The Godfather, Part 3 [Concluded]

[Askthepizzaguy]

And then the Boombox guy has no purpose. TinCow.

The lyrics, my friend, the lyrics point at one person in this game. The song titles themselves have 9, 2, and 1 in them, but most of the songs have the word "one", and one of them have "111" in them, you said so yourself.

Plus the references to God.

If they aren't put there deliberately, then why those specific songs? especially when we cannot find an explanation for them? And why is Sasaki defending Ares? Even you, TinCow, think Sasaki is scum, don't you?



Listen, you will never, ever, get more evidence pointing the finger directly at one person from a host again without it being totally unfair for the Godfather. I've determined that the twist of the game is that the mafia can recruit, something that Ares himself suggested earlier. I will dig out the links myself if I need to.

Nevermind it was Shlin28:

Edit: Or maybe the twist in this game is mafia recruitment.

But at least one other person thinks the mafia can recruit.

Listen, I am a big blabbermouth and a bloodhound who is sniffing a strong scent of scum from Ares. Please help me understand why all the clues in the game point to him.

1. Voting patterns
2. Activity
3. Flip-Flopping (Sasaki versus me, Ares versus me... first Sasaki is OK with me, then suddenly reverses for no reason and "ignores" me, which obviously he's NOT actually doing... then Ares who suddenly reverses and thinks I am scum one moment, and totally innocent the next, and Sasaki is defending Ares)
4. Song writeups all indicate Gods or Numbers
5. SkyNet, which did nail at least 2 mafia this game, I swear it... but ignore that if you want.

I am not always right. But if you look at Ares objectively, the evidence is too compelling to ignore, isn't it???

Someone either commit me to a mental hospital or explain WHO IN THIS GAME is objectively more the Godfather than Ares.

It's been suggested: Reenk or Andres.

I think they are the new henchmen. They are both acting scummy, for sure, and both defending Ares.
But if you don't kill the Godfather, he will just recruit more henchmen.






I must be crazy. Talk me down from this ledge, my fellow townies...

[LittleGrizzly]

I must be crazy. Talk me down from this ledge, my fellow townies...

Jump! Jump! Jump!

ok ok... I think your putting too much faith into the song choices, better off focusing on the rest of your case, you've certainly made him a suspect in my eyes... along with Andres and Reenk but TBH the only person i would put money on his innocence is pevergreen...

[Askthepizzaguy]

I must be crazy. Talk me down from this ledge, my fellow townies...

Jump! Jump! Jump!

ok ok... I think your putting too much faith into the song choices, better off focusing on the rest of your case, you've certainly made him a suspect in my eyes... along with Andres and Reenk but TBH the only person i would put money on his innocence is pevergreen...

I determined that Ares was the best candidate long before I even LOOKED at the songs.

But... the songs do ALSO indicate Ares, more than anyone else in this game.

1. numbers... only a few people left alive have numbers in their name
2. god or gods... only one person left alive is a direct reference to a god or gods
3. 111... is a triple number
4. lyrics repeating three times in at least one song.

Sasaki himself suggested that the writeups might not be an indication until late game. Now he has no serious alternative theories.

And vote the lurker... it's a very persuasive strategy that all the current suspected mafia are proposing, and none of them are lurkers.

But focus on the meat of my argument against Ares in my earlier accusation, it's fairly good stuff, and I also cleared many people for being under pressure all game but never defended, targets of the scumbags, or doing suicidal behaviors or very, very risky behaviors.

Ares is the only remaining person who the suspected scumbags seem to have a problem with killing. Everyone else is fair game.

[TinCow]

And then the Boombox guy has no purpose. TinCow.

Not true. It's GH's way of having a bit of fun and commenting on the game without making any official statements.

The lyrics, my friend, the lyrics point at one person in this game. The song titles themselves have 9, 2, and 1 in them, but most of the songs have the word "one", and one of them have "111" in them, you said so yourself.

It's possible that there are some hints in some lyrics, but definitely NOT in all of the songs. The first song was definitely a 'Welcome to Godfather 3' gesture. 'One Love' was definitely a commentary on the nastiness that went on in the game that round. If GH is making broad commentary like that with those two songs, he is likely doing it with the others as well. As others have noted, GH would not make any clue too direct. He likes pure mafia games, and anything that goes so far as to name a specific living person as mafioso gives the town too large an advantage. In his last game the clue he gave the town was to inform them that there actually wasn't a detective in the game. If GH were to drop clues in this game, I think they would be very amorphous and, at best, would name multiple people at the same time. This is why I jumped on the greenness of the false lyrics. Green could have meant many people, including several who were dead. That's about as good as I would expect a GH clue to get. If there are any clues at all in this game, they're probably about the 'twist,' whatever that may be.

[Thermal]

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

And then the Boombox guy has no purpose. TinCow.

The lyrics, my friend, the lyrics point at one person in this game. The song titles themselves have 9, 2, and 1 in them, but most of the songs have the word "one", and one of them have "111" in them, you said so yourself.

Plus the references to God.

If they aren't put there deliberately, then why those specific songs? especially when we cannot find an explanation for them? And why is Sasaki defending Ares? Even you, TinCow, think Sasaki is scum, don't you?



Listen, you will never, ever, get more evidence pointing the finger directly at one person from a host again without it being totally unfair for the Godfather. I've determined that the twist of the game is that the mafia can recruit, something that Ares himself suggested earlier. I will dig out the links myself if I need to.

Nevermind it was Shlin28:



But at least one other person thinks the mafia can recruit.

Listen, I am a big blabbermouth and a bloodhound who is sniffing a strong scent of scum from Ares. Please help me understand why all the clues in the game point to him.

1. Voting patterns
2. Activity
3. Flip-Flopping (Sasaki versus me, Ares versus me... first Sasaki is OK with me, then suddenly reverses for no reason and "ignores" me, which obviously he's NOT actually doing... then Ares who suddenly reverses and thinks I am scum one moment, and totally innocent the next, and Sasaki is defending Ares)
4. Song writeups all indicate Gods or Numbers
5. SkyNet, which did nail at least 2 mafia this game, I swear it... but ignore that if you want.

I am not always right. But if you look at Ares objectively, the evidence is too compelling to ignore, isn't it???

Someone either commit me to a mental hospital or explain WHO IN THIS GAME is objectively more the Godfather than Ares.

It's been suggested: Reenk or Andres.

I think they are the new henchmen. They are both acting scummy, for sure, and both defending Ares.
But if you don't kill the Godfather, he will just recruit more henchmen.






I must be crazy. Talk me down from this ledge, my fellow townies...

ummm, silence, kinda ! Were only on a forum and your giving me earache

[GeneralHankerchief]

[Reenk Roink]