Quote Originally Posted by Sasaki Kojiro
HAH! I wondered if a mafioso would be so foolish. I'm one of the real detectives.


Here's my pm, notice Kage didn't bother to include his, wasn't up to faking it I suppose. Of course now he doesn't have too, but whatever.
Right. If we would follow his advice and kill you, he would have been exposed as a fraud and we would have killed him next round, that makes no sense. Your defense seems to suffer from the same problem, but then it might be a desperate last stand...

I say we lynch at least one of you !

Quote Originally Posted by Sasaki Kojiro
Nope I wasn't contradicting myself. Last game, any small chance at taking a mafioso was worth it (we had 2 mafia and 1 detective). This game (when I posted) we had more power roles than mafia, so a random lynch was obviously not to our advantage. I was also interested to see who would try and lynch anyway. The two of you seem quite eager.
I'm always eager for a kill, you should know that by now

But onto your argument: who's to say the mafia hasn't already gotten one of the good guys ? Who's the say the odds haven't turned in our favour already ? And what about next round, two more people will be dead, will it be in our interest to lunch people then ? Yes/No ? The odds would probably still be against the good guys. Now we have a chance of killing a mafia member, tonight's victims will surely be innocents...

Besides, active debate sometimes makes the mafia make mistakes (like not participating, or saying too much, it's win-win for the townies) AND it allows the detectives to be subtle, with few people posting/voting, those that do and point out the right people will immediately become targets.