no kills????
anyways im gonna push on with my no lynch theory:
vote: abstain
edit, just want to add
YLC stated he had "a few" night orders to do, so i'm assuming that hell of a lot happened, but our pro-town is managing to deal with it so far.
Re: Whispers in the Night - Mafia Game (IN PLAY)
no kills????
anyways im gonna push on with my no lynch theory:
vote: abstain
edit, just want to add
YLC stated he had "a few" night orders to do, so i'm assuming that hell of a lot happened, but our pro-town is managing to deal with it so far.
Last edited by taka; 01-24-2009 at 06:01.
Tainted Evil, Reenk's synopsisOriginally Posted by Reenk Roink
Act all cool and stuff, only taka knows about your true noobness.
Gunfight at the O.K Corral
Re: Whispers in the Night - Mafia Game (IN PLAY)
*ahem*
My write up was missing a part of itself. The write up has been corrected, please read it over again.
Sorry for the inconvenience
Re: Whispers in the Night - Mafia Game (IN PLAY)
right, so ares probably turned into a ghost and was killed again during the night is what im assuming. which means that pro-town IS doing their job.
guys i 100% urge EVERYONE to VOTE ABSTAIN and carry on letting pro-town do their job.
if ANYONE votes during this round, then THEY ARE the mafia/badguys
Tainted Evil, Reenk's synopsisAct all cool and stuff, only taka knows about your true noobness.
Gunfight at the O.K Corral
Re: Whispers in the Night - Mafia Game (IN PLAY)
ATPG was dealer for a hard game of an Italian version of Blackjack that lasted 3 hours. Somehow, ATPG walked away with everyone's money.
WHAT????
I am flattered, but... why? Is this a clue? AND I KNOW I LOOK LIKE A TOTAL-ish MAFIA by asking such a "naive" question,
(according to my own mafia behavior pattern analysis)
But I am seriously wondering why the host is focusing on me. I haven't voted. I am a townie. The people who are dead are supernatural and killing people, except for the lynches.
I haven't contributed to night deaths or day deaths, and why would money be important in a game with...
Ahem.
Was that a reference to the Golden Rule mafia, Askthepizzaguy leaving with everyone's money?
Are your clues references to previous games?
#Winstontoostrong
#Montytoostronger
Re: Whispers in the Night - Mafia Game (IN PLAY)
And don't you DARE accuse me of WIFOM tactics.
Seriously, anytime anyone ever questions anything about why the host would indicate them in the writeups, someone comes out of the woodwork and screams bloody WIFOM until we are all dead.
STOP IT.
Think with me for a second. Is there a pattern that could relate to previous games? Me leaving with everyone's money is an OBVIOUS reference to the Golden Rule game. But I'm not prominent in all the writeups... other people star in them.
What's the deal?
#Winstontoostrong
#Montytoostronger
Re: Whispers in the Night - Mafia Game (IN PLAY)
Hmmm...well, everything is a clue, and if you always look at the clues right, you will always get the right answers. I cannot say whether or not your are correct in your assumptions, and that goes with everyone postulating about your current predicament.
Last edited by ULC; 01-24-2009 at 06:33.
Re: Whispers in the Night - Mafia Game (IN PLAY)
Let's play a game. A thought experiment, if you will.
HUMOR ME.
Spoiler Alert, click show to read:
Ok, ASSUMING I am not mafia for one whole half a split second, work with me on this thought experiment: Most of you have intimate knowledge of previous games and their outcomes. I am not the most senior player here, some of you old fogies KNOW more than I do, regretfully. I need your help to analyze this, assuming I am right. Which games is the host referring to? Or is this a dead end?
Senior citizens, Askthepizzaguy needs YOU for mafia analysis.
#Winstontoostrong
#Montytoostronger
Re: Whispers in the Night - Mafia Game (IN PLAY)
YLC, may i ask who were the "couple of people" with ATPG for the black jack? write-up doesnt really say...
Last edited by taka; 01-24-2009 at 06:31.
Tainted Evil, Reenk's synopsisAct all cool and stuff, only taka knows about your true noobness.
Gunfight at the O.K Corral
Re: Whispers in the Night - Mafia Game (IN PLAY)
GH and tevash were the final "survivors" in my game... could it be them?
GH isn't even in this game though. That's the wrong analysis. What else...
Former mafia buddies of mine???
Seireikhaan and Reenk Roink
It refers to the Prometheus, if this is the correct interpretation.
#Winstontoostrong
#Montytoostronger
Re: Whispers in the Night - Mafia Game (IN PLAY)
It is not supposed to say who was playing with our Italian friend for a reason.
And everything has a reason behind it in this game.
Re: Whispers in the Night - Mafia Game (IN PLAY)
Nevermind.
It doesn't make sense why I'd be winning all their money.
