The Godfather, Part 3 [Concluded]

[GeneralHankerchief]

All right, looks like it's just Ichigo and Seamus then.

Thanks Reenk.

[seireikhaan]

I leave you folks alone for 8 hours and I come back to this? Dear lord...

Vote: Ichigo

Sorry, my man, but its not a choice I like making...

[TevashSzat]

Well......don't really have anything against Seamus or Ichigo atm. Ichigo seems to not be active at all atm, which is not characteristic of scum, but I don't see how Seamus is extremely scummy right now either so......I'm going to let you guys decide this......

[Quintus.JC]

Vote: Seamus

Nothing against Seamus, but Ichiago just doesn't look at all like mafia atm.

[TinCow]

Vote: Seamus

Nothing against Seamus, but Ichiago just doesn't look at all like mafia atm.

How on earth can you tell? He's made a grand total of 2 posts the entire game, including his post to join.

Vote: Ichigo

If one of the two has to go, make it a lurker, not someone as active as Seamus.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

I remember Ichigo acting a lot like disco the last few games...

[LittleGrizzly]

If the choice is between an active seamus and an inactive ichigo then ichigo has to go

Vote Ichigo

[Beefy187]

Vote: Seamus

Nothing against you Seamus. But if I remember right, Ichigo died round one or two, two games in a row being innocent. It will suck if we do that again in his come back game.

Logically speaking Ichigo is a better lynch

[ULC]

Vote: Seamus

Again, Ichigo simply has not been on at all since at least 10:53 yesterday. He may be busy, he may simply not have gotten on, but we are looking for mafia, not lurkers (which Ichigo does not count as yet!) - mafia are active to a degree, in other parts of the Org, like glphz was when he was mafia in my game. If Seamus is town, then death should not influence activity, rather only the ability to vote.

[LittleGrizzly]

Tally

Ichigo 3 (LittleGrizzly, TinCow, Sereikhaan)
Seamus 3 (YLC, 187Beefyz, Quintus.JC)

I would like to point out that Ichigo's inactivity doesn't represent innocence, he could still be a mafia that simply hasn't opened his pm. Seamus has done nothing to suggest he is mafia, so basically in my eyes we have two people who have done nothing to make themselves appear guilty, one is active in the game, the other isn't...

This makes the choice pretty simple in my eyes...

[seireikhaan]

And never mind that a pair of lurkers achieved Total Victory in Chicago...

[LittleGrizzly]

Sigurd also lurked his way to victory in the last game i was involved in...

[TinCow]

If Seamus is town, then death should not influence activity, rather only the ability to vote.

You're missing the fact that if both are townies, we're killing the only one who's going to give us any help. Ichigo already missed a lynch vote and hasn't done anything to help at all. Seamus is helping and can put his vote to good use. In addition, there are far more ways for an active mafioso to be caught due to patterns in his activity. In contrast, a lurker mafioso easily gets forgotten about by both the townies and the detectives. Lynch the lurkers, you'll never get more info out of them anyway.

[Chaotix]

Vote: Ichigo

I do not suspect either of them at this point. However, one of them must die, and I would rather it be Ichigo than Seamus. The reason? Seamus, when townie, is generally more useful with his analysis than Ichigo, who tends to post spam when active.

[White_eyes:D]

Vote:Ichigo I don't like that he is lurking that much.....but I also don't think he is a Mafia (I mean two posts??).......

[Ignoramus]

Vote: Ichigo

[naut]

If the choice is between an active seamus and an inactive ichigo then ichigo has to go

I agree with you there.

Vote Ichigo

[glyphz]

Vote: Seamus Fermanagh

Tally:

Ichigo - 7 (LittleGrizzly, TinCow, Sereikhaan, Chaotix27, White_eyes:D, Ignoramus, Rythmic)
Seamus - 4 (YLC, 187Beefyz, Quintus.JC, glyphz)

[Andres]

What amazes me is your all ignoring his obvious self preservation vote, something that has got me into serious trouble previously, at least question it!

What amazes me is that you are ignoring that other preservation vote, the one made by Sasaki

[Sigurd]

I am sticking with my initial vote: Ichigo.

Even though he is not active in your game YLC, does not mean he is not active, if not publicly, in this game. It would be a good strategy to appear completely AFK the first days after being chosen by the Godfather ... or being the GF choosing his goons. They will do the work while he takes a few days off in Bahamas.

[boudica]

My initial vote was for Seamus based on a suspicious part of his initial analysis, and he responded to my poking at him well enough. I would have removed my vote from him then and placed it on a lurker at that point, but have only just got back online at this point. I have no particular reason to vote Ichigo either - and would rather vote for someone less active, but am interested as to why YLC says Seamus is ringing alarm bells for him?

so for now I must:

Vote: Abstain

Tally
Ichigo - 7 (LittleGrizzly, TinCow, Sereikhaan, Chaotix27, White_eyes:D, Ignoramus, Rythmic)
Seamus - 4 (YLC, 187Beefyz, Quintus.JC, glyphz)
Abstain - 1 (boudica)

EDIT:
Sorry not even sure if i should be voting now - just read the other thread. Apologies if i misunderstood, I just thought we all had to vote again.

