Fillet Royale- Large Mafia game [Concluded]

[Beefy187]

Did I say no revealing or no quoting pms?? I did didnt I? I did I did!! ....

Also ATPG, dont bold your vote when your not even alive. It makes it confusing for who ever is doing the tally.

As for the rule breakers... I shall come up with severe punishments

[Askthepizzaguy]

who revealed their pm? To be honest I didn't see.

[Reenk Roink]

Vote: Quintus.JC. My prime suspect now.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Out of fairness, Reenk, wasn't he blocked on night 1 with 3 murders?

I'm not saying he's innocent, I just want to make sure you're acutely aware of that fact before you make things final.

That's the best I can do for you, QJC.

[Reenk Roink]

Blocking one Mafia when there is another Mafia (as was certainly the case with Quintus.JC because he was blocked in the first round) very reasonably allows for a kill by that family.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Just checking. Of course, that would make a minimum of 4 mafia people, possibly more if there was more than one in each.

[Reenk Roink]

The watcher says that each of the three Mafia families had two members each. It is the most reasonable exposition of a game setup.

[Beefy187]

Heres the latest post from the Watcher


Rhythmic has been found innocent by The Watcher's investigation.

Unfortunately, his and Andres mistake of PM revealing may have "severe consequences" according to the Master of Beefdom. Hopefully it does not involve killing them off as they are the two innocents of the town. Do pray that the Master of Beefdom is in a Christmas mood. Perhaps this will warm his heart: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VNsvE33pRSw.

If nothing happens to them then the town has two remaining lynches for the two remaining unknowns (of course The Watcher is still https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KCgFYz7VX74).

As to The Watcher's identity, I believe it is painfully obvious by now for some, though perhpas still unclear for others. Needless to say The Watcher has done well enough to dodge the lynches but yet still seem suspicious enough (by getting into the small spat here and there and getting FoS'd) so that the Mafia would leave him alive. Thank you Mafia, for continuing the tradition of stupidity that pervades your ilk.

I trust in the towns ability to pull this off, we're all just https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QUSDS9pkA2Y!
.................................................................................................... ................................................................................


Just to add how I feel right now... I had pretty much the worst Christmas yesterday in my life. Receiving my crappy result from the final year of my high school (decent mark... but crappy mark for those with Asian parents...) But on the bright side, I really do not care as I invented the new dimension in schooling to cheer my self up. The school game. And I know I won that game.

However that still doesn't make me happy. As I woke up today, realizing I got some essay to do.. The last essay I got back, I got A for the one I was most passionate about (for the first time!) and got a D for the other two. But see.. I have to do another three essays. Which makes me feel rather poor again.

Then on the bright side again. I know all (if not most...) Orgahs are on my side. Always. Even if Christmas has been slightly too cold for my liking.

[Beefy187]

And about the set up. I didn't make it incredibly impossible. In fact, quite easy considering the killers may kill each other.

To watcher: That clip didn't warm my heart... Bring forth death metal next time

[naut]

The remaining players are:

Andres - If he is what he says he is he's innocent
Reenk Roink - Unsure, but some think he's the (W)watcher
QJC - Potentially innocent if the role-block can be trusted, but if each Mafia family has 2 members perhaps he's not
Rythmic - I know I'm a townie, leaving me alive benefits the Mafia, because I'm more suspicious than them, why? because I'm not an overt player
YLC - Unsure

So that leaves me looking straight at YLC and Reenk Roink, and with one of them probably the (W)watcher, this makes this game quite winnable. And if the game continues and they were innocent, lynch me next round.

Edit: Night 3 summary, Reenk was role blocked, like QJC and the murders still occurred. Also he stated he had a job to do. Making it unlikely he's Mafia, but at least something with a night-ability.

FoS: YLC. I can't find anything that would clear his name. It has to be him. Please town lynch him today. And if it isn't him, I take full responsibility and you can lynch me tomorrow.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Interesting, Quintus... YLC... the part about Rythmic's innocence.

[Reenk Roink]

Beefy can we please have an extension?

I'll make this short:

I am The Watcher.

My role was the Garbage Man. I got to look through the garbage of one person every night to see what meat they were eating. It was a detective role.

