-
Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
The United Nations backs the Goldstone Gaza War report
Quote:
Reporting from Jerusalem and The United Nations - In a vote likely to complicate U.S. efforts to revive Middle East peace talks, the United Nations Human Rights Council on Friday endorsed a report calling on Israel and Hamas to conduct credible investigations of alleged war crimes by their forces or face further international inquiries and possible prosecutions.
The action in Geneva by the 47-nation council was a sharp setback for Israel, which had labored to discredit the month-old U.N. report. The council's vote could force Israel to defend itself for months or perhaps years -- in diplomatic forums, if not criminal tribunals -- as U.N. bodies grapple with highly charged fallout from last winter's conflict in the Hamas-ruled Gaza Strip.
Although the council embraced a report that condemned both sides, the resolution itself criticized only Israel and was adopted by a wide margin.
For the Obama administration, the decision represents a new obstacle to its goal of negotiations to establish a Palestinian state. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu had warned that an international stamp of approval for the war crimes allegations would prevent Israel from "taking risks" to reach a statehood accord. And the U.S.-backed Palestinian leadership in the West Bank, after first accepting that argument under U.S. pressure, reversed its stand and pushed for Friday's vote.
With only the United States and five European allies objecting, the council, dominated by developing nations, fully endorsed the findings and recommendations of an expert panel led by South African jurist Richard Goldstone that investigated the Gaza conflict.
Twenty-five nations, including Russia and China, voted for the resolution promoted by Arab members, and 16 nations abstained or did not vote. Egyptian Ambassador Hisham Badr, a key supporter, told the council that it "cannot turn a blind eye to the deteriorating human rights situation in the occupied Palestinian territories."
State Department spokesman Ian Kelly said the United States voted against the measure out of concern "that it will exacerbate polarization and divisiveness" and undermine special U.S. envoy George J. Mitchell's work to restart peace talks broken off in December.
"What's distressing us," Kelly said Friday, "is that we're losing focus on this ultimate goal, which is a lasting peace between the Israelis and the Palestinians."
A spokesman for Mahmoud Abbas, president of the West Bank-based Palestinian Authority, called for the U.N. report's full implementation "to translate words into deeds" and "protect our people in the future from any form of aggression."
Israel's Foreign Ministry said the council's decision "provides encouragement for terrorist organizations worldwide" by condemning one state's efforts to defend itself against a militant group.
The Goldstone panel said Israel used disproportionate force, deliberately targeted civilians and destroyed civilian infrastructure. It accused the Islamic militant group Hamas of deliberately targeting Israeli civilians with years of cross-border rocket fire leading up to Israel's 22-day offensive, which left 13 Israelis and nearly 1,400 Palestinians dead.
The report urged the U.N. Security Council to require both sides to show within six months that they are conducting impartial investigations; failing that, it said, the Security Council should refer the allegations to prosecutors at the International Criminal Court based in The Hague.
The resolution adopted Friday will not necessarily lead to war crimes trials. Rather than call for Security Council action, it urged debate in the U.N. General Assembly, which lacks authority to refer cases to The Hague, and asked U.N. Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon to report on whether Israel was heeding the report. A U.N. spokeswoman, Michele Montas, said Ban was studying the resolution and would "do whatever is asked of us."
Israeli officials worry that U.N. debates and inquiries will further isolate the Jewish state and encourage private lawsuits against Israeli officials and soldiers in countries that accept jurisdiction for war crimes beyond their borders. Last month, British activists tried, but failed, to get a British court to order Israeli Defense Minister Ehud Barak's arrest during his visit to London.
The Israelis have rejected the U.N. report's recommendation for a special inquiry on their conduct in Gaza. They argue that Israel has an independent judiciary that can review any outcome of the military's ongoing investigations of 23 cases involving civilian deaths. Some Israeli officials have called for an independent review by Aharon Barak, the former head of the nation's Supreme Court, but that idea has failed to gain traction.
While welcoming Friday's vote and calling for trials of Israelis, Hamas said it would investigate the U.N. allegations against it. The United States and European Union, along with Israel, brand Hamas a terrorist organization and give no credence to that promise.
Israeli officials said they were powerless to stop the resolution. But even their lobbying for solid Western opposition fell short when Britain and France chose not to take part in the vote.
