Chicago Soirée [Concluded]

[Yoyoma1910]

Sorry gentle men, I seem to have a terrible headache.


It must be all this Louisiana Bourbon.




Point of order!

Bourbon has never been made in Louisiana, therefor I cannot be dead!


It was all a bad dream, hah hah... oh, ow... why are my brains leaking onto the floor... oh my god... I'm still stuck in that silent night game! argh... mmmmmmm.....



____________________________________________________________________

[Andres]

But I am beating a dead cow

But TinCow is not dead!

*** looks at awfull attempt at humour ***

[Askthepizzaguy]

But TinCow is not dead!

*** looks at awfull pun ***

His case and his arguments are, IMHO.

[Yoyoma1910]

Sorry again gentlemen, I didn't realize I had been killed until well into our conversation.



It won't happen again.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I was too busy accusing TinCow to see past my own nose.

Seireikhaan can have a transcript of what was said. Our conversation was well-intentioned and revealed nothing new about the game, IMO. But I defer to Sk's judgment. My conscience is clean.

I have to run, enjoy the peace and quiet!

[shlin28]

Bah, you guys are basically arguing about nothing, townies are supposed to not care about being killed! So what if someone accuses you of being mafia? If you are mafia, you die and thats good for townies. If you are town, you die and can still contribute, and thats good for townies.

Vote: Gaius Scribonius Curio

Too townie IMO.

Edit: spellings

[GeneralHankerchief]

Ugh, I've think we've seen a record for most white noise generated. That's not something to be proud of, ATPG.

You said yourself (it was you, right? It might have been Andres) that it's pointless to focus on one person a round because there are two mafiosi. Yet your dogged attacks on TinCow have made us completely forget about everything that happened beforehand.

IMHO, ATPG and TinCow are both townies. However, ATPG at this point is doing us more harm than good.

My vote stays on Andres. His behavior in the night phase reminded me a lot of Mafia VI.

[Thermal]

Firstly i've had a real science GSCE exam to revise for, so not being online for just under one day isn't so bad i figure.

Vote: ATPG

Call it what you want, but hes being even more ludicrous than usual!

Main points:
1: votes for himself, suicide votes arent healthy
2: quickly changes vote, as if he was trying to prove he was innocent voting for himself, only to vote for someone else knowingly after
3: Later on after gods knows how many votes ensures us he votes for himself no matter what, only to do a blatant lie and change vote again!
4: Madly active, always is active but like hyper, he won't rest until we all sub-consciously vote against someone else because we can't be bothered to read his extensive essay sized posts and therefore miss some of his faults
5: Over suspicious for no reason and would have avoided suspicion by being quieter, his reversed reverse psycho-versed psychology isn't something I'm coming to terms with yet
6: accuses most players of being scummy at some stage including all those who have voted against him, such as tincow, but tincow isnt suspicious IMO

[Quintus.JC]

@ATPG: you're behaving extremely unusual in this game, by giving reasons to call for your lynch I'd be repeating what other people have said, so I won't.

Vote: GH

I've really busy over the days, skimming through the thread has seriously messed up my head... something about you doesn't feel right.

[Thermal]

tally?

Askthepizzaguy: 4 (Sigurd, Andres, TinCow, 777ares777)
GeneralHankerchief: 3 (Reenk Roink, TevashSzat, QJC)
Andres: 2 (GeneralHankerchief, Lord Winter)

Taka: 1 (Beefy)
TinCow: 1 (Askthepizzaguy)
Lord Winter: 1 (Taka)
Boudica: 1 (LittleGrizzly)
Gaius: 1 (Shlin)

Abstain: 2 (Gaius Scribonius Curio, Boudica)

[glyphz]

Yoyoma & YLC got offed. Haven't read the posts prior.Simple mafia game. Clues? Don't know if there's one.

a) someone in the 'A' or the earlier letters.
b) someone who took part in Golden Rule
c) neither

Top 2 vote getters, Atpg and GH, fits well w/ a and b.
*looks at tally*

Conclusion: No objections. Vote: Abstain

[GeneralHankerchief]

Ugh, really?

Come on glyphz, you're smarter than this.

Unvote: Andres
Vote: glyphz

[White_eyes:D]

ATPG is acting really scummybut so is TinCow. GH is really avoiding the limelight....so to even things up and reveal more scum(Possibly.....) Vote:GH
Tally?
Askthepizzaguy: 4 (Sigurd, Andres, TinCow, 777ares777)
GeneralHankerchief: 4 (Reenk Roink, TevashSzat, QJC, White_eyes:D)
Andres: 2 (GeneralHankerchief, Lord Winter)

Taka: 1 (Beefy)
TinCow: 1 (Askthepizzaguy)
Lord Winter: 1 (Taka)
Boudica: 1 (LittleGrizzly)
Gaius: 1 (Shlin)
glyphz: 1 (GeneralHankerchief)

Abstain: 2 (Gaius Scribonius Curio, Boudica, glyphz)

[Reenk Roink]

Unvote: GeneralHankerchief
Vote: Askthepizzaguy, courteously

I like to be the deciding factor.