[Andres]

Neither of them strike me as guilty

Vote : Seamus

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Tally
Ichigo - 7 (LittleGrizzly, TinCow, Sereikhaan, Chaotix27, White_eyes:D, Ignoramus, Rythmic)
Seamus - 5 (YLC, 187Beefyz, Quintus.JC, glyphz, Andres)
Abstain - 1 (boudica)

[ULC]

My initial vote was for Seamus based on a suspicious part of his initial analysis, and he responded to my poking at him well enough. I would have removed my vote from him then and placed it on a lurker at that point, but have only just got back online at this point. I have no particular reason to vote Ichigo either - and would rather vote for someone less active, but am interested as to why YLC says Seamus is ringing alarm bells for him?

so for now I must:

Vote: Abstain

Tally
Ichigo - 7 (LittleGrizzly, TinCow, Sereikhaan, Chaotix27, White_eyes:D, Ignoramus, Rythmic)
Seamus - 4 (YLC, 187Beefyz, Quintus.JC, glyphz)
Abstain - 1 (boudica)

EDIT:
Sorry not even sure if i should be voting now - just read the other thread. Apologies if i misunderstood, I just thought we all had to vote again.

Please check this post and the links contained within. If people bothered to read what I post I wouldn't require repeating myself continuously like I always do.

[Csargo]

lurking - to read messages on an Internet discussion forum (as a newsgroup or chat room) without contributing

Tada!

Anyways, Andres stole my tradition which is very rude. I would have voted Sasaki, but I wasn't around. Taka said I was guilty, which doesn't make any sense at all. Ignoramus probably has a role since he actually voted for someone. I'll have to go back and read some of Seamus's posts to see whether or not I want to vote for him.

[boudica]

Please check this post and the links contained within. If people bothered to read what I post I wouldn't require repeating myself continuously like I always do.

I'm sorry - Sasaki's double??-talk confused me enough. It seems you saying that your only reason for suspecting Seamus is that (quote YLC) "Seamus on the other hand has my little voice going mad"

[ULC]

I'm sorry - Sasaki's double??-talk confused me enough. It seems you saying that your only reason for suspecting Seamus is that (quote YLC) "Seamus on the other hand has my little voice going mad"

Yes, add to the fact that (again) I said Sasaki and Lord Winter invented something to argue over, which included Seamus, with Sasaki coming to Seamus's defense. This is a lot better argument currently then anyone else has - if someone has a better argument, then my hats off to them. I'll be busy finding mafioso while you all go after the lurkers, see who wins faster

[Jolt]

Vote: Ichigo

Thought about voting for him. Quite honestly, for no reason (e.g. Random)

[shlin28]

YlC seems rather persistent over something rather trivial...

Out of Ichigo and Seamus, I would say Ichigo offers the better lynch. Also, if YLC is in the remotest chance of being scum, he could be trying to provide cover for Ichigo.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Voting closed.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Day 2

It had been a long day in the Gameroom town square, with lots of voting, changed voting, re-voting, and, of course, tallying. Lots and lots of tallying. Chief of Police shlin28, engrossed in a captivating novel, paid little attention to the proceedings, and instead drafted a couple of trustworthy villagers to do the tallying for them.

Upon the first count, the villagers came back to shlin and said that there was a tie vote between two villagers: Ichigo and Seamus Fermanagh. Cursing to himself, for he wanted to go back home and watch some TV, shlin looked up from his book, fired his gun in the air a couple of times, and said "runoff!" before going back and reading some more.

Some time later, the villagers came back with the new tally, whispering the name of who was to get executed in shlin's ear.

"Ichigo!" he yelled. "Get up here, it's time to get on with the show!"

Reluctantly, Ichigo made his way up to the execution platform. He hadn't said much, and it seemed that his silence was the primary reason for getting so many votes. He finally snapped to attention late in the voting when he realized that he would have to say something in order to save himself, but it wasn't enough. And now, he was going to pay for it.

Still, though, he reasoned, at least in his final act he would be providing a cool death for the villagers.

"All right, Ichigo," shlin said, "the villagers say you're guilty and want you to die. Get in the tank."

Before Ichigo did as he was told, an errant laser beam fired off from the shark tank, passing through the glass and hitting Ichigo directly in the stomach. Moaning, he staggered forward a few steps, finally stumbling and tripping into the tank itself, where he was quickly ripped apart by a combination of teeth and lasers.

The villagers properly "ooh"'d and "ahh"'d over the display of marine eating habits and a light show, and all of them went home satisfied after the day's spectacle.

Day 2a tally:
Ichigo: 9 (seireikhaan, TinCow, LittleGrizzly, Chaotix27, White_eyes:D, Ignoramus, Rythmic, Sigurd, Jolt)
Seamus Fermanagh: 5 (Quintus.JC, 187Beefyz, YLC, glyphz, Andres)

Abstained: 6 (shlin28, Reenk Roink, TevashSzat, Sasaki Kojiro, boudica, Ichigo)
Didn't vote: 6 (777Ares777, Lord Winter, taka, Seamus Fermanagh, Gaius Scribonius Curio, Askthepizzaguy)

~~~~~~~~~~~

Still alive: (25)
shlin28
YLC
777Ares777
Andres
seireikhaan
TevashSzat
Quintus.JC
Lord Winter
Rythmic
White_eyes:D
Chaotix27
Sigurd
Reenk Roink
glyphz
boudica
187Beefyz
taka
Seamus Fermanagh
Jolt
LittleGrizzly
Gaius Scribonius Curio
Ignoramus
Askthepizzaguy
TinCow
Sasaki Kojiro

Killed:
Tratorix
CountArach

Executed:
Ichigo

PMs please.