I did not realized that...

As the Lunar Whale took off, the heroes inside were already arguing with each other about who they thought was guilty. They did not realize the figure clinging onto the bottom of the spacecraft. The shadowy figure made his way inside of the Lunar Whale, and to everyone's surprise, showed up in the main hall.

Day one: Blind lynch
Night one: murder, vigilante killing

3 dead, 8 remain

______________________ Follow me so far?

Day two: Blind lynch
Night two: murder, vigilante killing (if the vigilante still lives)

6 dead, 5 remain

_______________________ This will happen, most likely. Unless we tie up the votes. DONT tie the votes unless it can kill two suspects on the final night.

Day three: Blind lynch
Night three: murder, vigilante killing (if the vigilante still lives)

9 (most likely) dead, 2 remain.

Victory conditions achieved for town or Mafia, because either Mafia are all dead, or one is left to kill the remaining townie, which means town loses.

We only get three shots at this, unless we accidentally kill the vigilante. And since Quintus claimed he is immune to 3 murders/kills (but not lynchings), it is likely impossible for Mafia to kill Quintus. Only town can kill Quintus, in most likely scenarios. That means either Mafia wants him dead, or he IS the Mafia.

Which means either my reasoning sucks, Chaotix came up with some very exotic rules where normal mafia logic doesn't apply, or Quintus is the Mafia and trying to trick us, or Quintus is town and just pulled a Spartan. Hurting his own team when trying to help them.

In any case, I suggest that he has hurt whichever side he is on, and therefore should be lynched. And unfortunately I should be lynched on night two or three, because I suggested it.


If he is telling the truth, then Mafia wants Quintus dead and only town can deliver it. If he is lying, he must be lynched. If Quintus dies and the game continues, then I have to be lynched or vigilante killed next turn or the turn after to be on the safe side.

I don't suppose it would help town if I tell them I am a townie. Sigh...
I know for sure I am town, but you guys don't. That means if I am wrong, not only am I responsible for bandwagoning an innocent player with a good townie skill, but also responsible for my own lynching, which doesn't help town either.



Still, I can think of NO situation where Quintus' reveal helps town, or even his own side.

IF: Quintus is town:
He just told mafia not to kill him, which would waste their kill. WHY???
He just told town something which would make him seem suspicious, so we kill him. WHY???

IF: Quintus is mafia:
He just said something which makes him appear VERY guilty. WHY???
He told town the ONLY WAY TO KILL HIM is to lynch him. WHY???

IF: Quintus is town, but made an error in revealing:
Then Quintus is hurting town, and is a bad townie, and we need good townies to survive. Lynch.

IF: Quintus is mafia, but made an error in revealing:
Then Quintus is a bad mafia, and he's hurting mafia's side. And a mafia would not intentionally do that. But it helps town to eliminate him. Lynch.

Now, here is an exotic idea:

Imagine Quintus is Mafia, but IMMUNE TO LYNCHINGS! He can only be killed by the vigilante, let's say.

Even so, his reveal makes him suspicious and people will vote for him. This will end up with the following result: Either he doesnt die, proving he lied and is therefore scum and can only be killed by the vigilante, or he doesn't die and everyone who voted for him died. Then the vigilante HAS to kill him next turn or else town loses.

Conclusion:
Even in this farfetched scenario, nothing Quintus is doing is helping his own team, and therefore should be lynched by town AND killed by any mafia teammates he has, just to be on the safe side.