We can't lose.
We can't lose.
Tally
Ibn-Khaldun- 2
El Diablo-2
Quintus.JC- 1
Elite Ferret- 1
Still no vote by El Diablo... you guys have 2 hours. Dark clouds loom in your future.
#Winstontoostrong
#Montytoostronger
The vigilante killing:
Spoiler Alert, click show to read:
__________________________________________
Two lynchings... and no murder.
Spoiler Alert, click show to read:
_____________________________________________
Vigilante attempts to kill Elite Ferret, eliminating Apu’s extra life.
Mob lynches El Diablo and Ibn-Khaldun
Craterus is not assassinated.
I did not WOP El Diablo, because no one changed their votes to break the tie, and town is getting plenty of help. And he's dead anyway.
_____________________________________
Still alive-
Quintus.JC
Beefy187
Elite Ferret
Fenring
Craterus
Dead-
Sarathos
Tratorix
Motep
Ibn-Khaldun
Warmaster Horus
El Diablo
Lord Winter
__________________________________
Begin Day Five
P.S. I gave you guys a few hints.
Last edited by Askthepizzaguy; 08-26-2008 at 17:16. Reason: It's day five, not day four
#Winstontoostrong
#Montytoostronger
What the hell, the game doesn't end?!
Since I'm certain this is the last round of voting, I'll reveal myself. I am the Vigilante, after witnessing the death of Reverent Lovejoy I decided to take the law in my own hands. My alligance is still town, you can see that in the write-ups when I tried to kill Apu. Now the matter seems less clear.
Craterus - He is supposed to be confirmed innocent, so I won't bother with him.
Fenring - Survived one assasination attemp, that leaves him innocent, right?
Beefy - An unlynchable mafia is just crazy!
Quintus. JC - I am the Vigilante with the ability to kill 1 person everyround if I think they're the serial killer (only after the murder of Lovejoy). I was certain either Elite Ferret, El Diablo or Krusty would be the killer so since the other two were lynched I decided to go for Elite Ferret.
Elite Ferret - Dubious, but it would be strange to gave the killer the ability of an extra life from assassinations if he were the killer himself.
So... what do we do now?
Uhhhh well that write up proves my reveal to you, and yeah the mafia wouldn't have an extra life, because they wouldn't be attacked, unless there was a vigilante, which there is...
Craterus was claimed innocent by host...
Fenring was attacked by mafia...
Beefy: if the mafia is unlynchable then that makes it impossible for the town to win...
Quintus:the mafia wouldn't be the vigilante, but the fact that there was no murder adds a little suspicion, though I think that's more likely because Ibn was the murderer.
I admit I seem the most likely suspect, if I wasn't me I'd vote myself but I know I'm not mafia...
In the other thread ATPG did say he had something in place to stop either side winning too easily, perhaps a former townie has been made into mafia. If this is the case I'd say it's most likely Fenring as ATPG wouldn't say that Craterus is innocent if he wouldn't be for long, unless he's trying to make us lose. However if there is no kill tonight and the game doesn't end I'd say the new mafia is Quintus, and the vigilante thing is a coverup.
For now vote:Fenring
Ahh so there was an attempt, but Crate survived. I think that clears Quintus, he wouldn't be able to kill twice in one night, then again he was the only one not present at the attempt, unless he was the killer...
Err. So nobody here got any evidence to accuse anyone, we'll just have to do things the opposite way, process of elimination.
Craterus - all fault will be blamed on ATPG if he was the killer.
Beefy - Been lynched twice, he just can't be the mafia.
Fenring - Survived one attemp, but still doesn't put him in the clear
Quintus - I am the vigilante, I'm supposed to haunt the haunter, not haunt myself.
Elite Ferret - The only person without clear proof, however after my attempt kill on him seemed to prove him sort of innocent, because he wouldn't need the ability of an extra live if he were the killer himself.
I feel like i'm repeating myself, but the scene is seriously quite baffling, the only plausible explanation would be Elite Ferret's one about one of the townie switched alligance. If that's the case than only Beefy and Craterus can be confirmed, since the former has been lynched already and latter only survived an attempt last round. Fenring could of switch sides by now. If Elite Ferret had switched then I should of already killed him. I think the suspicion goes to Fenring for now, maybe after surviving the assassination he known the killer and joined his side.
Vote: Fenring.
Or we could go for a more obvious explanation: Elite Ferret is the mafioso in this game, and ATPG decided to give him an extra life so that the vigilante wouldn't knock him out with the first attempt.
If I were the mafia I'd have to kill every possible townie, including mr. Smithers wich wouldn't make sense because I, Charles Montgomery Burns would be hopelessly lost without my loyalslaveassistant. He (Craterus/Smithers) was attacked though, not to mention with a giant sledgehammer wich I would never be able to lift.
Beefy seems clear, the only other explanations that make sense would be that ATPG intended the mafioso to be killable by the vigilante only, or that he isn't immortal but can survive a set number of lynchings. I don't believe either of them.