[glyphz]

you're smarter than this.

er... am i?

Anyway, i lack the time to read, & attmept to analyze through, the past 3 pages before the deadline
...and I doubt I'll find much either.

Procrastinating on a Pol. Sci. paper...

about 'Liberty!'

[GeneralHankerchief]

ATPG is acting really scummybut so is TinCow. GH is really avoiding the limelight....so to even things up and reveal more scum(Possibly.....) Vote:GH

How am I avoiding the limelight? I wasn't online when the ATPG/TinCow thing erupted, I can't help that. But when I have been on, I've definitely made my presence known.

[Beefy187]

Actually im willing to congratulate ATPG for his victory in Golden Rule

Unvote: Taka, Vote: ATPG

Here. Have what you deserve

[seireikhaan]

Chief Vonken amassed the crowd together once more, this time not needing to explain the events from the night before. The charred remains of YLC's house served as a very real symbol of what the town of Cicero was facing. The town no longer remained restrained as had been the previous day. Accusations were shouted everywhere. In particular, Askthepizzaguy was particularly boisterous. As he continued to harry other townspeople, more and more townspeople turned against him. In the end, Askthepizzaguy would receieve more votes than anyone else. As he was thrust forwards to Chief Vonken to be executed, his rantings became louder and more confused. He repeatedly exclaimed that his death would prove his name and that he would aid the town in death. Not liking this sort of heresy, Chief Vonken whipped the deranged man with the short barrel of his pistol, knocking him to the ground. The chief fired a single shot, penetrating the skull and blowing chunks of brain and blood across the ground.



Askthepizzaguy: 6 (Sigurd, Andres, Beefy, Reenk Roink, TinCow, 777ares777)
GeneralHankerchief: 3 (TevashSzat, QJC, White_eyes:D)
Andres: 2 (GeneralHankerchief, Lord Winter)

TinCow: 1 (Askthepizzaguy)
Lord Winter: 1 (Taka)
Boudica: 1 (LittleGrizzly)
Gaius: 1 (Shlin)
glyphz: 1 (GeneralHankerchief)

Abstain: 3 (Gaius Scribonius Curio, Boudica, glyphz)
Not voting: 3 (Warluster, Warman, Sarathos)




Alive: 21

Andres
Ares777
Beefy
Boudica
Caius
Gaius Scribonius Curio
GeneralHankerchief
Glyphz
LittleGrizzly
Lord Winter
QuintusJC
Reenk Roink
Sarathos
Shlin28
Sigurd
Taka
TevashSzat
TinCow
Warluster
Warman
White_Eyes


Dead: 4
CountArach (N1)
Tiberius of the Drake (N1)
YLC (N2)
Yoyoma (N2)

Lynched: 2

Chaotix (D1)
Askthepizzaguy (D2)

Suicide: 1

Hooahguy (D2)


EDIT: Night has begun! I want orders within 24 hours.

[Gaius Scribonius Curio]

................

Wow!


That's just insane........

To be fair I feel that once again much ado has been made about nothing. Tincow's logical defence, whilst seeming cold and calculated was much more solid than ATPG's passionate rant. That said the whole battle of wits and words scenario, while very entertaining to read through (as well as being very very confusing), merely provided yet another bandwagon for lazy townies, and perhaps the odd surprised and relieved mafioso, to jump on.

I acquit Andres and Tincow of such behaviour, several hours of reasoning with a ranting ATPG, must have provided ample reason for their votes, if only for some peace and quiet. Reenk Roink to appears to have made some studious reasoning of his own to the fray.

There are some people whose behaviour needs to be examined however. Beefy, while admittedly not usually the most reasoned player, has jumped on every bandwagon, or even semi-bandwagon, that has been so far dreamed up. Suspicious certainly, but, I feel, way too obvious.

GH voted before the rant, and rejoined halfway through, without changing his vote. It seems to me that with an argument in full swing, and one of the combatants someone he deemed suspicious he wanted to let things play out. I cannot fault him there.

Aries has the excuse of exams for jumping on an already rolling bandwagon. I sympathise with that but the fact itself still needs to be pointed out. This can be excused somewhat by the fact that reasoning was given.

Taka still has my alarm bells tingling. Semi-lurking amongst the buzz of many verbose players, he could be a suspect.

Glyphz is usually more up-to-date, and usually thinks things through a little more. Worthy of a second look in my opinion.

That my take on everything that has happened in my absence. Except for one small matter, may I call to the floor Shlin28. I should like an explanation of your vote for me. To say that someone is 'too townie' is, as ATPG suggested yesterday, a logical fallacy. If you have anything more that you based your opinion on I would be interested to hear an accusation...

[Andres]

Gaius Scribonius Curio, no opinion on LittleGrizzly?

