The Scourge of Ephesus [Concluded]

[Beefy187]

Out of 12 peoples alive three are killers (assuming that each mafia gets one killed per night)

Candidates

boudica (yet to speak this round. Apparently busy)
GeneralHankerchief (Role blocker for now)
187Beefyz Imma innocent.. Rargh!
Chaotix27
YLC
Yoyoma1910 (Yet to speak this round)
Ibn-Khaldun (Yet to speak this round)
Lord Winter
CountArach
Caius lurking both in this game and the other
Glyphz
Seamus Fermanagh kidnapped last night. Should be inactive

Now since two of the killer met each other. Wanted to kill each other. So they are enemies.

And if they don't lynch each other, they will end up in eternal stalemate unless with the help of the bigger mafias buddy. But I'm assuming they rather lynch them.

So using this theory, I think one of the mafia is CA. While his defense was adequate, according to the more experienced analyzer, he was scummy.

As atm, there is no one ales being voted (Chaotix doesn't count as Seamus cannot be the shooter), I think CA could be one of the mafia. And if not either Yoyoma or Ibn-Khaldun is.

Now if CA is indeed a mafia, then one of the rival mafia member could be amongst those who joined the CA bandwagon.

I think my theory doesn't have flaws except the fact that CA is probably innocent. If CA is indeed a mafia, then he would've revenge voted for the person who is a member of the enemy mafia.

Which makes me think that either both mafia who had a standoff were lurkers (or possibly all three of them) or mafia shook there hands.

Vote:Yoyoma

For now as he is the most active amongst the lurkers.

EDIT: I never heard of role blocker being the mafia. It could mean that role blocker is neutral then later recruited as part of the mafia
(one of them destroyed the statue and GH the old man loves the history yes?) but I think role blocker being the mafia is weird.