British Foreign Secretary David Miliband told the BBC that Britain and France sat out because it would upset efforts to restart peace talks and persuade Israel to end its crippling blockade of Gaza. But delegates from both countries in Geneva said they took the war crimes allegations seriously.
source: http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/n...bref=obnetwork
Another interesting video here. It's Al-Jazeera though, right-wingers please don't go all insane. Thank you.
======
Well, Judge Richard Goldstone has finally brought forth his report, about a week ago the UN Security Council has accepted the the report brought forward on the Gaza War. This meaning that both Israel and Hamas will have to conduct their own investigations within six months or they will be referred to the ICC in The Hague.
25 countries, including the big fish Russia, China and India voted in favour of the report, while six voted against, including the United States of America, and the Netherlands.
My opinion: It's good that Israel has lost its position of being untouchable (interestingly Ehud Barak also might have faced an arrest in the United Kingdom a short time ago. If they fail to manage to conduct their own investigation which will have to be approved of by the UN, otherwise they will be tried in the Hague. Just like the people in Bosnia.
It's interesting to see, eh. I'm not anti-Israel, and it's a good thing that Hamas is also facing consequences, it's a shame though that almost all the attacks are directed towards Israel (although it's really not that surprising). In any case, if Israel is tried for war crimes, we might see interesting things.
Two things should happen: The (ultra)orthodox Jews should get the idea of their minds they were for some reason predestined to live in that land, and the Arab nations will have to accept that the Jews are there and most likely will not leave. Once we get the extremists from both sides to the court room, there will be room for the moderates to discuss.
Hey, it's not impossible, even Israel and Iran have negotiated. :2thumbsup:
I think that Judge Richard Goldstone is one of the most respectable people on the planet and should at least get a Nobel Peace Prize (instead of Hussein Obama, for example).
Peace out,
- Hax
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Israel doesn't accept the legitimacy of the ICC, having not ratified the agreement. Therefore, no on from there can be brought before it.
What a just world we live in.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Israel doesn't accept the legitimacy of the ICC, having not ratified the agreement. Therefore, no on from there can be brought before it.
What a just world we live in.
Actually, there's something to that. The Palestinian Authority is trying to get approval by the United Nations to be accepted as a member state for the ICC. If they agree, the ICC will have jurisdiction to judge any person that commits crimes within the borders of the member state in which the crimes have been perpetuated. :2thumbsup:
Might be something, eh..you never know.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
If they agree, the ICC will have jurisdiction to judge any person that commits crimes within the borders of the member state in which the crimes have been perpetuated.
No need, these constitute grave violations of the4th so there is universal jurisdiction which means any signatory can bring them to court.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
the UN is in no position to dictate about morals to Israel. we took a risk in pulling out of gaza with the UN telling us that they would come to our defense. for years rockets fell on civilian populations and the UN was silent. we fight back, they go nuts. besides most western nations didnt vote for it. now what does that tell you about it?
what a load of :daisy: idiots, the UN all are. a joke, thats what they are. run by thugs and liars. (sorry i had to vent.)
Bibis speech to the UN was magnificent. that is all i will say about the matter, coming to the realization that debate here is futile. :wall:
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Well, y'know, Hooah...
There's more to the world than just Israel. There's more to the world than just Palestine. Both sides have committed atrocities. We should learn from our mistakes.
Judge Goldstone is Jewish and has a lot of respect from the South African people. He is a man with loads of experience. If there's anyone fit to handle the situation, it's probably him.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Hamas to conduct credible investigations
Have fun with that, UN.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
the UN is in no position to dictate about morals to Israel.
Yes it is.
Quote:
we took a risk in pulling out of gaza
No you didn't, neither did Israel for that matter.
Quote:
with the UN telling us that they would come to our defense.
:laugh4::laugh4::laugh4::laugh4::laugh4:
Quote:
for years rockets fell on civilian populations and the UN was silent.
Bollox
Quote:
we fight back, they go nuts.
They went nuts because it appears the State was flagrantly commiting war crimes against civilians.
Quote:
coming to the realization that debate here is futile
Thats sad, over time your knee jerk reactions to any subject mentioning Israel had matured and moderated.
You appear to have regressed
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
the UN is in no position to dictate about morals to Israel.
Because you are the choosen ones? Like in "Highlander"?
Newsflash, the UN is ALL about dictating morals to individual states. One might even argue that is the reason why the UN exists!
Quote:
we took a risk in pulling out of gaza with the UN telling us that they would come to our defense.
