The Godfather, Part 3 [Concluded]

[Seamus Fermanagh]

Tally as of post #1203

Seamus = 4 (Grizz, Reenk, Taka, WE)
Reenk = 2 (C27, GSC)
Shlin = 2 (Andres, QJC)
Taka = 2 (Seamus, pever')

NV = 3 (Beefy, Ares, Glyphz)


I am clearly the best lynch target this round because I am participating but haven't yet produced an iron-clad analysis identifying the godfather. The ONLY possible explanation is that I am the godfather. Poppycock. In fact, I suspect that one or more of those voting for me are well aware that that's arrant nonsense -- but then again that "one or more" have their own reasons to vote for me, don't they?


Reenk says kill him, I have a hunch, so I am to be killed?!?! He doesn't even have Aggonyduck's reputation for hunches behind him to support that kind of malf. To lynch me for that reason is, essentially, to lynch me because "He's known and not murdered yet, so he must be mafia." If that's your level of analysis, then you can skip the rest of this post because you've already decided to kill me regardless of any content or deeper reasoning.


'khaan, murdered early, thinks I altered the PM so that's proof of my guilt? Hello, I already noted that when I cut and pasted. As for what was unique, you were, prior to this round, the only person to have lodged a vote to lynch Shlin. If I as GF or grunt #2, knew Shlin to be mafioso grunt, than I would have had to presume you had investigated Shlin and therefore had to wipe you out immediately, hoping that you would not make an immediate reveal in favor of trying to get two mafiosi (voting shlin being the way to get others to vote for him, build up pressure, and try to find the GF or the other grunt by figuring who was orchestrating some defense/distraction). In that scenario, I would hope to silence you before you could reveal your results and thus also prevent a likely detective assessment of me in the next few rounds. If you were the detective, that would be about what happened -- only I didn't do it. If you are a murdered detective, you're putting a lot of effort into killing an innocent generic townie. Assess carefully who's been interacting with you to encourage that misfocus.


taka voting for me at the time he did was simple self-preservation. Nothing surprising there, and would be the response of an innocent townie OR lurking mafioso. At least he's posting a bit more than the vote....


White_Eyes has been voting almost in lock step with Reenk since the outset of the game. Of the 5 lynch votes where they both voted, 4 have been exactly the same. Only in the round where Winter was lynched did they vote separately. Moreover, you have kept your vote on me, TWICE, after stating that you thought it likely I was pro-town and even after I asked you to shift it. Reenk's 3-4 sentences asserting his hunch are THAT compelling. Exactly what did you get from Reenk when he bought you?


Well, it appears pretty clear that this town will not pressure taka any more than it has, at least for this round. He will be allowed to continue his lurk because you judge him to not be much threat. Since the worry -- aside from me -- seems to center on Shlin, I'll join with and

Unvote: taka; Vote: Shlin

and then see what develops.

Tally as of post #1205 inc.

Seamus = 4 (Grizz, Reenk, Taka, WE)

Shlin = 3 (Andres, QJC, Seamus)
Reenk = 2 (C27, GSC)
Taka = 1 (pever')

NV = 3 (Beefy, Ares, Glyphz)