Trapped in Taormina [Concluded]

[Northnovas]

How stupid can one be; getting a penalty when in power-play? Take it easy guys. The Canucks are not unbeatable.

Okay this statement is now true and it was a damn penalty that lost the game.

As for Husar post I am innocent just a townie with no role and I would also like to add what does PK know about the detective role. I have PK a townie like me am I wrong!?

[Gaius Scribonius Curio]

Things to be drawn from the write-up.

It seems that Haudegan was killed by the brother. It may be a leap of faith, but the fact that the head was stuck on a spear, may mean that he found Manfredo? If so that means that there is no possibility of a pro-town vigilante.

Husar seems to have been killed by the Yakusa (Martial Arts) so we know Taketski is still around. We also know that he has to kill everyone, so there may not be an ulterior motive for having Husar as a target.

I'd suggest that Rythmic was the detective. I'd imagine the detective as a religious and polite guy. I'd guess a Carelli killing, a professional job, but if my first theory above is wrong then it could also have been Manfredo.

Finally, the nervous guy and Pevergreen. I need to check this against what happened in thread. If Pever insulted someone, they'd definitely be on the list of suspects, the theory about it being Axel would seem to be the best atm.

[TinCow]

As for Husar post I am innocent just a townie with no role and I would also like to add what does PK know about the detective role. I have PK a townie like me am I wrong!?

Nice of you to mention that you're just a plan old townie twice in two sentences. You seem to be reacting overly defensive for a paper-thin accusation by a dead person whose own reputation wasn't exactly sterling.

Vote: Northnovas

It seems that Haudegan was killed by the brother. It may be a leap of faith, but the fact that the head was stuck on a spear, may mean that he found Manfredo? If so that means that there is no possibility of a pro-town vigilante.

This is a gem of an analysis and one that I totally missed when reading the write-up. Re-reading it, I completely agree with your interpretation of the events. It's very possible that the MiB has just killed Manfredo. I haven't checked, but I think Sasaki, PK, and I are the only people left who voted for Ichigo. If the grinning man kills none of us tonight, I think we can assume he got Manfredo.

[Northnovas]

Nice of you to mention that you're just a plan old townie twice in two sentences. You seem to be reacting overly defensive for a paper-thin accusation by a dead person whose own reputation wasn't exactly sterling.

Vote: Northnovas

I didn't realize he was dead so I was just defending myself but like any mafia game when one defends their name they become suspicious. A vote for me is only pro mafia because it will be a wasted lynch.

I am just trying to figure what role you since N1. I can't imagine you not being in the thick of things. Possible the MiB and now you have aquired your target there won't be anymore kills??

[Csargo]

The first and third kills were interesting...

[Gaius Scribonius Curio]

The first and third kills were interesting...

You mean with the victims bleeding slowly to death? Do you think there is a connection?

I think that would be unlikely, but possible.

[Gaius Scribonius Curio]

Ok, seen as I've done my knee playing football against a bunch of obnoxious scallys (or chavs, depending on your preference), and I can't be bothered walking to the library from the cafe, its time for a little in-depth analysis...

Alive (17)

Tiberius of the Drake
woad&fangs
Omanes
Caius
Gaius Scribonius Curio
Sasaki Kojiro
TinCow
Elite Ferret
Northnovas
LittleGrizzly
Mithrandir
axel
Makanyane
Bananabob
Tratorix
Privateerkev
Proletariat

We know from the write-up that there are at least four killers. Unfortunately, due to the verbose nature of some of the remaining people, there is a chance for others to lurk and remain undetected. There are three groups of people on this list. Those who have been relatively talkative in game, those who have been helpful or analytical, but not overly loud, and the lurkers. Not one group is above suspicion!!!

The first group would consist of: PrivateerKev, myself (Curio), and possibly Tincow and Makanyane, of those who are left. Posting styles and plans and ideas etc. should be relatively plain to see. Guilty or innocent? Thats your call.

The second group would containWoad&Fangs, Sasaki,
Northnovas, Omanes, Little Grizzly and Proletariat. Their motives and patterns are not so easy to see. However, they have been posting and trying to help (or mislead) the town. Most of these participants have come under suspicion at one point or another, and managed to produce a satisfactory answer for their actions, or in Omanes case, lack of them. Northnovas and Little Grizzly, haven't as yet, but a guilty til proven innocent attitude with such a high ratio of mafia to town left, is verging on ridiculous. If there is evidence, by all means produce it, but wanton accusations prove nothing.

Finally the lurkers! Tiberius of the Drake, Caius, Elite Ferret, Mithrandir, Axel, Bananabob and Tratorix have all had relatively little to say, and extremely little that has been of use. Axel and any other relatively new player (Mithrandir? I haven't been around long enough to know who is new), perhaps have an excuse. Also EF, has come in half-way through and could be yet to form a complete and informed opinion. However Caius, Tiberius of the Drake and Tratorix, I know have experiance, yet have been unhelpful and no-one has brought them to bear over this.

FOS: Little Grizzly, Caius, Tiberius of the Drake and Tratorix.

Little Grizzly has given no satisfactory defense of himself (afaik, please point this out if he has and I will retract this), and yet is suddenly guilt-free. Why? Caius, Tratorix and Tiberius of the Drake, as I've said I have nothing to go off other than their post-histories, which I am reviewing, and would like to hear a defence for their lack of activity.

This has taken me a while so I may be a bit off the pace, and my apologies if any information recorded above is wrong, I am human, I make mistakes, correct me.

Edit: apparently not... lol

[Makanyane]

Have no idea left - except mafia is obviously being cleverer than the rest of us
Vote: Sasaki


Curio, analysis of other people is one thing but you seem to be trying to tell everyone else what they should think of you too - I'm not sure I liked way you grouped yourself with me, TC and PK as 'our'

[Csargo]

You mean with the victims bleeding slowly to death? Do you think there is a connection?

I think that would be unlikely, but possible.

And to Sasaki: Bow down to the list.