New IDEAS

[Revan-Shan]

More suggestions for the mod:

Musthave:
Giants should be able to destroy walls, castle doors and towers, but, at the same time, those creatures + trolls and so, wouldn't be able to use the doors in the walls and assault objects (rams, assault towers...).

Monsters should throw away their enemies with their attacks.

Silvan Elves could have trees as buildings, that's what they are planning to do in The Third Age Total War.

Elves should be build with extra expertise so that they are faster and more dangerous, like real elves.

vampires should be faster than anyone else.

Skeletons should never rout, but they should autodestroy if they have no leader.

Underground battles, were discussed previously, just to remember.

Underground campaign map, I heard that idea, a wonderful one. Don't know if it's possible to have two cmpaign maps at the same time in the same screen but it would be excellent.

[Dogman55]

More suggestions for the mod:

Musthave:
Giants should be able to destroy walls, castle doors and towers, but, at the same time, those creatures + trolls and so, wouldn't be able to use the doors in the walls and assault objects (rams, assault towers...).

Monsters should throw away their enemies with their attacks.

Silvan Elves could have trees as buildings, that's what they are planning to do in The Third Age Total War.

Elves should be build with extra expertise so that they are faster and more dangerous, like real elves.

vampires should be faster than anyone else.

Skeletons should never rout, but they should autodestroy if they have no leader.

Underground battles, were discussed previously, just to remember.

Underground campaign map, I heard that idea, a wonderful one. Don't know if it's possible to have two cmpaign maps at the same time in the same screen but it would be excellent.

1: I think that it's been discussed that the idea is possible. (Note: No experience in modding, so this might be all gibberish) by using whatever files/animations/etc. are left from Elephants in MIITW it could be possible to apply this to giants. And why stop at Giants? There are -alot- of possibilities for this. To name a few: Steam Tanks, Kroxigors, Stedgadons, Trolls.

2: I don't think that's possible. While it could be very cool, it seems just a tad excessive no?

3. U don't believe that Wood Elves are making it as a playable faction.Just as rebels

4. What do you mean they should be built with extra expertise? Like automatic experience chevrons?

5. I can see that... but why?

6. Total Agreeance there.

7/8: I think that it's nearly impossible to do. And if it was, wouldn't it be better suited as an expansion pack? Let's get to fighting above land before we worry about going down deep.

P.S I think I'd expand with Lizardmen and Sieges since it has popped in my head. I think it'd be more Old One like if The lizardmen could not build siege equipment, and instead only could rely on brute force (Via Kroxigors and Stegadons) to batter down Enemy walls or Gates. And it would add an extra degree of difficulty that i would love to face.

[Pantsalot]

More suggestions for the mod:

Musthave:
Giants should be able to destroy walls, castle doors and towers, but, at the same time, those creatures + trolls and so, wouldn't be able to use the doors in the walls and assault objects (rams, assault towers...).

Monsters should throw away their enemies with their attacks.

Silvan Elves could have trees as buildings, that's what they are planning to do in The Third Age Total War.

Elves should be build with extra expertise so that they are faster and more dangerous, like real elves.

vampires should be faster than anyone else.

Skeletons should never rout, but they should autodestroy if they have no leader.

Underground battles, were discussed previously, just to remember.

Underground campaign map, I heard that idea, a wonderful one. Don't know if it's possible to have two cmpaign maps at the same time in the same screen but it would be excellent.

1. I think this was used in the lotr mod for RTW with the trolls converted from elephants I believe,
that could be a possibilty although in M2TW elephants have cannons on their backs so therefore
cannot be used as siege weapons in close combat, so there would be many difficulties in doing so.
2. If u mean that they pick up & throw away their enemies then that could be possible as a death
animation but extremely difficult to do. If u mean that when they whack their enemy with their
weapon then the enemy flies away a few metres then I guess that it is also possible, kinda like
sometimes when u hit an enemy formation with a siege weapon, when u make a successful calvary
charge against the enemy or when u throw a regiment of elephants that have no ammo at them.
Although I think this would be excluding calvary as they would have to change the calvary to count
as infantry which would lock most of their abilities
3. As dogman has said, wood elves won't be in the mod, although there was one test model made by
Alletun which was really well done.
4. This would probably make the elves a bit imbalanced, & would be wasted effort in my opinion as
the effort could be placed in creating new models etc.
5. I doubt there will be any single unit vampire units or several heroes in one unit since of modding
blocks & balancing, if the vampire was in a unit of infantry then that would be silly if he was faster.
& if u r thinking of blood dragons then there is a fact that they r mounted on what is not another
vampire.. & even if they were on foot they r not faster than a horse..
6. The mod is trying to stay with the warhammer rules, & in the warhammer rules skeletons can
apparently rout.
7/8. I'd guess that a underground battle in custom or historic battles modes could be possible but
once again it would be very difficuly & a large amount of wasted effort, a double campaign with
above- & under- ground would likely be impossible or EXTREMELY difficuly, they would have to have
it as a secondary campaign option in a W2TW expansion which looks like they r likely never going to
get to do. Also I don't believe there has ever been a battle underground as the every1 apparently
do not know where the skaven live.