Some rabbid rabi told you this? I would love if you gave some links to support it, because from all I have read, that is... Just wrong.
Quote:
for years rockets fell on civilian populations and the UN was silent.
How many civilians did those rockets kill? In the meantime, how many civilians did israel kill? And let's face it, the UN wasn't really silent, nor the world press. I even heard about it in backwater Austria.
Quote:
we fight back, they go nuts.
Well, if less civilians and ordinary citizens would get hurt in your "fight back" I dont think many would have a problem. Israel is a modern state, you have the technology to limit non-military casualties. You just choose not to. Are you suprised people react?
Quote:
besides most western nations didnt vote for it. now what does that tell you about it?
It tells me that most western nations thinks we might aswell build a wall around both countries, throw in some weapons occasionaly, and show it on prime-time TV.
Quote:
what a load of :daisy: idiots, the UN all are. a joke, thats what they are. run by thugs and liars. (sorry i had to vent.)
Yeah, cause anyone not agreeing on Israels stance in their conflict is thugs and liars. Not to mention nazis. Remind me again, how many civilians has Israel killed? Is it more or less than the other side? You cant have the belief that one israeli life = 10 others and have it agreed on world wide.
Quote:
Bibis speech to the UN was magnificent. that is all i will say about the matter, coming to the realization that debate here is futile.
When I say that debate is futile, I would rather point at individual cases than general ones :wall:
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
I wish there could be a way to erase that whole region. World would be much nicer then.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Ibn-Khaldun
I wish there could be a way to erase that whole region. World would be much nicer then.
You know, I could say the F-word and get banned...
But a statement like yours is quite ok... AMERICA, :daisy: YEAH!!!!
However, I am still in favour of building walls and throwing in weapons, broadcasted on live-TV at prime-time :idea2:
He "wished there were" (subjunctive, hence clearly hypothetical) and did not single out any particular nation/culture for cultur bashing. So yes, his statement DOES pass muster as an expression of frustration (however unrealistic). SF
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Kadagar_AV
AMERICA, :daisy: YEAH!!!!
Knee-jerk very much, huh? What makes you think the post you responded to is in any way related to the US?
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Ser Clegane
Knee-jerk very much, huh? What makes you think the post you responded to is in any way related to the US?
Uh, actually that was <- to a popular movie where nationalistic moral algorithms were seen as a saviour of the free world in a very sarcastic way.
Nationalities aside :shame:
EDIT: One might also ask who Israels biggest supporter is.
EDIT no. 2: Isn't it kind of strange that a forum allows someone to claim a whole region should be erased, while at the same time banning people for using the A-B-C-word? Sometimes one would rather have the thought-police than the word-police ;)
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Hooahguy
the UN is in no position to dictate about morals to Israel. we took a risk in pulling out of gaza with the UN telling us that they would come to our defense. for years rockets fell on civilian populations and the UN was silent. we fight back, they go nuts. besides most western nations didnt vote for it. now what does that tell you about it?
what a load of :daisy: idiots, the UN all are. a joke, thats what they are. run by thugs and liars. (sorry i had to vent.)
Bibis speech to the UN was magnificent. that is all i will say about the matter, coming to the realization that debate here is futile. :wall:
Rubbish, bombing the hell out of Gaza was totally unjustified and pretty much an unmitigated military failure as well
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Philipvs Vallindervs Calicvla
Rubbish, bombing the hell out of Gaza was totally unjustified and pretty much an unmitigated military failure as well
Wait, are you talking about when the Palestinians bombed the hell out of gaza or when the israeli bombed the hell out of gaza...
Cause for a layman like me, I am really struggling here...
From my humble point of view, yeah, both sides should be up for Haag...
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
I am with Hooahguy. All this nonsense, it basicly comes down to Israel not having the right to defend themselves because they aren't helpless. The Dutch killed entire villages in Indonesia. The French killed entire villages in Algeria. The rape of Africa. And we weren't even under attack, we have no moral authority here.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Kadagar_AV
EDIT no. 2: Isn't it kind of strange that a forum allows someone to claim a whole region should be erased, while at the same time banning people for using the A-B-C-word? Sometimes one would rather have the thought-police than the word-police ;)
What can I do.. All that unwillingness to solve their problems as matured people is giving me a headache. :shrug:
You know there is a saying(I try to translate this to English):
"Little boys solve their problems with fists but men solve their problems with words."
So.. Now you know what I think about those who are in power there..
