The Godfather, Part 3 [Concluded]

[CountArach]

Possible candidate for Chief of Police:

Someone who has been suicidal with his life. YLC, who is no longer with us. Therefore: Pevergreen.

However, some of you find my interactions with YLC scummy, which is silly. YLC would have to have been the Godfather. And if you think after all that, YLC is the Godfather, I simply don't know what Occam's Razor means to you.

So, other candidates: Taka
Frankly, anyone who lurks this much and has been threatened to be lynched for it, posted no defense and seemingly allows it to happen, ain't no Godfather. But! If you're too scared, let's offer another one:

(Remember, the nominee must be someone who logically speaking cannot be the Godfather)

I was thinking White_Eyes, but it's a little risky. What if he were the Godfather lynching his own subordinate, Lord Winter?

The others I cannot fully, comprehensively clear. But I would be inclined to trust Andres... he hasn't been controlling the game and he never triggered my scum alarms.

I'd suggest Beefy187... but... to be honest, he's due. He's due to be a mafia and show us all how awesome he really, really is. As such, I don't want to risk it.

Quintus.JC and Chaotix27... I feel they are innocent. But you know, the Godfather would easily slip past my detection if they supported me over TevashSzat. Last ditch effort to help themselves win. That said, I don't feel they are guilty.

I'm sorry, but YLC is the best choice. Pevergreen is the replacement, he suicided as the Godfather? Nope. Never gonna happen. He voted himself and got himself nearly lynched and kept his vote on himself? Nope. Never gonna happen.





Nominate: YLC/Pevergreen as new Chief of Police. Sorry, Shlin... you had a good run, no hard feelings, I believe you needed to work harder at catching suspects and less harder on defending people you couldn't know were innocent.

My name is CountArach and I approve this message.

[Askthepizzaguy]

777Ares777
Last Activity: 02-16-2009 02:22

This doesn't fully clear him, as he could have sent the murder via email. But seriously, Ares never triggered my scum alarms, and since he seemingly wasn't here during the murder...

I think we can risk it. What do you say? If YLC/Pevergreen makes you too scared, 777Ares777 would also make for a 95% chance of innocence player.

Nominate: 777Ares777, but only if you reject YLC as a candidate. I still feel he's a better choice.

[pevergreen]

In the name of YLCevergreen we agree or whatever.

lewl.

Seriously though. Its pevergreen. No capital.

[Askthepizzaguy]

As you wish. pevergreen it is, my friend.

My thoughts since I found out the game had continued, and Tevash wasnt the Godfather:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

I do have a house of cards built on Lord Winter's death... if he weren't a mafia henchman, we're in serious trouble. But his scummy behavior before he died and afterward... he showed up only to say "see? I wasn't a mafia after all?" which was a total lie as there's only 1 murder per night again, and I'm reasonably certain Sasaki got Vigilante'd not murdered, guilty or innocent.

Lord Winter: After I compelled him to produce suspects under pressure, he kind of sputtered, tossed out a few names, and gave no real case. Then he fled the scene like a frightened chihuahua engulfed in flames. He hasn't been back since, and he isn't helping at all.

TevashSzat: Scummy detective reveal after I predicted he'd reveal, and after I suggested I might let him live a couple more rounds if he had a role. I can dig out the links if you want. Hasn't helped us solve the case, his primary role has been to defend himself.

Sasaki: Could the mafia recruit another henchman after the first one died? Twisty, twisty? I don't trust him. He's far, far too devious and I don't get the vibe that he's legitimately helping us. Plus he might have been investigated or something, the vigilante/unicyclist seemed sure he was mafia.

shlin28: defended TevashSzat up and down... gave excuses for not being here to argue with me... dropped out for less than 20 mins to "eat breakfast" and then scurried out of here when I cranked up the heat, saying he'd be back in 3-4 hours. No reason given. He triggered my scum alarms and hasn't been helping us find suspects, and seems to only be concerned with his own life, and defending scummy people for them. Bad, bad CoP, IMO. Again, no hard feelings shlin.

[Reenk Roink]

I will fight tooth and nail to keep shlin where he is (for the moment).

I'll give more of my thoughts after the kills but unless some good lead comes, I will be going after Chaotix and Gaius as they are threats to me and must be killed. Hopefully the Mafia makes it easier for me and takes out one or both (Lord knows you haven't done a good job helping yourselves so you might as well help me and the town ).

