Andres:

Fair points about Kommo's tool. He himself noted its limitations which included reduced accuracy with "newer" players; the inability to discriminate between Pro-town and Mafia roles (spotting the power players quickly and wiping them out is counterproductive if you happen to whack the Detective and the Doctor first); and finally that certain posting styles, when consistent for that player, didn't have enough variance to twig Holmes' radar.

Don't get me wrong, his Holmes was albe to nail me a time or two, but NO SYSTEM (except the one about women running the marriage) is unspoofable -- as about 5 millenia of human history will indicate.

I also agree about your point on listing lynches in advance. Unless we are down to the endgame and we have a VERY focused set of targets, it's counterproductive to suggest more than one round in advance.

Pizza:

You realize that, vis-a-vis this game, your discussion of your tool also provides clear evidence that you have been poring over the specific posts of previous games....which we know figures prominently in the writeups of each night phase. This too is food for thought.