Netherworld Mafia [Concluded]

[Andres]

Post #363, about 2/3 of the way down towards his sig. Bolded and ever'thin'.

Are we ignoring me?

[Seamus Fermanagh]

Are we ignoring me?

Well, at the time I hit "quote" on his post, I hadn't read yours.


I take your point, but...

My witch-doctor in CN2 was a false "reveal" with all sorts of details and interesting quirks. It worked on the principle of the "great lie" -- so big that it can't be unreal.

TinCow seems to be using minimalism -- offering nothing and no support -- just doesn't jibe with a "big lie" effort. That's why I'm skeptical. Is it a "reverse" big lie -- possibly -- but it seems too risky an effort and too quickly found out.

I have no doubt that he'll be the focus of study by "holmes" and our SamSpado Demons -- if he's dirty, we'll have a nice reveal and a necktie party then.

I picked Joe as a tool to not lynch Kommo, who is valuable if he's not trying to pull wool over everyone. Again, I'd like a little time there -- though I agree with you that unlimited time isn't appropriate either. We're over 400 posts now, so when he gets home from work we SHOULD start to see something.


Did you ever address my from earlier?

[Andres]

TinCow seems to be using minimalism -- offering nothing and no support -- just doesn't jibe with a "big lie" effort. That's why I'm skeptical. Is it a "reverse" big lie -- possibly -- but it seems too risky an effort and too quickly found out.

I have no doubt that he'll be the focus of study by "holmes" and our SamSpado Demons -- if he's dirty, we'll have a nice reveal and a necktie party then.

Hmmm...

Why do you think Kommodus is above all doubt innocent?

I picked Joe as a tool to not lynch Kommo, who is valuable if he's not trying to pull wool over everyone. Again, I'd like a little time there -- though I agree with you that unlimited time isn't appropriate either. We're over 400 posts now, so when he gets home from work we SHOULD start to see something.

First: you used your vote on Joe to avoid getting TinCow lynched, not Kommo. Second, where exactly did I demand for Kommo to post 'holmes' results? 'holmes' has proven it's worth in the past, but it has failed as well. Also, we shouldn't rely too much on a non confirmed innocent to find the mafia for us. That's laziness.

Did you ever address my from earlier?

Yes, I can be a pitbull. You never noticed before?

The way I see it, either Tin Crow or I are mafia, or we are strong pro-town.

So, according to you, you can be mafia? Is that a confession?

The roles we have seen suggests a role that can raise the dead, a role that can block a killing, and the mafia. If both TC and I have claimed we have a strong pro town role, that either means that we do indeed both have a strong pro town role, or one of us is lying. We would not have claimed such an important role unless the stakes were high, and we were not mere townfolk, and if we were both mafia then we would not have drawn attention to both of us.

I suspect that their will be an attempt on either of our lives tonight. The mafia will of course try to kill one of us assuming that we can either bring back the dead or protect someone from their attacks. If you lynch someone else then the two of us tonight, we will have a clearer view on who is mafia, and who indeed had a special role.

Interesting post.

[BananaBob]

So, according to you, you can be mafia? Is that a confession?

According to me the town has no way of knowing other then my word.

[Makanyane]

According to me the town has no way of knowing other then my word.

if you're going to claim "a role" you should expect the rest of us to ask what it is , - and saying its either mafia or pro-town isn't a reason for us not to lynch you


so having decided to proclaim yourself important you might as well say what role is, and try and convince us you're worth keeping alive!

If you're not mafia - they will already think you have pro-town role so you're not losing anything else by telling town what it is and asking for protection (*I think - confess to still being confused*)

[Kommodus]

if you're going to claim "a role" you should expect the rest of us to ask what it is , - and saying its either mafia or pro-town isn't a reason for us not to lynch you


so having decided to proclaim yourself important you might as well say what role is, and try and convince us you're worth keeping alive!

If you're not mafia - they will already think you have pro-town role so you're not losing anything else by telling town what it is and asking for protection (*I think - confess to still being confused*)

Agreed. TinCow claims there are odd things about his role that make it unwise to reveal at the moment. Are you claiming this same thing? If not, why not tell us your role?

[GeneralHankerchief]

Can anyone find out if Makanyane responded to TinCow in the same way she did to BananaBob when TinCow claimed power town?

[BananaBob]

Agreed. TinCow claims there are odd things about his role that make it unwise to reveal at the moment. Are you claiming this same thing? If not, why not tell us your role?

Because my role looses its effectiveness if the mafia knows the specifics.

[CountArach]

According to me the town has no way of knowing other then my word.

On the other hand, the same thing could be said for a pro-town power role. I'm not sure what to think to be honest.

I think that we should keep TinCow around for at least one more round and then see what happens.

I have a theory that one of the killers can only kill someone they voted for (And then perhaps unvoted?) and I'll look into that during today.

Vote: Abstain for now. Will likely change later.