The Midgard Saga II [Concluded]

**Sarathos** · 08-13-2008, 09:55

Originally Posted by GSC

Its quite possible, indeed likely, that the Jotun will have targeted Motep tonight anyway, why would they not target him (unless he is Jotun), when he has revealed a PM, even at the risk it is fake? In other words Thor should protect Motep tonight anyway, just in case.

But what if Motep's reveal is fake? Then you are protecting a Jotun with a God whilst giving them the freedom to kill, do know absurd that is....

**pevergreen** · 08-13-2008, 09:58

Originally Posted by Sarathos

do know absurd that is....

No, I dont.

Motep selected for Holmgang:

He either fights himself, possibly killing GH, and giving clues as to both their strengths. This could result in Motep being lynched.
He gets his champion, if he has one, to fight for him. This quite possibly reveals another decent townsperson to the mafia.
Or he doesnt get selected for Holmgang at all.

**Kagemusha** · 08-13-2008, 09:58

Originally Posted by Sarathos

But what if Motep's reveal is fake? Then you are protecting a Jotun with a God whilst giving them the freedom to kill, do know absurd that is....

And if you are wrong, another King would be dead. I think protecting a Jotuin for one round is lot smaller mistake then getting another king killed.

**Craterus** · 08-13-2008, 10:04

Originally Posted by Kagemusha

And if you are wrong, another King would be dead. I think protecting a Jotuin for one round is lot smaller mistake then getting another king killed.

Then why are you calling for his lynch tomorrow? At least try and be consistent.

**naut** · 08-13-2008, 10:05

pever's PM reveal looks fake.

**pevergreen** · 08-13-2008, 10:33

Originally Posted by Rythmic

pever's PM reveal looks fake.

How so, not only did I have no reason to reveal, it's going against everyone elses claims. I have no runes, I stick by that. I deleted only one line off my PM, because I want to be able to verify if anyone claims that PM as well later.

I havent seen a townie pm claimed, so I presume its the right one...

**Andres** · 08-13-2008, 10:15

Originally Posted by Craterus

Then why are you calling for his lynch tomorrow? At least try and be consistent.

Good point.

**Kagemusha** · 08-13-2008, 10:42

Originally Posted by Craterus

Then why are you calling for his lynch tomorrow? At least try and be consistent.

I have explained the simple and effective plan for bunch of times now. But i will spell it out again.

1.Thor should protect Motep this night
2. Motep should use his champion in homgang, to show that he is what he says he is.
3. If Motep comes clean and uses his Champion, we know that he is a king and should be protected./If not he should be lynched as he has been lying and is propably a Jotun.
4. If GH and Moteps Holmgang does not happen, we should put him against someone as alone Holmgang the next round.

The idea is to actually find out for certain what Motep is. I cant understand how you call that inconsistent, when otherwise we are left guessing. Moteps champion is expendable, if he is a king, because then he can defend himself in Holmgang while Thor can protect him during nights. What part in this is inconsistent or hard to understand?

**Craterus** · 08-13-2008, 10:44

Why he should risk his (innocent) champion just to prove something to you? That's what I'm not understanding.

I believe the reveal, clearly you don't. Either that, or you're Jotun and you're not satisfied that the town has already lynched 2 key figures and you have the laughable audacity to ask for one more.