[GeneralHankerchief]

What I don't like is now, I'm pretty much next in line to be lynched for no good reason. Andres and Reenk didn't have anything when they voted me. White Eyes gave a completely inaccurate reason for voting me ("avoiding the limelight" when I clearly wasn't), Quintus has me based off a gut feeling and nothing else, and glyphz thinks it may be me based off the previous kills (alarm bells go off in my head) and the fact that my nickname starts with the letter "G" (MAJOR alarm bells go off in my head).

If you guys want to lynch me, that's fine, but for heaven's sake do it for a good reason!

[White_eyes:D]

What I don't like is now, I'm pretty much next in line to be lynched for no good reason. Andres and Reenk didn't have anything when they voted me. White Eyes gave a completely inaccurate reason for voting me ("avoiding the limelight" when I clearly wasn't), Quintus has me based off a gut feeling and nothing else, and glyphz thinks it may be me based off the previous kills (alarm bells go off in my head) and the fact that my nickname starts with the letter "G" (MAJOR alarm bells go off in my head).

If you guys want to lynch me, that's fine, but for heaven's sake do it for a good reason!

I was not trying to lynch you....I was trying to see who would make last minute changes to their vote to see if there Mafia.(The whole avoiding the limelight....that was more for TinCow....call me crazy but his defense was FAIR too cold and calculated....)

Above plan failed, since only ATPG killed himself and Beefy changed his vote and was the only one to.....I really don't think it's Beefy....(so I had a good reason...it was to look for suspicious voting, which failed )

[glyphz]

What I don't like is now, I'm pretty much next in line to be lynched for no good reason. Andres and Reenk didn't have anything when they voted me. White Eyes gave a completely inaccurate reason for voting me ("avoiding the limelight" when I clearly wasn't), Quintus has me based off a gut feeling and nothing else, and glyphz thinks it may be me based off the previous kills (alarm bells go off in my head) and the fact that my nickname starts with the letter "G" (MAJOR alarm bells go off in my head).

If you guys want to lynch me, that's fine, but for heaven's sake do it for a good reason!

The reasons I put up were merely wild guesses, ones that I cannot take even seriously myself.
So rather than simply, voting abstain, I decided to post them to see what others thought.

The reaction, as would be expected:

Does not mean I'm set to go after you, GH.

[GeneralHankerchief]

No, it succeeded, at least on me. The problem was that glyphz's voting looked even more suspicious.

-edit- meant for White Eyes.

[Reenk Roink]

What I don't like is now, I'm pretty much next in line to be lynched for no good reason. Andres and Reenk didn't have anything when they voted me. White Eyes gave a completely inaccurate reason for voting me ("avoiding the limelight" when I clearly wasn't), Quintus has me based off a gut feeling and nothing else, and glyphz thinks it may be me based off the previous kills (alarm bells go off in my head) and the fact that my nickname starts with the letter "G" (MAJOR alarm bells go off in my head).

If you guys want to lynch me, that's fine, but for heaven's sake do it for a good reason!

Oh I have a good reason to vote (courteously ) against you, I'd just rather that you be ignorant of it.

[GeneralHankerchief]

That makes no sense. If you constantly vote for me, it probably means that you think I'm mafia. If you have a good reason for doing so, then you're not doing the town any favors by withholding it.

[Andres]

What I don't like is now, I'm pretty much next in line to be lynched for no good reason.

Wait a minute, why would it be sure that you are going to get lynched in the next round because of what occured in the previous round?

Alot can happen and for what it's worth, and only speaking for me, you're currently not my prime suspect.

Paranoia?

[GeneralHankerchief]

Mostly just keeping my eye on the tally and the reasons why people voted for me. In the most recent game similar to this one, Mafia VIII, I remember a lot of people seemingly lynched because they were "next in line". I'm sensing this trend happening again.

[Thermal]

yet another bandwagon for lazy townies

I believe i made 8 points for the reason i voted against ATPG, so while i followed the bandwagon i personally had various reasons to.

My theory is that after Andres got himself into trouble ATPG wildly upstages him, as if to protect andres, and through previous deranged behavior i will FoS: Andres i think GH and Tincow seem more normal to be honest. I like expressive behavior, but theres expressive and then pathetic (i.e accusing everyone like ATPG did) regardless i was going to vote against ATPG before i even seen the tally, after reading through his puzzling posts they seemed to burden his own votes and carry them off of Andres, interesting.

[taka]

Taka still has my alarm bells tingling. Semi-lurking amongst the buzz of many verbose players, he could be a suspect.

sorry if im seem to be semi lurking to you, i've exams coming up and tend to be only able to catch up when im at home (and not in library)

Now, with ATPG gone, i think i'll be able to catch up more easily without all his random accusation posts

As with what andres asked, i too would like to see your opinion on little grizzly



so far, from my opinion i feel that the mafia (or at least one) is lurking whilst letting townies bickering amongst ourselves and throw false accusations on each other. i still fail to see anyone suspicious enough for me to think they are mafia at a high percentage.

i do however think that shlin is underposting; from what i know he used to post a lot. i think i've only seen him post once?