Dark Vacuum [Concluded]

[boudica]

oh right - I thought it was a weapon or something

and so:

Warman8: 1 (Sigurd)
Rhythmic/Psychonaut: 1 (Jolt)
Reenk Roink: 1 (boudica)

[ELITEofWARMANGINGERYBREADMEN88]

I don't know how relevant it is that both Andres and shlin was at the same location.

I have made a small tally to find out who was at the same location.

messhall/quarters
Andres
boudica
Reenk Roink
Rythmic
shlin28
TevashSzat
TheFlax
Warman8

If perchance the killers need to be at the same location, part of the OP suggests it (My interpretation is that physical beings need to be physically present, while Nephilim and other psychic beings don't and both killings was performed by physical entities), I would suggest we look at the players in that particular location.

Let's start with
vote: Warman8, what do you have to say?

How do you know the killer will kill someone in the same room? Could he just not slip out and kill someone in another room, this case, the messhall/quarters, and slip back out and make it look like osmeone here killed Shlin and Andres?


Vote:TheFlax What do you think Mr.?

[Quintus.JC]

Vote: TevashSzat

He is being quiet, also he was in the messhall on the night of murder.

[TevashSzat]

Vote: TevashSzat

He is being quiet, also he was in the messhall on the night of murder.

Well....I'm always quiet in mafia games.

I don't post unless I have something relatively meaningful to contribute or I don't want to get WOGed. I usually don't have that great of an insight so most games I'm not that active....

How do you know the killer will kill someone in the same room? Could he just not slip out and kill someone in another room, this case, the messhall/quarters, and slip back out and make it look like osmeone here killed Shlin and Andres?


Vote:TheFlax What do you think Mr.?

IIRC, it said in the rules that you can only interact with people in the same location you're at.

[Quintus.JC]

Well....I'm always quiet in mafia games.

I don't post unless I have something relatively meaningful to contribute or I don't want to get WOGed. I usually don't have that great of an insight so most games I'm not that active....

That is fair, however you were among the people in the Messhall on the previous night, so I see the vote as justified. Besides its only a massive tie right now, it would be interesting to see who breakes it though.

[Quintus.JC]

Tally
The following people all have one vote:
Reenk Roink
Rythmic
TevashSzat
TheFlax
Warman8

boudica is the only person without a vote who was at the Messhall last night.

[TheFlax]

IIRC, it said in the rules that you can only interact with people in the same location you're at.

No it did not, I'll quote the rules again for your benefit.

By being in a location someone else is not, you may or may not be subject to whatever abilities they may have, and your abilities may or may not be usable only on those in the same location as you.

Isn't that clear enough? Its very probable, as it was mentioned before that some may be able to use their abilities only in their locations, while other roles are not limited by this.

Now if you could kill people in other locations and most of them though that was impossible, you'd probably target the location containing the most people, to create kind of confusion and finger pointing that's happening right now. I still think pretty much everyone is a suspect, even those not in the Crew Quarters/Mess Hall.

[seireikhaan]

ATTENTION:

I am a Grigorii Ostranovii, Lieutenant aboard the Ravager. Each night, I have may access the Crew Manifest to investigate the condition of one player, provided I am in one of two places during the night.

Night one, I investigated Sigurd- he was quite stable and innocent.

Last night, I investigated Ares- and I received a report indicating that he is completely insane. In other words, Ares has succumbed to the Nephilim and is GUILTY. He must be lynched now.

Vote: Ares

Tally:

Ares- 1 (seireikhaan)
Reenk Roink- 1 (Boudica)
Rythmic- 1 (Jolt)
TevashSzat- 1 (Quintus J.C.)
TheFlax- 1 (Warman)
Warman8- 1 (Sigurd)

[glyphz]

ATTENTION:

I am a Grigorii Ostranovii, Lieutenant aboard the Ravager. Each night, I have may access the Crew Manifest to investigate the condition of one player, provided I am in one of two places during the night.


Last night, I investigated Ares- and I received a report indicating that he is completely insane. In other words, Ares has succumbed to the Nephilim and is GUILTY. He must be lynched now.

Vote: Ares

Best lead we have.

Vote: 777Ares777

Ares was in the Flight Deck last 'day.' Could mean mafia does not need to be in the same place as their victims.

[TheFlax]

Ares was in the Flight Deck last 'day.' Could mean mafia does not need to be in the same place as their victims.

He's also one of the biggest proponents of the idea that abilities can only be used in your location. Given that's not true for sure and given the recent reveal, I'm thinking its very possible he was misleading us into only voting for people in the same location as those murdered. Judging by the votes before the reveal, it nearly worked.

Thus, I'm inclined to think 777Ares777 might be guilty, as glyphz said, we have no better leads.

Vote: 777Ares777

[LittleGrizzly]

Vote: 777Ares777

Im willing to go with this...

[taka]

Vote: 777Ares777

i guess so

[Thermal]

ATTENTION:

I am a Grigorii Ostranovii, Lieutenant aboard the Ravager. Each night, I have may access the Crew Manifest to investigate the condition of one player, provided I am in one of two places during the night.

Night one, I investigated Sigurd- he was quite stable and innocent.

Last night, I investigated Ares- and I received a report indicating that he is completely insane. In other words, Ares has succumbed to the Nephilim and is GUILTY. He must be lynched now.

Vote: Ares

Tally:

Ares- 1 (seireikhaan)
Reenk Roink- 1 (Boudica)
Rythmic- 1 (Jolt)
TevashSzat- 1 (Quintus J.C.)
TheFlax- 1 (Warman)
Warman8- 1 (Sigurd)

If i have succumbed to nephilim i know nothing of it, unless players aren't informed that they have been changed then your a fat liar, And a bandwagon has started against me over it? If you continuously take peoples words for things so scantly then town will never win, i'm not going to be angry at anyone particular, but it couldnt do any harm to think for yourself, had i have made this baseless statement about seireikhaan before he made one up about me, the exact thing would have happened to him, far to easy to forge.