Also, I do have a feeling about Chaotix for awhile now so even if he wasn't going after me he would be my target after Seamus.

To make an actual case: look at how he has slowly been trying to put suspicion on me throughout the game. I think he plans to use me as a scapegoat at the end of game stage as the end game is the hardest and you want suspicious people around you. After all, Reenk is always a good lynch right?

[Askthepizzaguy]

I don't think destroying all your enemies is a legitimate townie strategy, Reenkster. In spite of a difference in philosophy, it's just going to bring heat on you, and what if we lynched you instead of someone else, if you're innocent, that means we wouldn't be lynching the Godfather.

What you're saying Reenks of paranoia and untownie behavior. I also note that you're here at night; sending in your murders, are we?




I can't be sure you're a better candidate than Shlin, but you're actively changing my mind.


EDIT: 20 minutes later- Cat got your tongue, Reenk? Town, I say let's get rid of ye olde shlin this round, and make absolutely certain Reenk is dead before the end of the game. I just can't fathom this.

My case against you before was admittedly very weak Reenk. But I am at a loss to explain this from you now. I wouldn't let that pass if I had a say in it.

[LittleGrizzly]

Don't we have to kill shlin28 before a new CoP can be installed ?

Im nervous about Reenk, im not sure if its just his playing style or what but he does send slightly scummy signals off...

i especially don't like...
I think he plans to use me as a scapegoat at the end of game stage as the end game is the hardest and you want suspicious people around you.

It sounds like he's setting himself up to be left at the end and then have this case to fall back on as an excuse to lynch the other players instead of him... of course the whole kill of my enemy's doesn't exactly inspire confidence either...

Shlin is another one i am unsure about, sure he's been having fun with his CoP role, but it feels like that could be his cover...

TBH out the remaining players they are the ones i getting the gut instinct feeling on, its known to be wrong occasionally though... so im willing to give logic a go as well...

[Andres]

To make an actual case: look at how he has slowly been trying to put suspicion on me throughout the game. I think he plans to use me as a scapegoat at the end of game stage as the end game is the hardest and you want suspicious people around you. After all, Reenk is always a good lynch right?

Well, how about you quote the posts where he threw suspicion at you and then explain why it's nonsense?

[Andres]

Well, how about you quote the posts where he (Chaotix27) threw suspicion at you and then explain why it's nonsense?

Reenk Roink, would you be so kind to answer my question?

[Reenk Roink]

Well, how about you quote the posts where he threw suspicion at you and then explain why it's nonsense?

Andres is officially on my suspicion list now (and it's not retaliatory because everyone is gunning for me this round, I picked Andres specifically dor a reason).

Here you are though Andres (please do be patient guys, points at Atpg and Andres, I can't spend all my time on the game):

Sorry, Reenk, but this is possibly the worst reasoning I've ever seen you give for a serious vote. First: If you don't think ATPG is mafia, then who do you suspect? Surely you must have some opinion about who may be guilty, or who's acting scummy? You're a smart one, Reenk. You will have noticed if someone's acting differently. And if by chance you haven't, whatever happened to "Reenk Roink abstains courteously" when there is no clear suspect?

And yet, you choose not to voice any opinion, and instead vote for somebody who you don't believe is guilty, but just want to stop from helping the town by questioning and examining. Tell me, are we supposed to just stop examining you and look for other suspects, because you said you didn't like people opposing you? Do you think ATPG will stop using SkyNet on you just because he's been lynched?

And then there's the reasoning that TinCow must be scum, even though he was killed when both mafia were still alive, just because he decided to agree with the logical parts of ATPG's post.

Vote: Reenk Roink

I'm getting the same vibe from you that I had in The Prometheus, now. Give it a couple rounds, we'll have a detective reveal from you.

I responded and refuted his claims in a post by the way, look it up if you care (I think you don't care and I'm just a scapegoat for you fyi).

TinCow was indeed not cleared at all like was previously posted by him, and we all know the story by Atpg and his "logic"...

By the way, where's the detective reveal Chaotix?

As for the second post, Chaotix mistook a good Pearl Jam video for me wanting to stay alive (when I was just teasing Atpg that I was alive despite all his efforts). Of course Atpg is up to the usual SkyNet type analysis we expect from him again now, and he rehashes a long refuted argument.

Vote: Andres - Chaotix can wait.

PS:

But what do I know?

In reference to this game, not much.