The main reason for my originally saying GH was probably innocent was his confirmed night abilities. He has proven that he can bring two people per night to a secret chamber and bore them to sleep. We know this and it has been confirmed. However, what we do not know is exactly what goes on when GH puts these people to sleep.

GH claims that this is a role block AND protection role. Yet there have been two attacks on people that GH was supposed to be protecting at night. The first attack completely succeeded and ATPG was killed. The second attack (Seamus) seems to have been completely unaffected by GH's actions whatsoever. Thus, GH is lying about his ability to protect people.

So, what could he be doing? One option is that he is a mafia detective. He snags two people at night, bores them to sleep, then rifles through their belongings looking for something. This type of action would be useless without the ability to kill, which GH may or may not have. However, what if GH has a partner? Or, better yet, what if GH only needs to find and kill a single person?

Let's take a look at something else in the write-ups that no one has touched on before. This is from Night 4:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 
A shady figure strided over the sands of the theater.

He looked around him and noticed the enveloppe.

The man picked it up and read the short note inside it.

He grinned and walked away, calmly.


This is not just for color, something happened here. Someone put something in the envelope and dropped it for another person to pick up. What goes into an envelope? A letter. Letters have writing on them. Writing is information. This was an information drop. Could this be the result of GH locating a good target and then communicating the identity of that target to his partner? Is it a coincidence that the 'Mexican Standoff' attacks start the following night?

There's more as well. GH's character is obviously very concerned about what is going on with the statues. He is upset when a statue is destroyed and he leads people at night to a secret chamber. This is significant, and it seems very heavily connected to the role that was destroying the statues and which now seems to be manifesting as some kind of evil spirit who possessed Seamus last night. Yet, GH's claimed role contains NO information of any kind about any of this stuff:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 
Quote Originally Posted by Andres
The Guide

You are the guide, mentioned in the opening scene.

You have a perfect knowledge of the Ancient City of Ephesus.

Each night, you are allowed to protect two players. When you do so, you’ll hide them in the secret tunnel between the ancient library and the ancient brothel. When you protect a player, you’ll also block his/her actions for that night.

Each night, you have to pm me the names of the people you’re going to protect. Your pm has to reach me before the night ends.

Assination attempts on you might fail under certain circumstances.

Good luck!


This seems wrong. The way his role is written, he should have some major part in this supernatural skullduggery that is going on, yet the role PM he produced has nothing whatsoever. Look at this game, look at the setting, look at the write-ups. There is essentially no likelihood whatsoever that there are any plain old vanilla roles here, yet GH is claiming a role that simply blocks and protects. Not only does this not fit into the game as it is written, he can't even protect well, as conclusively shown by ATPG's death. It seems very likely that GH has heavily modified his own role PM and is faking what he is doing.

Indeed, I now doubt GH's claim that he can even block people. I bet he does nothing of the sort. I bet GH added that so that he could 'block' his mafioso partner and clear them of any wrongdoing. I think that if we look at who GH has 'blocked' we will find his partner.

This is who he has 'blocked':
Night 1: Sigurd (lynched) and Quintus (killed)
Night 2: Reenk (killed) and Tevash (lynched)
Night 3: Seamus and shlin (killed).
Night 4: ATPG (killed) and boudica.
Night 5: Sigurd (lynched) and boudica.
Night 6: YLC and Beefy.
Night 7: Seamus and glyphz.

So, of all those 'blocked', only Seamus, boudica, YLC, Beefy, and glyphz are still alive. Of these, only two, Seamus and boudica, have been 'blocked' twice. Interesting, especially given the most recent GH/Seamus evidence they so kindly provided.

The Night 7 results are posted at 16:51 EST. At 16:52 (one minute later) GH posts his 'success' claim, but it take him until 16:56 (four full minutes later) to post the results PM. GH's "Score!" post indicates that he 'knows' the protection worked. However, the write-up description reads like Seamus wasn't protected at all. So, if GH knew a protection worked, he read it in a results PM. So, he had this PM and was able to read it and celebrate about it within ONE MINUTE of the night results being posted, but it then took him another FOUR MINUTES to copy and paste the results PM? No way, those four minutes was him fabricating a results PM or double-checking a previous forgery for errors.

Seamus then conveniently busts out with this gem saying that GH told him he was going to be protected THREE MINUTES before Andres posted they night results. Why in the world would GH ever disclose this information? First, GH could never know the exact moment when Andres would precisely post the night results, so there is no way he could have properly timed this thing to get there before it was too late for Seamus to change his own night orders. Second, there's no reason whatsoever to inform Seamus beforehand. The only reason to do so would be to prove to Seamus that he's the person who's doing the protecting/blocking, but that's the one thing that absolutely everyone in this game has already accepted! The thing that was in doubt was whether GH's actions were effective, not whether he could do them, and GH didn't need to disclose his night actions to someone beforehand to prove their effectiveness. GH is extremely smart. He would not have disclosed this info to Seamus unless it was crucial for his survival, and in this case it was not.

GH is some kind of mafioso and Seamus is his partner. Lynch them both.