
Originally Posted by
TinCow
I understand your point, Andres, and agree to a certain extent. However, I have never found Day 1 comments to be of much use in finding mafia. Since truly random and joke votes are acceptable, there is really no way for a mafioso to look suspicious on the first vote unless they make an absurd error. 2 votes each on 15 different people would not give me any more information than the current double-bandwagons, simply because we accept a complete lack of reasoning as acceptable on any vote. Every time I've tried to find something of value in Day 1 comments, I've failed or been completely wrong. That's not to say that I ignore them, but it certainly limits the utility of the analysis. On Day 1, I think I actually do more harm by analyzing the posts too much than I do by voting randomly or without reason.
Bookmarks