Andres and Rythmic are innocent by my investigations. YLC and Quintus.JC have not been investigated. Given my own status, one of YLC and Quintus.JC must be a Mafia. I wouldn't rule out the possibility of both being Mafia though it is extremely unlikely.

Although I was roleblocked in night 3, Beefy still sent me the investigation of Andres. I asked him about it and he said it was a mistake.

The fact is, being roleblocked on night 1 doesn't make you innocent at all like Quintus.JC keeps pushing. If both Mafia were still alive, then roleblocking one of them wont stop the kills anymore than killing one of them did.

The reason I am firm on my suspicion of Quintus.JC is because of his posts this round especially. He jumped on to kill Rythmic, and his answers to Askthepizzaguy show much desire to live.

YLC may very well be the Mafia, however, we have 2 votes on Quintus right now. I would have guessed Rythmic would cast the final vote but he didn't and is holding off. I don't have a problem with voting YLC, but I will only break the tie if Beefy grants us an extension and I can be sure about not getting Rythmic to die.

Worst case scenario: Rythmic (or Andres or myself) lynched
Almost as bad: Tie - no lynch
Good: YLC or Quintus.JC lynched

Note: The major reason I preferred Quintus.JC over YLC to be lynched is that YLC was WoG'd early in the game. Mafia can indeed be WoG'd as shown by KukriKhan in the Prometheus, but it's still unlikely.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I tend to believe Reenk's reveal.

I have knowledge that verifies part of what he is saying, due to my own role. Even though I'm dead, I thought you guys might like my input.

[Askthepizzaguy]

This also explains a LOT of the bogusness of what Quintus.JC has been pushing.

[Beefy187]

Extension granted...


But I however wants some answers. I did say Pm quoting not allowed yes?

[naut]

As I've already stated, I'm fairly certain it's YLC. But, it's tied at 2-2 currently. Should I vote to break the tie or on my suspicions?

[Beefy187]

Someone told me that I didn't stress on the quoting rule on the actual thread. Therefore I wont enforce my rules too strictly. But no more Pm quoting please

[ULC]

Well, considering my vote caught suspicion methinks, we still have 5 players, correct? 4 town, 1 mafia? Then even if you guys lynch me, then we still have one last day! If were stuck at 2-2, then just vote me Rythmic if your certain of my guilt, the mathematics of the situation will excuse you.

[naut]

I'll break the tie, if we have two options and at least two days the margin for error is in our favour.

Vote: Quintus

[Andres]

Did I say no revealing or no quoting pms?? I did didnt I? I did I did!! ....

Also ATPG, dont bold your vote when your not even alive. It makes it confusing for who ever is doing the tally.

As for the rule breakers... I shall come up with severe punishments

Sorry, apparently I missed that somehow.

If quoting pm's is not allowed, then I'll do the only honorable thing :

Suicide : Andres

Very sorry Beefy

[Reenk Roink]

Sorry, apparently I missed that somehow.

If quoting pm's is not allowed, then I'll do the only honorable thing :

Suicide : Andres

Very sorry Beefy

Beefy has already stated that the rule wasn't really stressed in the game thread. Thus suicide is extremely harmful to the town's cause (though the gesture is very noble).

[Beefy187]

Sorry, apparently I missed that somehow.

If quoting pm's is not allowed, then I'll do the only honorable thing :

Suicide : Andres

Very sorry Beefy

Yea don't worry too much. Its my fault for not making it extremely obvious.

And only punishment for you would be.... have a wonderful day today... Yes you better enjoy it

[glyphz]

Yea don't worry too much. Its my fault for not making it extremely obvious.

And only punishment for you would be.... have a wonderful day today... Yes you better enjoy it

Praise to His Beefiness, the Merciful!
Just hand all to Him! Nao!
Make things easier, yes?

[Beefy187]

Praise to His Beefiness, the Merciful!
Just hand all to Him! Nao!
Make things easier, yes?

Did I ever tell you guys that I hate sweets?

You got better luck giving me random foods then sweet stuff

[glyphz]

Did I ever tell you guys that I hate sweets?

You got better luck giving me random foods then sweet stuff

Eh?