You get an idea, you get excitied... I'm a dumb
#Winstontoostrong
#Montytoostronger
Re: Whispers in the Night - Mafia Game (IN PLAY)
atpg, i think you have a role. and your role is to keep people up at night to save them from things. and nab a bit of money from them at the same time
Tainted Evil, Reenk's synopsisAct all cool and stuff, only taka knows about your true noobness.
Gunfight at the O.K Corral
Re: Whispers in the Night - Mafia Game (IN PLAY)
That would be SWEET.
Sadly, I have no role, that I am aware of. I am unfortunately a lynchable, murderable townie who is NOT getting where YLC is going with this.
Suggests I was more on track with the "other games clue" back a few posts. The rest, I kind of veered off course.
#Winstontoostrong
#Montytoostronger
Re: Whispers in the Night - Mafia Game (IN PLAY)
Forget what I was talking about 2 seconds ago.
Read all of Taka's posts, one after the other.
He was online night two. He was online all of night three.
He was just online now, having a conversation with YLC I believe.
He knows a bit too much for the average townie. He has the following mafiascum pattern:
Spoiler Alert, click show to read:
And no, I wasn't talking to myself, but at the end the guy asked me why I didn't post in the thread and I said "Better to think before we act" and he said "who is we" and I said there were lots of me.
It was funny. haha.
Now, the point is, I can't be bothered to make the above nonsense readable at the present second. However, READ ALL OF TAKAS POSTS IN ORDER, and you will see what I mean.
Yeah it looks like total trash. I'll clean it up.
Get to it. Tell me what YOU think of him.
#Winstontoostrong
#Montytoostronger
Re: Whispers in the Night - Mafia Game (IN PLAY)
Vote: Abstain
I'm in agreement with Taka
Re: Whispers in the Night - Mafia Game (IN PLAY)
Ordinarily I'd be too.
I believe that taka is directing town to remain docile so that he can do his dirty deeds, however, based on how he's been posting and when he's been active, such as at night time.
I am aware that the case isn't ironclad, and that's why I'd prefer to question his behavior rather than simply start a bandwagon.
In doubt, it's ok to be more cautious. If I were sure, I'd kamikaze him too.
#Winstontoostrong
#Montytoostronger
Re: Whispers in the Night - Mafia Game (IN PLAY)
And I'm also aware I called for people to be more cautious with their votes for this game, too...
And I know it can be seen as hypocritical, and as different from previous games. However, each game is different and requires a different strategy. A game involving the supernatural, and dead people being able to kill us, we would be better off lynching the right person, not just any person.
But due to his repeated requests to more or less control how the town behaves, I have to wonder just how innocent his suggestions are.
I'll probably be lynched for daring to make a suggestion that someone besides me is guilty, but hey, such is life, and I'll eat you all after I am dead.
I always seem to get more dangerous when I die.
#Winstontoostrong
#Montytoostronger
Re: Whispers in the Night - Mafia Game (IN PLAY)
Aye aye!
Re: Whispers in the Night - Mafia Game (IN PLAY)
I already said you guys could lynch or murder me at your convenience.
I hear the spirits calling me. This isn't even WIFOM... I kind of want to be dead so I can see what it's like in this game.
Anyone want to kill me? No? Yes? No?
Either way is fine. If we're going to play me like a townie, I'd go with Taka. If you think I'm mafia, lynch me so I can eat you. Thanks.
#Winstontoostrong
#Montytoostronger
Re: Whispers in the Night - Mafia Game (IN PLAY)
Hmmm... why did Quintus wake up with a headache?Is he some kind of a blocker or something that "Kept everyone awake"?
Vote: Abstain for now
Re: Whispers in the Night - Mafia Game (IN PLAY)
It... is... flippin... freezing... in... this... garage.....
Pointing little mini heater at my freakin face.... I shouldn't have taken a nap in here, I shouldn't have... dang it's cold.
Ok. I have several more minutes of useful consciousness before I die of exposure, so I can go back and restate a case against Taka, in a way that might be something you peeps can follow.
In the meantime, bear with me.
#Winstontoostrong
#Montytoostronger
Re: Whispers in the Night - Mafia Game (IN PLAY)
Sorry, not much time during W-E.
I'm going to Vote : abstain.
I heard rumours about angry spirits being able to kill. I think taka is on to something.
Andres is our Lord and Master and could strike us down with thunderbolts or beer cans at any time. ~Askthepizzaguy
Ja mata, TosaInu
Re: Whispers in the Night - Mafia Game (IN PLAY)
Can you explain why you think Taka is onto something?
What are these rumors?
You can lynch me for being inquisitive, but I will keep talking. I would like a real discussion. Do you have answers, Andres?
*if you have something to add to Chicago, I'll abstain from the discussion here and focus on that*
Last edited by Askthepizzaguy; 01-24-2009 at 18:46.
