The Lunar Whale: A Final Fantasy IV Mafia [Concluded]

[Askthepizzaguy]

hmmmm.... On second thought I believe there is a case to be made against Caius, as I argued with glyphs earlier last night, it would be the perfect place to sneak in a very unsuspicious character to be the second sabateur.

Why lynch just one suspect when we only have 3 nights, and on the final day the remaining player gets murdered anyway?

I call for a double lynch, Caius and Quintus. This will double town's chances of catching the scumbag, and it will NOT reduce their chances of winning at all by even one night. Work it out on paper.

This is the only instance where I would condone a double-lynch.

unvote: Quintus
Vote: Caius

Tally:
Quintus.JC, 3 votes (Shlin) (WH) (Glyphz)
Caius, 3 votes (FH) (aries) (ATPG)
AskThePizzaGuy, 1 vote (Elite Ferret)
glyphz, 1 vote (El Diablo)
Tiberius of the Drake, 1 vote (Quintus.JC)

[shlin28]

Do we even know we can have a double lynch?

[Askthepizzaguy]

usually in mafia games, if town is undecided between two top candidates, the moderator lynches both. I see no reason why he would not, unless of course, as in my game, all town ever did was double lynch.

But if Chaotix will rule on whether or not we can double lynch, that would be great.

[shlin28]

In most small games I have played if there is a tie there is an extension of 24 hours to decide which one gets lynched

[Askthepizzaguy]

Grrr....

That sucks. Maybe I should have done that for my game. Would have lasted longer that way.

Ok, well if we cannot double lynch, I'll keep my vote floating until I see the final score. Quintus is my top suspect and I don't want Caius to go down before Quintus does.

unvote: Caius

tally:

Quintus.JC, 3 votes (Shlin) (WH) (Glyphz)
Caius, 2 votes (FH) (aries)
AskThePizzaGuy, 1 vote (Elite Ferret)
glyphz, 1 vote (El Diablo)
Tiberius of the Drake, 1 vote (Quintus.JC)