I mose well mention some observations before you maul me:

- Andres was dragged into the mess hall, so his killer is probably from another room
- The killer hates families and children, just an observation


All votes after seireikhaan have been

-best lead we have

It isn't a lead though its a statement by a player who hasn't been proven innocent himself, and unless ive been mistaken he's lying

-inclined to believe im guilt

I wonder why? That annoys me highly.

-willing to go with it

Oh you mean your willing to follow a bandwagon just to kill a random person off?

-I guess so

???


Seriously town, investigate seireikhaan and stop doing mindless voting


right thats my piece, if im innocent you will lynch seireikhaan i assume?

[Thermal]

ATTENTION:

I am a Grigorii Ostranovii, Lieutenant aboard the Ravager. Each night, I have may access the Crew Manifest to investigate the condition of one player, provided I am in one of two places during the night.

Night one, I investigated Sigurd- he was quite stable and innocent.

Last night, I investigated Ares- and I received a report indicating that he is completely insane. In other words, Ares has succumbed to the Nephilim and is GUILTY. He must be lynched now.

Vote: Ares

Tally:

Ares- 1 (seireikhaan)
Reenk Roink- 1 (Boudica)
Rythmic- 1 (Jolt)
TevashSzat- 1 (Quintus J.C.)
TheFlax- 1 (Warman)
Warman8- 1 (Sigurd)

Just to criticize this post


it starts with attention with bold letters, It feels very artificial

He then goes on to bold his role name, maybe your insecure about the role you have seireikhaan? By bolding a complex name you aim to impress....

Saying someone is innocent before moving onto me gives people security in your accusation against me, lulling them into thinking you tell the truth

Insane? you must know more than that, insanity? well at least that doesnt mean im necessarily mafia even on that false statement, insane cops can be useful even for example.

GUILTY in bold letters? If you really had this role you wouldnt feel the need to emphaise like his, those that know of seirkeikhaan's usual behavior could easily see flaws in his post im sure

I must be lynched now? You direct people, you dont just give them an idea, you direct them to do something when your just as easily evil yourself.

Finally seireikhaan is known for mind games and the like, to trust him so..uh why bother ares town doesn't seem to have a mind of there own

location: mess hall
vote: seireikhaan

[CountArach]

A mafia surely wouldnt claim detective at this point because that would just be a huge gambel and just invites the real detective to investigate them at night.

Vote: Ares

EDIT: Location: Flight Deck

[CountArach]

I suggest we leave sereikhaan in a room on his own tonight for security reasons. Unless of course his ability is limited by night-time location.

[LittleGrizzly]

Why would khaan do this as mafia though ?

surely this is a big risk to take when he was essentially in no danger...

rather than just criticising his bolding and townies accepting his reveal give us something about what motive he could have for such a move as mafia ?

You did seem to take a while to write that reply... this could just be you composing yourself for your defence as a townie... or worried scum...

[Thermal]

A mafia surely wouldnt claim detective at this point because that would just be a huge gambel and just invites the real detective to investigate them at night.

Vote: Ares

EDIT: Location: Flight Deck

Claiming detective is great for seireikhaan if hes mafia, as he cannot be killed in the night, no townie would say there detective else they know they'd get mafia killed, admitting your detective until essential is not a good move.


The only way i believe seireikhaan is if i have been converted and YLC hasn't told me, I have been framed in the past too but meh, at least if i ever get the position of mafia i have a way of getting rid of townies, thanks for the method seir

[LittleGrizzly]

I suggest we leave sereikhaan in a room on his own tonight for security reasons. Unless of course his ability is limited by night-time location.

we need to agree an area noone else is allowed to go... medbay perhaps ?

mess hall bad idea for obvious reasons...

ill go Location Flight Deck

[Thermal]

My post didnt take long to compose, i didnt look at the thread till about 10 minutes before my reply, believe it or not, and no im not a notorious liar, it would be different if id been know as sneaky but im not.

And as the flax pointed out, location players are in isnt good enough, seir needs investigation if possible.

[CountArach]

Claiming detective is great for seireikhaan if hes mafia, as he cannot be killed in the night, no townie would say there detective else they know they'd get mafia killed, admitting your detective until essential is not a good move.

And if he is proven to be wrong then we can lynch him later. At this point in time I am always willing to trust a role reveal especially of this magnitude.

[Thermal]

Well if he doesnt get killed in the night that is suspicious in itself.


Role PM quoting being disallowed then?

[LittleGrizzly]

I would hope/assume if there was another investigator he would come out now and challenge 'khaan's claim.... in the absence of a counter claim and an obvious motive... it is hard to see a better lynch past you...

[Thermal]

I would hope/assume if there was another investigator he would come out now and challenge 'khaan's claim.... in the absence of a counter claim and an obvious motive... it is hard to see a better lynch past you...

I know, but i hate the way 4 people follow seireikhaan on that sole reasoning

[LittleGrizzly]

Rules(shamelessly ripped from Netherworld, with a few modification according to this games needs ):

NO QUOTING PMS

[Thermal]

Well the best i can do is say my name then

~ Marcus Adams
~ Captured ECD marine


I'll just join white eyes in the marine death pile

[Beefy187]

Maybe Seireikhaan is speaking for the real detective as he is already cleared.

Vote: Ares

Location: Lab


Lab is my shweet shpot! Its Mine!!

[taka]

Location: Engine Room

[seireikhaan]

Forgot my location:

Location: Flight Deck

[LittleGrizzly]

Ill change to Location Labs would rather keep 'khaan in a room to himself...