The Golden Rule [Concluded]

[Beefy187]

Strictly speaking it was done during the night phase not the lynch scene. So I think someone set up Ares is possible.

But hey.. What else is there to go on with right now?

[shlin28]

Looking over ATPG's warning, it does seem that Ares seemed to be framed. I am very tempted to unvote him, if we actually have any evidence against anyone apart from him and YLC. ( I don't see how YLC voting for himself is scummy, I do it all the time )

I would say our FBI agent lies amongst this tally, crossing out Ares and YLC, we have 5 people that could possibly be the FBI agent, and all of them had come under suspicion a lot in this game it would seem.

Ares: 2
Chaotix: 1
Beefy: 1
Yoyoma: 1
YLC: 1
TevashSzat: 1
Seireikhaan: 1

Choices choices choices... *reads over the entire thread again* I will see if I can dig anything up.

[Yoyoma1910]

Hmmm.


I was hoping my analysis would drum up more discussion and less joining...

I still personally feel that Ares is a good suspect, but then again if he is innocent, this wouldn't be the first game I've found him highly suspicious unduly in see Beefy game, Duel of Fates. I'd also note that I am only human, and my interpretation of what is written could be swayed by my own prejudices.

I don't know, Ares, something about your playing style always seems to make me wonder about your motivations.

Though I do agree, especially with Pizza's last comment, that this worm likely has a hook in it. Then again, he could be intervening to throw us off the scent he placed himself.

Perhaps "Eternal Darkness" has to do with those that lynch El Diablo. Or perhaps its supposed to imply a relationship with YLC's resident evil game... I don't know?

[Reenk Roink]

I've never played a Pizzaguy Mafia game before so forgive me if I'm wrong, but I think basically everything he has posted is smoke and mirrors (the roles, writeups, and his clues). This based on how Pizzaguy plays at other times.

I mean look at this:

Another close call today. I am confident that our equipment will not be detected.

This kind of contradictory and confusing message is typical of what we've got so far. My guess is that Pizzaguy is helping the Mafia because he made the game stacked against them. I remember skimming his Futurama Mafia and noticing he mentioned doing the same thing for the town.

I don't like how woad&fangs and General Hankerchief just jumped on the bandwagon with poor reasons (as compared to TevashSzat and Chaotix27 who look less like "I just want to get that guy lynched) that is going on for Aries and YLC, who may be suspicious, but as of now are driving the discussion. We shouldn't punish them for it.

Vote: woad&fangs

[Beefy187]

This kind of contradictory and confusing message is typical of what we've got so far. My guess is that Pizzaguy is helping the Mafia because he made the game stacked against them. I remember skimming his Futurama Mafia and noticing he mentioned doing the same thing for the town.

I don't see how that clue could help the mafia. Its more likely for the town

And in Futurama mafia, Pizzaguy did help a town with lots of clues but he made the professor mafia so we were pretty much stuffed from the start

To Shlin: Cmon! I'm fifth on the wagon!!

[Reenk Roink]

The problem I have with the statement is that the log says "close call" which suggests he was close to being lynched? That seems to be a hint that the FBI Agent is one of the people who were voted for that round.

However, he then says he is "confident that our equipment will not be detected" which is weird because firstly what equipment? And worse, now he is confident that something will not be detected right after he said that was a close call...