Fillet Royale- Large Mafia game [Concluded]

[Reenk Roink]

Please edit your posts. You aren't allowed to reveal PM's in this game.

Also Merry Christmas, will talk about the game later.

[Quintus.JC]

Guys, firstly PM quoting isn't allowed, secondly a townie's PM is already posted in page 2 by the host. So Andres and Rythmic's posts really doesn't matter.

Vote: Rythmic

Your playing style is identical to the one in Family Guy, you don't attract much attention, you haven't even received a vote before Andres noticed you. You got through the whole game without suspscion from others, directly under the radar.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Is it me, or is the Watcher very Pizzaguy-esque in nature?

To be honest, I haven't even been participating. I don't know why people are still discussing me, I am dead and not mafia, nor a very useful townie.

[ULC]

Vote: QJC

[Askthepizzaguy]

I'm dead and I still Vote: QJC

edit: joke.

[Quintus.JC]

Vote: QJC

May I ask why?

[ULC]

May I ask why?

Maybe I can ask you to PM me first?

[Quintus.JC]

You PMed me first to ask why I've placed my vote on Rythmic, I explained myself. Then we exchanged a fair few PMs.

[ULC]

Correct, but I disliked the general nature of your reasons for voting Rythmic - I'm sorry, but it was a good try.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I've always liked mafia that try to win the game using convincing private messages. It's deviousness encased in secrecy.

[Quintus.JC]

I am willing to reveal my reasons for voting Rythmic, as long as everyone will keep it within this game - Fillet Royale.

[Askthepizzaguy]

But the Watcher doesn't seem to want to do that...

[Quintus.JC]

@ATPG & YLC: everything you see in this thread, remains in this thread, deal?

[Askthepizzaguy]

I wouldn't do what you're proposing to do.

First of all, it's not convincing, and second, it potentially ruins a different game for some.

[Quintus.JC]

Well heck, no one listens to me in this game! Why do you all think I'm lying? Because of the PMs, I'll bloody go public I will.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Now, now... you shouldn't do that. If you were telling the truth, your partner suffers in the other game, violating the forum guidelines for mafia game play. Players are expected to compete with the goal of winning the game, otherwise it ruins the game for others.

I can dig it out if necessary.

Second, if you did do so, then I would suspect it's further fiction, because it might be ever more misleading data. Your proposed course of action smells desperate and stabs a teammate in one game to satisfy another... and that's if it's honest.

[Quintus.JC]

I am actually town in this game! PM obviously isn't working at all, what do you propose me to do then?

[Askthepizzaguy]

Well, it's just a game so it's no big deal either way.

My that ham was delicious... mmm.... there are some traditions worth keeping. *burp*

I mean, if you're townie in this game, then you are. No biggie. I find that the players that are most cautious about losing are typically mafia. Think about it... townies are willing to do just about anything to win, but they take it as a matter of course that some will die, and they may still lose.

Mafia, on the other hand, tend to play very cautiously (myself excluded) or play risky behind the scenes while always cautioning town about the consequences of such and such an action. But it's bad psychology; town isn't afraid of losing, mafia is.

[Quintus.JC]

The following Spoiler is my anaylsis of Rythmic in both Family Guy and Fillet Royale, the Spoiler tag exists for a reason, the information in the spoiler stays in this thread only.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Reading the following message would ruin Family Guy Mafia, so don’t if you are still in it.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Rythmic is the teddy snatcher in Family Guy, I’m the serial killer that has been cooperating with him along the game. Kudos to Rythmic because he has played brilliantly in Family Guy, fooled everyone. Got into the circle of trust. Now he is on his way to win the game. Me – as he’s partial partner, knows his method in Family Guy, not getting noticed, and it has proved successful. In this game, Rythmic has applied identical tactics… and it has worked all the same, the town is behind his feet. Everyone thinks he’s innocent, and anyone who tries to accuse Rythmic gets voted out. Well now I’m accusing him!

List of all of Rythmic’s posts in Family Guy, apart from the post where he basically said ‘IN’

I am sooo confused... I'm a bit pressed for time currently. I'll be back later to cast a vote, and actually try and understand what has happened/is happening?!

Ok, it's late here and I need to get to bed. But, before I do that I'll cast my vote. Although I hate to bandwagon, the last couple posts are rather convincing at pointing towards Shlin28 aka Brian. It does afterall make sense in terms of the show that Brian would snatch Rupert.

Vote: Shlin28

Night y'all.

