The Midgard Saga II [Concluded]

**Andres** · 08-13-2008, 16:25

Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief

That one sentence is all I need to see, Andres. It tells me you're trying to draw out the powerful pro-town players.

-edit- No, obviously, you don't get it. Maybe you will after I die.

So you keep ignoring the fact that insisting on lynching Tratorix was suspicious?

**GeneralHankerchief** · 08-13-2008, 16:32

Originally Posted by Andres

So you keep ignoring the fact that insisting on lynching Tratorix was suspicious?

I thought he was guilty.

GH, what does the bolded part of your role PM say?

The bolded stuff says "Hankar 'The Chieftain'", my role (war veteran), and 4 (my Holmgang score).

Yell at me to shut up again?

That wasn't yelling, that was an offhand dismissal. When I yell online I use italics and/or exclamation points.

If GH insists on thinning out the townie herd with pointless Holmgangs

Wrong.

Despite all the hostility and harsh language he throws in my direction.

I'm sorry if you consider one offhand dismissal of a situation you clearly don't have a grasp of "harsh language."

**LittleGrizzly** · 08-13-2008, 16:36

Seeing as you seem to be dead in the water already, maybe you could explain your reasoning to some of our slower participants like Grizzy who really really doesnt get it ?

EDIT: for clarity i was talking to GH in reference to his comment about you really don't get it, maybe you will after im dead...

**GeneralHankerchief** · 08-13-2008, 16:36

Originally Posted by LittleGrizzly

Seeing as you seem to be dead in the water already, maybe you could explain your reasoning to some of our slower participants like Grizzy who really really doesnt get it ?

Was that directed at me?

**LittleGrizzly** · 08-13-2008, 16:43

Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief

Was that directed at me?

Yes, sorry i got my edit in a bit slow and have a bad habit of being too vague...

i was talking to you (gh) in reference to your comment about PK really not getting it, maybe you will after im dead...

Edit: damn i am too slow !!!

Thanks for the clarification GH, i wasn't sure if it was linked to some part of the game or not...

**Privateerkev** · 08-13-2008, 16:37

Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief

I thought he was guilty.

why?

The bolded stuff says "Hankar 'The Chieftain'", my role (war veteran), and 4 (my Holmgang score).

That information could have easily been gleaned from Midgard 1 which I know you played in. Your "reveal" proves nothing.

That wasn't yelling, that was an offhand dismissal. When I yell online I use italics and/or exclamation points.

It was harsh. Maybe in the spirit of mafia games but obviously not in the spirit of the .org since a Mod asked you to tone it down.

Wrong.

Then explain how it helps the town more than it hurts it?

I'm sorry if you consider one offhand dismissal of a situation you clearly don't have a grasp of "harsh language."

Strawman and insincere apology. Do you have anything more constructive to add?

**GeneralHankerchief** · 08-13-2008, 16:43

why?

I didn't like the fact that he had Norse at the top and didn't want to reveal it.

That information could have easily been gleaned from Midgard 1 which I know you played in. Your "reveal" proves nothing.

I didn't aim to prove anything, I just answered woad's question.

Then explain how it helps the town more than it hurts it?

Because I'm not utilizing the Holmgang system to kill anybody. I'm using it to die. (Grizzy, there's your explanation)

Strawman and insincere apology.

It wasn't an apology at all.

**Privateerkev** · 08-13-2008, 16:48

Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief

I didn't like the fact that he had Norse at the top and didn't want to reveal it.

Why should he reveal it in public? It would just give the Jotun one more tool for making fake role PM's. He revealed it to me in private without knowing what it meant. I translated it and it confirmed he is who he said he was.

I didn't aim to prove anything, I just answered woad's question.

So you "revealed" without really meaning to "reveal"? It was just a casual "reveal"? Accidental perhaps?

Because I'm not utilizing the Holmgang system to kill anybody. I'm using it to die. (Grizzy, there's your explanation)

But you might kill someone. And it might be a townie. Which is bad for the town. If you truly wanted to die you would just suicide. That is far less hurtful to the town.

It wasn't an apology at all.

Well, at least you admit it. But erecting strawmans against me will do nothing to further this discussion. In the future, refute my actual points. Don't just get frustrated at me for ruining your attempt to allieviate your own boredom.

**GeneralHankerchief** · 08-13-2008, 16:54

Originally Posted by Privateerkev

Why should he reveal it in public? It would just give the Jotun one more tool for making fake role PM's. He revealed it to me in private without knowing what it meant. I translated it and it confirmed he is who he said he was.

I thought there was a better chance of it saying something like "Jotun" and he didn't want to publicly reveal it for fear of it being translated.

So you "revealed" without really meaning to "reveal"? It was just a casual "reveal"? Accidental perhaps?

I revealed because I no longer care one way or the other. I'm just letting you guys know what I was.

But you might kill someone. And it might be a townie. Which is bad for the town. If you truly wanted to die you would just suicide. That is far less hurtful to the town.

Pfft. No proper Norseman kills himself. It is the epitome of dishonor and shame.

Well, at least you admit it. But erecting strawmans against me will do nothing to further this discussion. In the future, refute my actual points. Don't just get frustrated at me for ruining your attempt to allieviate your own boredom.

I wasn't aware that you had any points to be refuted.