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Ibn-Khaldun
"Little boys solve their problems with fists but men solve their problems with words."
That's what mommy says. Dad says grab an end of wood and kick their butts. Dad is right.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Fragony
I am with Hooahguy. All this nonsense, it basicly comes down to Israel not having the right to defend themselves because they aren't helpless. The Dutch killed entire villages in Indonesia. The French killed entire villages in Algeria. The rape of Africa. And we weren't even under attack, we have no moral authority here.
The UN isn't the Netherlands or France. And 1940's isn't the 2010's.
I heavily applaud this resolution. Let's see if the Israeli start treating the Palestinian offensives with a little more precaution from now on, and not do "Here's the objective, accomplish at all costs, :daisy: the rest".
EDIT: And indeed, the greatest blow is possibly that the decision to compel Israel and Hamas to investigations was done by a Jewish judge who believes in the right of Israel to exist.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Jolt
The UN isn't the Netherlands or France.
It's the nobel peace prize of coalitions who takes the UN seriously nowadays, muppet show. What authority do they think they have can't just make things go away the UN should be ignored.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Fragony
It's the nobel peace prize of coalitions who takes the UN seriously nowadays, muppet show. What authority do they think they have can't just make things go away the UN should be ignored.
Enjoy your world war 3.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
CountArach
Enjoy your world war 3.
Kinda funny you say so, WW1 was a coalition falling apart over something minor after all. And nowadays it's meaningless, once again they want too much too fast.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Frag, are you forgetting that Israel was created by the UN?
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
CountArach
Frag, are you forgetting that Israel was created by the UN?
Are you forgetting that deserving people have won the nobel peace price?
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Except, that if you want to safeguard the lifes of people, you generally don't bomb hospitals.
If they wanted to safeguard the lives of civilians so dearly, they should have sent out an expert team of snipers, for example.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Hax
Except, that if you want to safeguard the lifes of people, you generally don't bomb
hospitals.rs
If they wanted to safeguard the lives of civilians so dearly, they should have sent out an expert team of snipers, for example.
Maybe it helps to not be shooting rockets from a hospital, but that thought seems to really confuse people. And I have no idea why. They are sacrificing their own just for good pictures. These aren't human beings they are the scum of the earth, it's a media war and Israel is the frontline.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
These aren't human beings
Dehumanization is the first step to genocide. :2thumbsup:
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Hax
Dehumanization is the first step to genocide. :2thumbsup:
If you ever meet someone from that place, be sure to ask what nice guys these Hamas are.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
If you ever meet someone from that place, be sure to ask what nice guys these Hamas are.
They are still humans.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Hax
Except, that if you want to safeguard the lifes of people, you generally don't bomb
hospitals.
If they wanted to safeguard the lives of civilians so dearly, they should have sent out an expert team of snipers, for example.
When your enemy stores munitions in churches, you blow up the churches.
Don't be an armchair general. You have no idea of the tactical situation on the ground.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Hax
They are still humans.
I know some people who would get very upset if you said that in their face. Hamas is scum, they kill people for singing at wedding party's it's a death-cult.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
I know some people who would get very upset if you said that in their face.
So what? They are still humans, and this is something we should never ever forget. We're still dealing with people who share the same emotions as us.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Hax
We're still dealing with people who share the same emotions as us.
No we aren't, these people are completely different.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
They experience sadness, love, hate, anger, compassion, fear, happiness, just as we do.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Hax
They experience sadness, love, hate, anger, compassion, fear, happiness, just as we do.
Sure, but if the mods will allow a little straightforwardness, I believe that the problem is Islam itself.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Fragony
Sure, but if the mods will allow a little straightforwardness, I believe that the problem is Islam itself.
Ok... This is just getting scary... :no:
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Kadagar_AV
Ok... This is just getting scary... :no:
Stockhom Syndrome by Proxy, that is scary
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Okay, can we lock this thread now? It's going nowhere. Or rather, where this topic always goes.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Sure, but if the mods will allow a little straightforwardness, I believe the problem is Islam itself.
Deleted by Moderator, borderline personal attack.
To begin, "Islam" is not just one big bloc. There are numerous schools/sects, including Ismaili, Druze, Aveli, and many others. How can you claim that Islam is Deleted? This truly is sickening.
