The Godfather, Part 3 [Concluded]

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Last time GH left clues in the writeup it was to reveal late in the game that he'd left the detective out. I doubt he decide to reveal the godfather in one song when none of the others have fit that pattern. Besides I don't see a basis for the assumption you made that the limpid green line is the important one. What about "Stars can frighten"? This could imply that the town is pursuing "mafia stars" who have done well in previous games.

[TinCow]

I do agree it's not the best evidence, and I wouldn't lynch on the basis of the songs alone. However, I seem to recall that GH expressed after Mafia VIII (or whatever game it was) that he thought he had made the clues too hard. I would expect his clues to be slightly easier in this game because of that. Also, GH isn't necessarily hinting at the Godfather. He could very well be pointing out the nude unicyclist or something else related to the 'twist.' It's even possible that 2 or 3 mafioso are still alive (if 3, they've been cleverly sticking to 1 kill per night to mislead us). If this is indeed pointing to Andres or pevergreen, they could simply be a grunt. Finally, while you have a point about the 'stars can frighten' bit, I think that's nowhere near as prominent a theme in the song as the green bit. The stars bit occurs twice, the green occurs four times. If the song is meant to tell us something, I would place money on it being the dominant theme of the song, not something vague.

[Chaotix]

Bah. I suppose I was probably going to die sometime during this game anyway.

The kill write-up in fact does make it blatantly obvious that someone is trying to frame Reenk. At best, we can trust Reenk a bit more. At worst, it's total WIFOM. I'd put it at 50-50 whether Reenk is innocent now. I could totally see Reenk framing himself to make himself look innocent.

Either way, I don't think Andres is the best choice. We should go after one of the lurkers, but I doubt anyone is going to vote for Reenk at this point.

[Beefy187]

We have 4 more opportunities to lynch if there is only GF left
3 more if theres one grunt and GF
2 more if theres two grunt and GF

Round of applause to Beefy for his outstanding math skills and fact that he realize GF implies girlfriend instead of God Father.

There is two obvious lurkers around, which is taka and glyphz.
I don't like lurkers.. there is players like Roadkill, Tevash and taka on the Org who are very clever silent killers. Glyphz has also won in the past just by not talking at all..

Someone who I will not vote for are Reenk and Pevergreen. I don't think the host will randomly choose a GF to be the CoP. That will be severely unfair for the town. YLC showed suicidal behavior which almost got him self lynched. However the mafia kill so far was not something like we witnessed in Chicago, going after suspects. I think mafia we are looking for are cautious player who won't risk suicidal moves like that.

As for the rest of us... They all look scummy but taka and glyphz stands out for me.

FoS: taka and glyphz

for now. Ill vote them later

[Chaotix]

Someone who I will not vote for are Reenk and Pevergreen. I don't think the host will randomly choose a GF to be the CoP. That will be severely unfair for the town.
for now. Ill vote them later

Err... not to shoot holes in your logic, there, but I think the point of it being a random selection of the CoP means there is an equal chance of mafia being chosen as anyone else. The selection was "random", not "random except for the Godfather".

[Gaius Scribonius Curio]

Reenk's selection as CoP does not exonerate him at all, as Chaotix has pointed out. However I don't think he is guilty.

Following Quintus's post I'm going to Vote:Taka. Quintus and Beefy together make a good case for him being a 'silent' killer.

Haven't got much time today, but I'll be back tomorrow or tuesday with an analysis of the remaining players, whether I'm lynched, or killed, in the meantime or not.

[Beefy187]

Err... not to shoot holes in your logic, there, but I think the point of it being a random selection of the CoP means there is an equal chance of mafia being chosen as anyone else. The selection was "random", not "random except for the Godfather".

I figured that. But if we keep on lynching the CoP...

Beside its Reenk. its REENK!

[taka]

i too dont believe that Reenk is mafia, or else the host is really us up

i'm not fussed to be lynched, that will give me a bit more time to spend on the smaller games which i feel more comfortable with (less reading )

I'll vote: glyphz since it would be either him or me i think and i obviously know im innocent

edit:

sorry, forgot ^^