Tally:

Shlin28- 5(Askthepizzaguy, Yoyoma1910, Shlin28, WhiteEyes, Rythmic)

El Diablo-1(Chaotix)
ATPG-1(Khaan)
White_eyes-1(El Diablo)

Well there is anywhere between 9-16 hours of time difference between me and the rest of you, so it's hard to make a timely addition or response. By the time I get here, I usually don't bother adding anything, since well it's all been said.

Alright to the write up. This caught my eye:

To me this seems to say that the Doctor was targetting Quagmire, but he couldn't since he was killed in the previous segment with a bullet to the head. Now, I don't know about y'all but to me this seems to point out that there are two killers, which we already knew, but the two killers don't know who each other are. Otherwise I'd find it unlikely that they'd target the same person.

Time to cast my vote. I'm fine with the role block. If it'll clear me then sure.

Vote: Seireikhaan

OOC: My laptop's display broke yesterday, I had a big response planned, by that got lost while trying to fix my computer. Give me a second to go over what I've missed.

Short version of what I did before, picked clues from the write up:



The role makes sense as to why he didn't get WoG'd but it sounds distinctly scummy to me, I think that taking a neutral backseat is at the least distinctly useless for a townie. Why would a townie have the ability to abstain, the ability to lynch is a townie's only ability. Odd, very odd.


My computer rather unexpectedly gave up the ghost

Smells of trying to go under the radar

I also disagree with his analysis, I don't see why he keeps pointing at El Diablo

I'm unsure about Chaotix

May be related to the reference about the Doctor working on disguises?


Ah, woops, I didn't realise you didn't want me to stop using my ability altogether. The wording of your PM threw me off. No worries, I can understand why you don't want me to use it, it's not the most useful of abilities anyway.

The evidence against the chicken is very very strong. Which reminds me I have to vote, and it's a pretty easy choice, again.

Vote: Quintus

Also I think seireikhaan is just trying to disrupt the flow of play, I really don't think his references or statements are particularily helpful.

I have to agree, Sarathos's style of play and "ability' hasn't sat well with me these last couple days.

Vote: Sarathos

I think he's questioning the reliability of your sources and the credibility of your information.

The write up is interesting. A bit more overt this time. Was Chris scum? I damn well hope so, otherwise we're in for some rough times.

Edit: Why was I with Choatix, aka Tom Tucker!?

Alright, look at the last night write up...

That may be a long shot, but could it relate to the fact there was a hamper of body parts, etc in the Griffin House?

Yeh, I found that just as perplexing.

All of Rythmic’s posts on Fillet Royale

Lol, I didn't realise I joined twice. Woops.

Anyway.... random vote: Chaotix.

Random vote, nothing suspicious there.

Hmmm, a public message like that looks like someone trying to pin suspicion away from themselves onto CA.

And, I'm having a bit of difficulty getting a read on some of the newer players. Some unusual playing styles so far.

Nothing important here.

Ok, what is Aries trying to do? Seems like a crazy, crazy approach to this game!

I have a bad gut feeling about Andres. He's sneaky.

So, Vote: Andres.

Gone with gut feeling, voted for Andres who one of the Russian protector.

Tough love.

Siting Aries’ overwhelming votes.

This is not good. There are three maf on the loose, and we haven't had an effective lynch yet. Damn.

Nothing contributory, just an comment he made.

Invisible mode or not has nothing to do with being mafia or not, it's just a privacy option.

A reply to a earlier question, again have little to do with the actual game and seems rather he is merely trying to say something without attracting any attention to himself.

Why did the lamb mafia not kill anyone on night 2? Maybe they forgot? Or maybe they can only kill every two nights?

Stating the obvious, something I get voted for (Golden Rules).

Good analysis CA.

Again a short post with the purpose of avoiding unwanted attention from the town.

Hahahahahahahahah.

Alright lynch me. Go on. I'm pure unadulterated, steak, beef loving town. I'd post my townie role PM, but I'm not sure it's allowed.

If I've been under the radar, what's boudica been? Off the map entirely.

Vote: boudica

[/Blazing Glory]

Boudica has been under the radar, but so are you.

I'm a hard core beef eater. BEEF! Goddamnit!

Since were revealing PMs in public, I'll go next. I'm town, and I love steak.

The town PM was posted by Beefy on page 2, so that doesn’t prove anything.

Compare his posts in Fillet Royale with Family Guy, its very similar if not identical. And no one notices this!

Look, just as Andres has pointed out; Rythmic has been living completely under the town’s radar, everyone over looks him, its almost feels like he isn’t even playing. Before Andres voted for Rythmic no one has even voted for Rythmic. He has skipped through everything unnoticed, with short posts to merely remind us he is there. And when someone actually accuses him with sufficient reasons, everyone thinks that person is lying and they want to lynch me. Maybe I should just do what Rythmic does; make obvious points only and don’t provoke anyone so I could remain in the shadows… How could the town still remain oblivion about this?! So I am getting voted for all this. There, I've said everything! Do what you wish now everyone.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Well that only compounds my suspicions.