Mods, I request a deleteion of that comment since it is hateful and no less than pure xenophobia in its worst form and insulting to the numerous Muslim members of these forums, and in violation of .org rules:
Quote:
# Posts containing any generally objectionable material: knowingly false and/or defamatory, inaccurate, abusive, vulgar, hateful, harassing... ...any kind of "flaming", slurs, or insults -- addressed to either an individual or a group -- is extremely inappropriate. Please respect etiquette at all times.
This discussion is not about Islam. This discussion is about Israel and Palestine.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Vladimir
When your enemy stores munitions in churches, you blow up the churches.
Don't be an armchair general. You have no idea of the tactical situation on the ground.
Not with the congregation inside, which is exactly why Saddam moved hostages into his weapons dumps.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Philipvs Vallindervs Calicvla
Not with the congregation inside, which is exactly why Saddam moved hostages into his weapons dumps.
Yes with the congregation inside and with a million babies guarding the perimeter if the target is valuable enough. It's likely Israel conducted whatever cost/benefit analysis their military uses to make such a call.
So you're saying we shouldn't destroy those ammo dumps? If the incident you're referring to happened, it was Saddam who committed the war crime, not the country who blew the dump. He used the same tactic with his command and control centers. Hamas is not above such tactics.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Fragony, dont get me wrong. I def do not hold muslims in high esteem, and I truly wish there were fewer of them around in Sweden. However, I am thinking you are going sliiiightly over the line here.
As to the topic.
Am I the only one finding it, well, kind of natural that both sides has been found to commit war crimes?
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Kadagar_AV
As to the topic.
Am I the only one finding it, well, kind of natural that both sides has been found to commit war crimes?
Not at all. In a sense, war itself is a crime, and I suspect rules are constantly broken in this conflict.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
A few "blanket" slurs and some "edged" responses. Play nice folks.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
I'm no Islamophobe/Anti-Semite, but I'm just wondering; does Hamas support the reintroduction of the Sharia Legal System, and if so, would that provide a pretext for rejecting the UN Courts?
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
@Subotan: Not officially, but there are cases of Hamas instituting laws of Shariah.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Huh. Besides, it's probably not going to reject the findings of a trial that will probably (and rightly) find Israel responsible for various war crimes.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Don't get it wrong, Hamas will be tried as well. Judge Goldstone has said that the UN has been lax in viewing Hamas' conduct. Hamas will be tried as well.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
I know, but it's to be expected that Israel will come out worse than Hamas.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Yeah, but why shouldn't they? There are different ways of judgement for different crimes. We'll see.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Fragony
Are you forgetting that deserving people have won the nobel peace price?
Errrr....... what?
If you mean Obama didn't deserve it then you might recall... I agree...
But still - what are you on about? :inquisitive:
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
CountArach
Errrr....... what?
If you mean Obama didn't deserve it then you might recall... I agree...
But still - what are you on about? :inquisitive:
I called the UN the nobel peace prize of coalitions. Who takes it seriously anymore with all these nasty regimes being allowed in it, became too much and ended up being nothing at all. United Nations against Israel would be a more apropiate name.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Fragony
I called the UN the nobel peace prize of coalitions. Who takes it seriously anymore with all these nasty regimes being allowed in it, became too much and ended up being nothing at all.
Ugh, that reminds me of McCains proposal to have a "League of Democracy". Whether we like it or not, there are "bad" countries out there, and excluding them from the UN would only force them into a rival power bloc, Comecon/Central Powers/Axis style.
Quote:
United Nations against Israel would be a more apropiate name.
Yes, because for the past 60 years, Israel has constantly been harassed and persecuted by every other country on the planet. How excellent that we can view things in proportion!
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Gah, we should stop treating their reality as a social experiment. The arabs will never accept a jewish state on 'íslamic soil;, never going to happen.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Fragony
I called the UN the nobel peace prize of coalitions. Who takes it seriously anymore with all these nasty regimes being allowed in it, became too much and ended up being nothing at all.
Open communication with regimes is incredibly important. We can't just go out guns blazing and kill all the bad guys in the world - we have to achieve something diplomatically.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Fragony
Gah, we should stop treating their reality as a social experiment.
Who says we are?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Fragony
The arabs will never accept a jewish state on 'íslamic soil;, never going to happen.
Oh? Then why have Egypt and Jordan recognised Israel? They're more realistic than you are.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
CountArach
Open communication with regimes is incredibly important.