I'm no sure if the mod is in the position to have anymore suggestions as it is going incredibly slow
now & to me it looks like it is likely to die out soon unfortunatly..

[Casuir]

1. Cannonless elephants exist, although theres no need to use them as a base as we can make new skeletons
2. Far as I can remember the bone giants bwian made already do this, think its controlled by mass
3. Wood elves, not silvan. And battlemap buildings cant be changed and as dogman pointed out they arent slated for a faction, how the stratmap buildings are represented is not a priority atm
4. Makes no sense, they'll get the base stats they have in tabletop, besides experience doesnt make them faster
5. Not possible
6. they'll get the base stats they have in tabletop
7. Not possible
8. Could ham something that looked underground if you messed about with lighting but the battlemap would be a dark gully and teh whole thing would look pretty crap. Dont really see the point anyways

[Revan-Shan]

More suggestions for the mod:

Monsters should throw away their enemies with their attacks.

I mean: like elephants in m2tw, when charging and attacking, not by grabing and throwing.

[Revan-Shan]

More ideas:


-A new faction: NATURE.

Similar to the REBEL (slave) faction. Includes dinosaurs in Lustria, + dragons, treemen, sea monsters (like pirates but more dangerous) and others in the Old World.


-New units based in the faction's weaponry and culture. example:

Imperial snipers: Shooters that use hochland long rifles.
Non dead peasants: Poor and very cheap light infantry for Khemri and the VC (this ome is already in the mod I think).


-Unit For the Kislevite faction/rebels or for the Empire:

Kossars: Archers/Axemen (bow and arrows + two hand axe)


-Human troops for the Vampire Counts. In the army book it says that the VC can use imperial militia (archers and free companies).


-Northern rebel tribes (area: Kislev): Ungols (reskin mongols)

[Ertai]

More ideas:


-A new faction: NATURE.

Call them Monsters or so.

-New units based in the faction's weaponry and culture. example:

Imperial snipers: Shooters that use hochland long rifles.

Hochland long rifle counts as Experimental weaponery i WFB. Place it very high on tech tree - guild (Master/HQ - Hunters guild perchaps?) unit or hanguner update.

-Human troops for the Vampire Counts. In the army book it says that the VC can use imperial militia (archers and free companies).

Never heard of. I'm looking at 7th ed. AB and cannot find it.

-Northern rebel tribes (area: Kislev): Ungols (reskin mongols)

Ungols are part of Kisleves society. If Kislev isn't playable army - do so!

[Krazysigmarite]

The majority of these ideas have already been discussed, but bringing them to light again is always good for constructive brain-storming.

[Pantsalot]

More ideas:


-A new faction: NATURE.

1. Similar to the REBEL (slave) faction. Includes dinosaurs in Lustria, + dragons, treemen, sea monsters (like pirates but more dangerous) and others in the Old World.


2. -New units based in the faction's weaponry and culture. example:

Imperial snipers: Shooters that use hochland long rifles.
Non dead peasants: Poor and very cheap light infantry for Khemri and the VC (this ome is already in the mod I think).


3. -Unit For the Kislevite faction/rebels or for the Empire:

Kossars: Archers/Axemen (bow and arrows + two hand axe)


4. -Human troops for the Vampire Counts. In the army book it says that the VC can use imperial militia (archers and free companies).


-Northern rebel tribes (area: Kislev): Ungols (reskin mongols)

1. I don't think the mod will have much units that u have noted & I don't think they should bother
making another rebel faction, although nice idea
2. I believe culture is not included in this mod, they'd first have to convert it into kingdoms & they'd
have to make some way to prevent Dwarven cultures living with Lizardmen cultures. Although maybe
there could be someway that advanced weaponary like the hochland rifle as noted could be made as
an upgrade, like if they made the silver armour stat model of a handgunner regiment include a model
of the handgunners holding hochland rifles & then make a building that gives the silver armour stat &
increased attack stat, though this is a bit too complex.
3. The map is not including the kislevite faction as it doesn't reach far enough or else the ogre
kingdoms would have been included as well. So kislevites could only be made for custom battles.
4. I think this is agreeable as it would be simple an easy to do & fair according to the VC army book.

& btw I was wrong about the Skeletons being able to rout, apparently they can, though if they r to
be unroutable then they'll have to be far weaker than most units.