My thought was more "Hmm, troops in Toulouse, guess I had recruited them".

I would certainly approve of a rule that required permission before troops could be moved into someone else's settlement. At the very least some kind of notification. Otherwise keeping track of what troops in your settlements are yours and aren't could be very confusing if the faction grows much.

Quote Originally Posted by Cecil XIX View Post
Indeed, that would have been the correct response in every other PBeM so I don't blame you. Does my rules clarifcation help?

Basically, if you suddently notice some soldiers in your settlement that you didn't recruit, than instead of saying "Hey, I've got some extra soldiers I can move." you should think "Hey, who put these here?"

I'm thinking of adding rules allowing players to bar other player's units from entering their settlements, as well as throwing someone else's units out. How does that sound to anyone?