Originally Posted by English assassin
Sorry, that won't do. To win a test match you have to bowl the other side out twice. If you let them make 700 or so runs in their two innings you probably won't have time to do that, whoever you are and whatever the weather. OK, a lot of play was lost in the fifth test, but even with a full sixth day its not at all obvious there would have been an Aussie victory. They didn't manage a first innings lead, after all.
And, there were only 14 overs played in day 3 at the Old Trafford test, and at the end of that test Australia were 50 odd runs short of their target with no wickets left and Lee and McGrath at the crease. Which is to say, even ten more overs, heck, even five, and they would have lost. So without good ol English weather the series would have been effectively over at 3:1 to England at the start of the fifth test.
Australia are still a very good side and they played as well as they could. England are also now a good side, and on their day either side could beat the other. Australia could certainly have tied the series and retained the Ashes. Weather, (unfair) bad luck, substitute fielders, had nothing to do with the result, that's what made it such a great series between two very closely matched teams.