For those regimes it really is, for us less so. There is really nothing to discuss, what shall we talk about, people disappearing, torture.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Fragony
For those regimes it really is, for us less so. There is really nothing to discuss, what shall we talk about, people disappearing, torture.
Yes. Yes indeed.
Try raising human rights with China without discussing human rights with China.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Fragony is quite right, we should cancel our diplomatic ties with the United States.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Hax
Fragony is quite right, we should cancel our diplomatic ties with the United States.
I wasn't going to say it, but I'm glad someone did :wink:
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Fragony
For those regimes it really is, for us less so. There is really nothing to discuss, what shall we talk about, people disappearing, torture.
Hmmm... What was that other country I heard that about? It can't have been the US, the beacon of light... The US would never, say, torture people or make people disappear... :idea2:
Quote:
United Nations against Israel would be a more apropiate name.
Agreed. Cause it's not like Israel could do anything wrong... :juggle2:
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Kadagar_AV
Hmmm... What was that other country I heard that about? It can't have been the US, the beacon of light... The US would never, say, torture people or make people disappear... :idea2:
Don't act too dissapointed, beacon of light no, despite the Messias. Better than these regimes yes, where would you rather have an opinion on the government, the west, or the rest.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
I'd rather have America as the sole superpower of the world than any of the other potential candidates.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Kadagar_AV
Agreed. Cause it's not like Israel could do anything wrong... :juggle2:
It isn't that Israel can't do anything wrong, and nobody says that, it's that Israel is being disproportionately targeted by them.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
I'd rather have Europe as the sole superpower on the world than any of the others. ~;)
Just because something is the best available doesn't mean it can't be improved. I thought that was part of America and capitalism, to strive for the better at all times, even when you're on top. So stop whining and try to improve things, it's the American way. :2thumbsup:
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Husar
I'd rather have Europe as the sole superpower on the world than any of the others. ~;)
I'm not quite as keen on that. ~;)
Quote:
Just because something is the best available doesn't mean it can't be improved. I thought that was part of America and capitalism, to strive for the better at all times, even when you're on top. So stop whining and try to improve things, it's the American way. :2thumbsup:
That is precisely why I prefer America to any of the other alternatives.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
I'd rather see India as the sole superpower, but lets leave that aside for now.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Hax
They are still humans.
I would say that to anyone. Shoot me if you want. This killing is stupid. I wish that people would grow up!
Blah blah .. I shoot you .. I am stronger than you .. balh blah blah ..
Stupid .. Idiocy ..
Just like WAR!!!
We should learn from the past and not make the same mistakes again ..
However .. Humans are stupid.. and they will never learn...
I still believe that erasing that whole region would benefit the world!
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Well, you could indeed state the whole Israel - Palestine conflict is just one of a some angry kids with weaponry.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Hax
Well, you could indeed state the whole Israel - Palestine conflict is just one of a some angry kids with weaponry.
I have seen enough videos of kids with weapons shooting each other so i am too pissed off.
I am not anti-Jew but this whole Israel-Palestinian conflict is becoming ridiculous!!
Stupid humans .... Stupid Humans!!!:wall::wall::wall:
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Welcome to pessimism!
Every nation has it's agenda. None are out for the good of us all. Is it better to support a nation that you believe is right, or a nation you believe is similar to yourself?
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
got it, apreciate his style but it's kinda onesided. Or really. So is Gorazde.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Fragony
got it, apreciate his style but it's kinda onesided.
He does say at the end that he'd like to come back to Israel and do a book about the Israeli side of the conflict, as he didn't have the time or the space in his book to do so. He does get snippets of their side in though, from time to time, and besides, all you have to do is turn on CNN/NBC/FOX in order to get the Israeli side of the story.
Quote:
Or really. So is Gorazde.
Well, Gorazde is about the town of Gorazde, so it's going to be focused on Bosniaks/Croats. He has done a few stories on the Serbs though.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Subotan
He does say at the end that he'd like to come back to Israel and do a book about the Israeli side of the conflict, as he didn't have the time or the space in his book to do so.
I think it's pretty obvious. It is really good, but it's not very right imho.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Subotan
He does say at the end that he'd like to come back to Israel and do a book about the Israeli side of the conflict, as he didn't have the time or the space in his book to do so.
I think it's pretty obvious. It is really good, but it's not very right imho.
The Fixer: A Story from Sarajevo (Paperback) <- never heard of this one, ordered.
-
Re: Israel and Hamas possibly facing a trial