#Winstontoostrong
#Montytoostronger
Re: Whispers in the Night - Mafia Game (IN PLAY)
Ok, now that Chicago is done, I need to work on this game.Spoiler Alert, click show to read:
I need to restate my case in a brief, concise way.
Here it is:
Taka
Votes abstain: 28
sowing doubts about others post 34.
Online at night post 65, joking, not solving the case.
Votes abstain: 88
Says he's in the library. I actually believe him.
Talks about WIFOM arguments, quicpost with smiley 93.
Votes Reenk. 94. Says what he could do would make him look scummy, which is overly defensive. Repeats his alibi.
Says he has no role, and he's bored. 96.
Cool under fire, 99. Points in his favor.
Quickpost with smiley, joke. 101
Agrees with me, but doesn't add to the discussion here. 103
Mr. taka is all over the night two writeups. not sure why. 120.
Quickpost with smiley, asks question, lols, smiley again 122.
Disagrees with a particular bandwagon 131
Taka is all over the night three writeups, was online night three. 133
Votes shlin. quickpost with smiley. 135.
Decides to tell town not to lynch anyone. 145 Abstains.
Doom and gloom 151. Scumtell.
Sucks up to me post 161, tells about "zombie versus ghost", posits new theory which is plausible. Bold mafia or townie. Asks priests to contact him... scummy, or townie, I am not sure.
Quickly reverses himself 165 after I scold him.
Andres votes Taka,
odd reasoning 167, but plausible.
Brilliant contribution 168, or mafia leaving false or self-incriminating clues. Not sure.
Posts another theory. Two theories... occam's razor suggests he's too bold to be mafia, but it's not proof. Quickpost 169
States a plausible defense 171.
Urges town not to lynch anyone, in a game where the dead can kill us or the mafia can. 175.
Even more creative theories 175. Now hold on... that's VERY brilliant. Or VERY scummy.
Asks if creative is good or bad, attention good or bad. Nowhere near a vet yet... too modest. Odd... 177
Urges town to abstain again 190. Why? I sort of agreed with it, but now I am not sure.
Taka is all over the previous day post 196.
EVER MORE CREATIVE THEORIES 203.
Too good to be a townie, I can't believe I'm saying that. 203.
Knows YLC only too well 205.
Oddly self-incriminating joke 207.
Odd post 208. Explain>?
Alive and active night four. How convenient.
urges everyone to abstain again 213.
innocent sounding question, posed to the HOST though. Scummy. 218.
Says I have a role in a silly post with a smiley 222.
Do you follow why I think he's questionable by now?
Last edited by Askthepizzaguy; 01-24-2009 at 19:16.
#Winstontoostrong
#Montytoostronger
Re: Whispers in the Night - Mafia Game (IN PLAY)
If Andres does not return at some point in the next couple days and explain what he meant by his previous post, I have to put him at number two on the scum list.
Fair warning, my friend. I trust you have an explanation.
Vote: Taka if I have not already.
#Winstontoostrong
#Montytoostronger
Re: Whispers in the Night - Mafia Game (IN PLAY)
I'm not following into a bandwagon that easily again!
To ATPG: What's wrong with Abstaining? For lack of better info, isn't it better to abstain and preserve our strength? Even if Taka is evil, don't we have a buncha pro-town roles who can stop kills and who knows what else, we may even have an investigator! So why not let them sort it out and let us relax in the sun.
I think you've become too paranoid
Re: Whispers in the Night - Mafia Game (IN PLAY)
You should know better by now than to be dismissive of me. That really angers up my blood.
Do you want to try again?
Even if Taka is evil, don't we have a buncha pro-town roles who can stop kills and who knows what else, we may even have an investigator!
This is REALLY scummy reasoning. Even if Taka is a scumbag, let's leave him be???
Explain yourself.
Last edited by Askthepizzaguy; 01-24-2009 at 19:33. Reason: grammar
#Winstontoostrong
#Montytoostronger
Re: Whispers in the Night - Mafia Game (IN PLAY)
Sorry, didn't mean to anger you... *backs away into a corner*
I'm just saying that if he is scum, there may be roles who can hold him in check, rather then basing it on some post analysis that although is very good, but not definite. Surely in this game, where we have no idea what we are against, it is better to conserve the town's numbers and get the power roles to do the badguyfinding.
Re: Whispers in the Night - Mafia Game (IN PLAY)
Very well. I would be willing to give Taka a reprieve while the mafioso or the investigators/blockers/whatever we might have go after him.
But Now I am suspect of you for defending him without a good reason. Do you offer yourself to be lynched instead?
#Winstontoostrong
#Montytoostronger
Re: Whispers in the Night - Mafia Game (IN PLAY)
To reiterate, it is in our best interest to conserve the town's numbers rather than lynching the most suspcious per a normal mafia game; so I thought it was quite reasonable for me to step in to defend Taka, given that he has not been online for 13 hours.
Also, I humbly ask not to be lynched
Reply With Quote
Bookmarks