So unless someone else is the vigilante and Quintus is trying to mislead us (wich would be extremely bold), there's only one option left for me:
Vote: Elite Ferret
Well, I'm not convinced that town will win anymore, but now you guys truly appear to be putting on your thinking caps.
Just remember, "the serial killer is not"
![]()
#Winstontoostrong
#Montytoostronger
But I was present at the attempted murder of smithers, as is clear in the write up, and was attacked earlier, so unless you are suggesting I'm more than one person I don't see how I could have hit some one with a sledgehammer then commented on it without anyone noticing...
This is most baffling, often in cases such as this, the least likely person is actually the most supsicious person.
Unvote: Fenring Vote: Askthepizzaguy
The same thing applies for me, though.Originally Posted by Elite Ferret
Last edited by Kralizec; 08-26-2008 at 15:38. Reason: added quote
@EF-
Oooh.
If you'll notice, all of the suspects were present. It's actually very possible for everyone here to have donned a trenchcoat, came out of nowhere, and smashed Smithers in the face, disappeared back into the large assembled crowd, and ditched the coat without anyone seeing him.
It is rather dark and cloudy outside. Tonight, it rains.
So your list of suspects has not been narrowed... except perhaps by some clever reasoning done by...
![]()
Last edited by Askthepizzaguy; 08-26-2008 at 15:58.
#Winstontoostrong
#Montytoostronger
Add:
For everyone's valuable information, if you vote for Askthepizzaguy, it will not count. You might as well vote Ichigo. And no, it isn't him or anyone else that's not an active player, either. That would be clever but patently unfair. I'm going to have trouble explaining who the serial killer was as it is.
#Winstontoostrong
#Montytoostronger
Flanders wasn't seen or heard after the serial killer struck...
That's a shame-diddley-ame.
#Winstontoostrong
#Montytoostronger
Question for Askthepizzaguy: In your game could Burns be strong enough for the assults? because in the series that would not be possible, and that would clear Fenring of any suspcion.
Unvote: Askthepizzaguy.
Well, I can't answer that question. (Not allowed)
However, if you look at all the murders, successful and failed, you might be able to rule him out. But then again, you might not, because I am Askthepizzaguy and I like to torture townies.
So, I give you my usual ambiguous reply. Figure it out on your own, townie!
Spoiler Alert, click show to read:
#Winstontoostrong
#Montytoostronger
The best way to ensure for a town win is either double lynch or triple lynch. Although I am able to get rid of one with my vigilante thingy.
Tally:
Fenring 1 (Elite Ferret)
Elite Ferret 1 (Fenring)
Hmm.... that's not very sportsmanlike.
Then you could just lynch/kill everyone but Beefy. I think that if such a thing happens, I may have to step in and say no no. That doesn't seem fair.
I'd randomly execute one of the top vote-getters through Random.org.
So, in short, I've allowed three double lynchings already. No more double or triple lynches.
#Winstontoostrong
#Montytoostronger
vote: Elite Ferret
No more doubt lynches? very well then:
Vote: Elite Ferret
I make it clear my vendeta against Burns, he won't survive the final round. Only him and Apu have any chance of being the mafia.
Sorry about the disappearance I got sick on the wekeend and have had the past two days in bed. Have not even read what has happened - will check in later.
ED
"My IQ test came back. Thankfully it was negative"
Been to:![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
edit:just to make it clear that wasn't aimed at you El Diablo, I forgot to refresh...
Last edited by Ferret; 08-26-2008 at 20:44.
Yeah as I said before if I wasn't me and hadn't seen my PM I'd vote me, but I am me, and you have seen my PM, did it not have similar text to your townie PM, or did you not get one of those?
It's rather easy to write your own private message and put words in my mouth.
The initial role PM's are useless anyways, because you might be a turncoat, even if your original PM said town.
I'm not accusing EF, just pointing out that such evidence is inadmissible.
#Winstontoostrong
#Montytoostronger
Yes it does make sense, but it seems everyone has prove of their innocences. And Beefy and Craterus' evidence seems to be an unshakable alibi. Its true that you and Fenring also has alibi too, but if that's the case then who the hell is the mafia?
Unvote: Elite Ferret
I'll wait and see what the others thinks.
Edit: Look, Beefy and Craterus can not be the mafia. So it has to be either EF or Fenring. We'll lynch one and I'll dispose of the other. Job done, right?
Last edited by Quintus.JC; 08-26-2008 at 22:48.
That's what we thought last time...
But if you are the mafia then you'll have taken out two opponents, or three if you can kill twice at night and day, and then get a draw on the last day before killing the survivor that night...if YOU are the serial killer then you can win in it two days, if you're not then the town should win tonight.
I thought being the vigilante cleared me of all suspicion. Let's just make this clear, the vigilante and the serial killer is two different person. I claim to be the vigilante, and no one has accused me of lying yet.
Bookmarks