The Brothel - Large Mafia Game [Concluded]

[Caius]

Unvote:khaan
Vote:Ichigo
If AP suicided, that was because he has a role. He could be another killer or a puritan. Come and defend yourself, if you are one of them!

[Csargo]

Unvote:khaan
Vote:Ichigo
If AP suicided, that was because he has a role. He could be another killer or a puritan. Come and defend yourself, if you are one of them!

[TevashSzat]

[shlin28]

This means the remaining mafiosi/serial killer (if there are any) are found with the following players:


Andres - entered late.
Craterus - entered late
makaikhaan
Ichigo - took phyros' role.

and the other 5 players have these roles:

Caius - prostitute
Elite Ferret - client
GH - client
Sigurd - prostitute
Cronos - prostitute

If Andres and Craterus are innocent, why didn't the mafia kill them? GH, Sigurd, Cronos, EF and Caius all got enough attention on themselves, so the mafia would like to keep them alive as lynch baits. So if the mafia is not Andres or Craterus, they will kill Andres and Craterus, as they are confirmed innocents due to them joining late. However, these two are still alive, so therefore, if you are following my (questionable) logic, one of them must be mafia

Don't lynch makaikhaan yet, I have a feeling he may not be the last killer.

[anelious phyros]

Unvote:khaan
Vote:Ichigo
If AP suicided, that was because he has a role. He could be another killer or a puritan. Come and defend yourself, if you are one of them!

Sorry to inform you but I suicided becuase i'm on vacation and I don't have much time. I would've stayed if I finally got a role!

[Craterus]

shlin, Andres and I have been kept alive for that exact reason. People have tried to turn our 'lateness' into a sign of guilt numerous times since the start of the game. We're still suspects, obviously.

[Caius]

Unvote:Ichigo

What about Cronos?

[seireikhaan]

Gar...

unvote: EliteFerret

Vote: Craterus

Somehow I feel like Craterus, now in retrospect, was too cautious in his treatment of me. Yes I know he came late, but its more than possible that there were originally 2 puritans, and Craterus was the third.


Tally(someone else might want to confirm this, this was a monster to try to compile)

makaikhaan- 2( Chronos, Ichigo)
Craterus- 1(Khaan)
Sigurd- 1(Craterus)


Not Voting- (Andres, Sigurd Fafnesbane, GeneralHankerchief, Caius, EliteFerret)

I must say, I never envisioned a scenario in which Andres, Sigurd, and GH all three be not voting in a round.

Folks! We got a lot of people not voting right now, over half.

[Craterus]

Too cautious? A detective's a detective. Apparently.

Seeing as Sigurd is probably innocent, I'll unvote: Sigurd, vote:makaikhaan.

I'm not entirely convinced by the reveal, it still doesn't add up and you're probably a mafia target by now anyway (assuming you're not the mafia we're looking for).

Strike 3

[seireikhaan]

Strike 3

I knew you'd say that.

[Csargo]

Unvote:khaan, Vote: Craterus

[Andres]

EDIT: nvm, wrong thread

[seireikhaan]

EDIT: nvm, wrong thread

By all means, Andres, you're welcome to, you know, vote.

[Sigurd]

The relative silence from the remaining players are worrying.

The town, I believe has the upper hand.
There are probably only one killer left and if we get the lynch right we will win.

I was so set in my mind that the last one was makaikhaan, that I have problems changing this opinion.
But if it is not the khaan, then who is it?
If I am interpreting phyros' post correctly we can strike Ichigo from our suspect list.
This leaves only

khaan
Andres
Craterus

If this is true, I can't see how they can win. We will definitely lynch one of them and kill one next night and then lynch the last. There are enough of us to do this.

I don't have the intuition that the ladies I am playing have, but for now I choose to believe khaan.
vote:Craterus

You have called for my input in this game before Andres, I am now calling you. What do you have to say?

[Sigurd]

Tally:

Craterus : 3 (Ichigo, makaikhaan, Sigurd)
makaikhaan : 2 (Craterus, Cronos)

not voting : 4 (Andres, Caius, EF, GH)