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

NO WAI!

Tally:
Quintus.JC - 3 (YLC, Rythmic, Reenk R.)
Rythmic - 2 (Andres, QJC)

[Thermal]

Quintus revealing scummy truths/lies for my game and PM qoting here, something that beefy told people off for in a previous game lets obey rules its like andres has already been confirmed innocent unless hes a great forger, not at all unfair? though if it helps town then thats something, even if its unhonorable help

[Beefy187]

Im waiting for Andres to come back here to rethink about his life.

[Thermal]

Beefy can we please have an extension?

I'll make this short:

I am The Watcher.

My role was the Garbage Man. I got to look through the garbage of one person every night to see what meat they were eating. It was a detective role.

Andres and Rythmic are innocent by my investigations. YLC and Quintus.JC have not been investigated. Given my own status, one of YLC and Quintus.JC must be a Mafia. I wouldn't rule out the possibility of both being Mafia though it is extremely unlikely.

Although I was roleblocked in night 3, Beefy still sent me the investigation of Andres. I asked him about it and he said it was a mistake.

The fact is, being roleblocked on night 1 doesn't make you innocent at all like Quintus.JC keeps pushing. If both Mafia were still alive, then roleblocking one of them wont stop the kills anymore than killing one of them did.

The reason I am firm on my suspicion of Quintus.JC is because of his posts this round especially. He jumped on to kill Rythmic, and his answers to Askthepizzaguy show much desire to live.

YLC may very well be the Mafia, however, we have 2 votes on Quintus right now. I would have guessed Rythmic would cast the final vote but he didn't and is holding off. I don't have a problem with voting YLC, but I will only break the tie if Beefy grants us an extension and I can be sure about not getting Rythmic to die.

Worst case scenario: Rythmic (or Andres or myself) lynched
Almost as bad: Tie - no lynch
Good: YLC or Quintus.JC lynched

Note: The major reason I preferred Quintus.JC over YLC to be lynched is that YLC was WoG'd early in the game. Mafia can indeed be WoG'd as shown by KukriKhan in the Prometheus, but it's still unlikely.

didn't you claim to be investigator on the last mafia game (pro...) yet u were a baddy yes? and why did u say i was a scum and a certain mafia after my lynch though no factual evidence supports this? you have done some lying i see

[Reenk Roink]

Sir Beefy, might I remind you that in many legal systems, suicide is illegal. Furthermore, there have been cases where orders have been put to prevent people from committing suicide, even when it's not illegal.

didn't you claim to be investigator on the last mafia game (pro...) yet u were a baddy yes? and why did u say i was a scum and a certain mafia after my lynch though no factual evidence supports this? you have done some lying i see

Yes I was a fake detective in the Prometheus. So what? Are you suggesting that I will fake detective in every further Mafia game? Going back to older games for behavioral clues is one thing, but this is beyond intelligible...

I said you were scum (never "certain" that's a fabrication by you) at that point because I, like most of the town, was operating under the assumption that there was 1 mafia per family. You were roleblocked and Chaotix27 was killed and investigated as the Lamb Mafia. Thus it was very likely to be the Pork Mafia and certain that Chaotix27 was the Lamb Mafia and I voted for you.

Anyway, since your death there have been no more Porkings... Pretty strong coincidence.

Again why are you so defensive Aries my friend? You've been long dead, why should you care? Are you Pork Mafia? I really think that we lynched the Porkster in round 2, though we had an imperfect understanding of the game. Good for us.

[Thermal]

Again why are you so defensive Aries my friend? You've been long dead, why should you care? Are you Pork Mafia? I really think that we lynched the Porkster in round 2, though we had an imperfect understanding of the game. Good for us.

exactly i'm dead, but i still want answers, the dead can still participate, and i said i would, i'm simply keeping a promise, mafia or town, it wouldnt matter either way, as either alignment can post after death to there hearts content if the rule says so, but you will see by the end that i was innocent, you have the inklings, i have the facts, but you believe what you want, the game is coming to an end anyway, then you will be relieved of the narrow path your confused mind has been led to

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

there have been no more porkings since my death, therefore i demand i be killed!