the game" derail.