Why would any of the above make you innocent in this game? It doesn't. It doesn't prove anything, it merely correlates past mafia performances with present games. And that is NOT a reliable indicator, as we all already know.

Your analysis may indeed be valid, but that doesn't mean you're innocent here.

So I am getting voted for all this. There, I've said everything! Do what you wish now everyone.

A more common than not mafia gambit. Deliver an impressive speech on your deathbed, and accept your fate, hoping the drama of it all will convince people. I've warned people what drama usually indicates.

[Quintus.JC]

Okay, in my defence:
1) I didn't have to go through all that trouble to vote for Rythmic, I could of simply bandwaggoned Boudica last round. And vote Rythmic this round without stating much reasons at all. All I had to do was vote Rythmic and say his playing style was suspicious, that's it.
2) I was role blocked on night 1, and yet all 3 murders occured anyway. This does 100% prove my innocence but surely it says something?

[I]Night 1 summery

Quintus was preparing to leave his house when news reporter came in his house.

"Mr Quintus!! Soo good to see you! May I ask a few questions?"

"Umm... Actually I was about to go out to buy my beef"

"Sir! May I ask you a few questions?"

"Like I said..."

"I have a camera on you..."

"Fine go ahead.."

[Quintus.JC]

A more common than not mafia gambit. Deliver an impressive speech on your deathbed, and accept your fate, hoping the drama of it all will convince people. I've warned people what drama usually indicates.

ATPG, that's not my style and you know it. I didn't do it in Family Guy, I didn't do it in the Proscription and certainly not in the Soviet Mafia.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Maybe I'm just mad that I am losing the game I worked so hard on.

[Quintus.JC]

Maybe I'm just mad that I am losing the game I worked so hard on.

Well I'm working hard now for town in this game, and I'd be upset too if we lost.

[Quintus.JC]

My point is that instead of bandwaggoning anybody, I voted for Rythmic because I believe he is the mafia and I stated my reason to the best of my abilities. Before the Rythmic case no one was suspcious of me, like I said; I could of easily blended in with everyone else, try to be the average guy and skid through everything. But I didn't, I presented my case against Rythmic, now all eyes are on me, and I would be pretty upset if I was lynched because of it.

[Askthepizzaguy]

You HAVE to understand why I don't trust you.

There is voluminous evidence against White_Eyes in the other game, yet you're making a desperate attempt to implicate your own partner.

You're either telling the truth or you're lying. And unfortunately, you may be telling the truth. But seriously, going to the lengths you're going in order to damn your own partner in a different game is scummy, for one, and then using it as a reason to vote him in this game is also suspect.

It doesn't prove anything, one way or the other. What you said about being role blocked on night one makes more sense, and that's really all you had to say. Why all the rest?

But, I'm probably about to be humiliated in the other game, so just tune me out. I have no idea what I'm talking about... I'm just offering an opinion, and that opinion is I don't trust your methods in this game.

[Quintus.JC]

You HAVE to understand why I don't trust you.

There is voluminous evidence against White_Eyes in the other game, yet you're making a desperate attempt to implicate your own partner.

You're either telling the truth or you're lying. And unfortunately, you may be telling the truth. But seriously, going to the lengths you're going in order to damn your own partner in a different game is scummy, for one, and then using it as a reason to vote him in this game is also suspect.

It doesn't prove anything, one way or the other. What you said about being role blocked on night one makes more sense, and that's really all you had to say. Why all the rest?

But, I'm probably about to be humiliated in the other game, so just tune me out. I have no idea what I'm talking about... I'm just offering an opinion, and that opinion is I don't trust your methods in this game.

Like you said ATPG. All I had to do was show everyone I was blocked in night 1, that would prove my innocence sure. But I don't want to be not lynched, I want to lynch the mafia. That's why I went through all that. If I was mafia would I do all tha? gaining all the attention, making me looking scum and probably get me lynched. I want to lynch the mafia that's why.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Hey, town possibly got boned by following my lead in the other game, so what does it matter what I think?

[Quintus.JC]

Hey, town possibly got boned by following my lead in the other game, so what does it matter what I think?

It matters when the world is against you and having at least some support.

Of to bed now, will find out the result tommorrow.

[Askthepizzaguy]

You were seemingly roleblocked on night one, and there were 3 murders. That should be sufficient evidence.