The Scourge of Ephesus [Concluded]

**Jolt** · 01-21-2009, 14:29

I find it funny that all people GH blocked fall asleep in his cave. Is this a simple coincidence? After they are asleep, what does GH do? It's quite odd that noone stays awake to actually see if GH remains in the cave. My bet goes to GH's being scummy.

**Jolt** · 01-22-2009, 13:30

Originally Posted by Jolt

I find it funny that all people GH blocked fall asleep in his cave. Is this a simple coincidence? After they are asleep, what does GH do? It's quite odd that noone stays awake to actually see if GH remains in the cave. My bet goes to GH's being scummy.

Did anyone read this? This is the proof that once the guys are asleep, his character comes out of the cave to kill someone.

**Askthepizzaguy** · 01-22-2009, 13:32

I admit I did not fully consider that possibility, but I had oodles of reasons for going after GH already.

I noted you were probably innocent because of your willingness to go after him, in spite of his "invaluable" "townie" ability.

**GeneralHankerchief** · 01-22-2009, 15:15

My defense is as follows.

**Yoyoma1910** · 01-22-2009, 15:28

No guys, I just thought of the answer!

Don't you get it:

Pizza, who was likely innocent, was killed by the VIGILANTE!

He was killed by the sword. GH couldn't protect him because it was a protown hit!

It all makes sense now.

**Askthepizzaguy** · 01-22-2009, 15:42

I am innocent, and from what YLC told me in private, it was the vigilante who killed me.

But I didn't really have reasons for trusting him, and he said he did not know who the vigilante was, or that the vigilante somehow was able to contact him but he didn't know who he was.

I can verify that it was alleged I was killed by vigilante, and if I was killed by the blade (if I recall... the games are blending together now...) then it was so I think.

I still do not think GH is innocent, because the mafia would/should have killed him by now, or GH should have blocked the mafia, one night, and then repeated the next night.

He's not bad at this game, he's the freakin' master. How he would miss such an obvious strategy is beyond me.... wait! No, it's not. He could be... yes... scum!

**Yoyoma1910** · 01-22-2009, 16:02

Well, they did try to kill him.

**TinCow** · 01-22-2009, 16:06

Originally Posted by Yoyoma1910

No guys, I just thought of the answer!

Don't you get it:

Pizza, who was likely innocent, was killed by the VIGILANTE!

He was killed by the sword. GH couldn't protect him because it was a protown hit!

It all makes sense now.

As far as I am aware, nearly every single protection role that has ever been written for mafia games makes 'doctor' abilities work against any attacker, regardless of alignment. There is nothing whatsoever in GH's role PM that indicates he is anything other than a bland old boring combo role blocker and doctor. If we're just going to discard what we know about how roles work, when there is no evidence to the contrary, next time I fake a role PM I'll be the Magic Fairy Pixie Dust Monkey who can bestow all powers in the Known World on others, but has no idea which powers will be given, who they will be given to, and whether they will even work. When you then try to lynch me for being mafioso scum, I will claim innocence by being unable to explain my Strange But Awesome Powers.