The Godfather, Part 3 [Concluded]

[Sasaki Kojiro]

But khaan didn't have a guilty result on seamus--else he'd have voted him. Khaan's reasoning on Seamus comes from something else. It's a reasonable suspicion but not convincing, Seamus should be familiar with the "private message-I know your guilty" tactic, it's been used before. And why on earth would the real detective pm a mafioso and tell him he was guilty?

btw, being vig killed makes me less likely to be guilty, not more.

[shlin28]

btw, being vig killed makes me less likely to be guilty, not more.

How? The mafia can still be killed by a vig, so you still have the same probability of being killed as a townie. So you are not less likely to be guilty.

Plus the vig sounded very... determined to save the town, hardly an example of a pure evil serial killer.

[LittleGrizzly]

Haven't got a clue who to vote for.. there seem to be a few candidates without much to go on... and then everyone else who hasn't really attracted much suspicion and possibly deserves some...

BTW sasaki encouraging lynching of first person to do 3 line vote is a good way to scare people off voting

[Sasaki Kojiro]

How?

The game is still going.

Haven't got a clue who to vote for.. there seem to be a few candidates without much to go on... and then everyone else who hasn't really attracted much suspicion and possibly deserves some...

BTW sasaki encouraging lynching of first person to do 3 line vote is a good way to scare people off voting

I was suggesting the opposite. We wouldn't want people posting just to say " I dunno" would we...

[Reenk Roink]

Vote: Seamus

[Seamus Fermanagh]

In this I agree with Shlin, Kojiro-san. Your death -- if we presume a Vig of sorts -- neither clears you of suspicion nor signals your guilt. I have tentatively assigned you townie status thus far because I have seen you doing what seems to be a fairly normal job for you of hammering suspects. You're correct about 'khaan's PM to me. The fact that I knew it was a fishing expedition prompted my response. Even if I weren't a townie, I suspect I'd have responded about the same regardless of what role I had. I did report all the PM stuff for everyone's review, and 'khaan can confirm I haven't altered anything.

Right now, I have concerns with Taka -- for a virtual lack of activity which, as I and others note, is not pro-town in its effect.

I also have concerns with Beefy. He is always around, always in tune with the discussion, and has posted more in this one thread than I think he has in both Capos combined. This is Beefy with 83 posts -- only about 12% behind Sasaki. Folks, this has NOT been his track record. I know he's been more active in mafia this last 6 months, but that's 2.76 ppp!

Of the two, I have been more adamant about lurkers for several posts, so for now I'll

Vote: taka

[Beefy187]

In this I agree with Shlin, Kojiro-san. Your death -- if we presume a Vig of sorts -- neither clears you of suspicion nor signals your guilt. I have tentatively assigned you townie status thus far because I have seen you doing what seems to be a fairly normal job for you of hammering suspects. You're correct about 'khaan's PM to me. The fact that I knew it was a fishing expedition prompted my response. Even if I weren't a townie, I suspect I'd have responded about the same regardless of what role I had. I did report all the PM stuff for everyone's review, and 'khaan can confirm I haven't altered anything.

Right now, I have concerns with Taka -- for a virtual lack of activity which, as I and others note, is not pro-town in its effect.

I also have concerns with Beefy. He is always around, always in tune with the discussion, and has posted more in this one thread than I think he has in both Capos combined. This is Beefy with 83 posts -- only about 12% behind Sasaki. Folks, this has NOT been his track record. I know he's been more active in mafia this last 6 months, but that's 2.76 ppp!

Of the two, I have been more adamant about lurkers for several posts, so for now I'll

Vote: taka

To be fair, I died reasonably early on both capo. And speed of discussion on Capo was way too fast for me.. Also I had high school when Capo took place.

As my high school finished, the only hobby I have besides studying is the Org, few other sites mainly sports news and ORG. This explains the sudden boost of my post. Also, I was asked to post more to avoid ATPG double posting.

I cannot and will not vote for taka just yet as a part of our mutual trust treaty. Him being a lurker is soo suspecious but I have taka guilt sensor and when he is guilty I should notice it..

As Tevash was 80 percent scum, why don't we look for the peoples who he called to be innocent? Or do you guys think, he would avoid investigating peoples in his crew?

[Chaotix]

Vote: Reenk

I'll continue voting for him for all of his scummy posts back during the ATPG-Tevash tiebreaker.

[pevergreen]

Shlin, stop reading into the write ups. Its often a dead end, even when it isnt it is hardly ever helpful.

Ares and Shlin are still the top of my to-lynch list, but I can't actually field any substantial evidence.

LG, I'd like to see you put a vote down.

Vote: taka

Come out, come out wherever you are.

[Reenk Roink]

This is worth a shot:

I ask everyone who will for my sake to vote for Seamus.

[taka]

Shlin, stop reading into the write ups. Its often a dead end, even when it isnt it is hardly ever helpful.

Ares and Shlin are still the top of my to-lynch list, but I can't actually field any substantial evidence.

LG, I'd like to see you put a vote down.

Vote: taka

Come out, come out wherever you are.

Boo. im here

first thing i'll admit is that im no good at keeping up with the big games, seems smaller games fit me better - theres kinda too much to read in a big game which i havent read through (as i mentioned to beefy)

looking back at some of the more recent posts, i think that Tincow has made quite a few reasonable points about shlin. even though he is our CoP, i find him highly suspicious that i dont think he's actually contributed to helping town much at all considering his position.

for now i'll hear to reenk's plea and

vote: Seamus

but next round, unless something drastic happens, im gonna vote shlin.