The Godfather, Part 3 [Concluded]

[Quintus.JC]

....no I am going to sleep....have fun getting killed by the Mafia.....
I may vote tomorrow.....but don't count on it.....only way to make sure Godfather and any of his grunts don't get though is to have a five way tie.....

Why are you trying to delay your vote at this critical stage?

Maybe you'll vote just in the last minute in an attempt to sway the tally in your favour, that is suspicious behaviour WE.

[Askthepizzaguy]

You people who can vote and stuff; uhh what are they called: Alive


In my opinion (if you can't tell) Reenk is just being a distraction, and this writeup will be your last. However, after so many misses this game (probable hits on mafia, but not Godfather) I cannot ask you to just risk your votes on my opinion.

I seriously doubt it's QJC or WhiteEyes, given the total lack of support from anyone besides me. And Reenk is making himself a target, methinks. Godfather is the only target that matters... take aim... don't miss. Who do you think it is?

[Quintus.JC]

I seriously doubt it's QJC or WhiteEyes, given the total lack of support from anyone besides me. And Reenk is making himself a target, methinks. Godfather is the only target that matters... take aim... don't miss. Who do you think it is?

We need a target...

[Reenk Roink]

Reenk, im very curious as to why you keep changing your votes?

Because I woke up and my gut said White eyes.

Andres had made himself unassailable (this is why I wanted him dead a LONG time ago). QJC is still on my radar but I want to take my chances on White eyes because he is more unpredictable than QJC, and wait for the next kill to see who it is.

Oc course, there is always the chance that Beefy or you are guilty, but it seems unlikely to me, and alas, how can I as the defender of Beefy go against him.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I cannot ask you to risk the game on my ever so erroneous opinion.

I suggest Reenk wants to die this round. Self-vote, constantly shifting votes without reason.
Conclusions:

1. Gamble... he's the Godfather but he's making himself appear suicidal and shifty so you'll assume he's the henchman
2. Distraction... he's the henchman, and he's protecting the Godfather.
3. Innocent, and I am a dumb.... something that starts with A for Askthepizzaguy.

That doesn't solve much, does it?

However.

Andres was here earlier. He left a vote on White_Eyes and walked away. He saw it wasn't going to cause a lynch, and any case on white_eyes is objectively pretty weak at this point. He's very cool, and I wouldn't put it past him, but dang... he's turned up townie on everything I've looked at.

It's NOT Taka.

It's probably not you, QJC... though you're playing me like a fiddle if you are, and if so, well done and enjoy your victory. I like that kind of spirit.

And Beefy? You pick.


Lynch Beefy as we always do.... or bring justice to Andres or Reenk. Given Andres' lack of "townie will" to make the risky decision at the end, I suggest he's hiding his guilt and his fear of death.

Me picks teh Andres. But YOU PICK the lynch.

I don't want to be responsible for epic failure.


Also look at how Reenk says Andres is "unassailable" yet doesn't vote him on this crucial vote with active townies here to convince.

[taka]

i agree with some of ATPG's reasoning, its also pretty weak just to say that u woke up and a gut feeling ¬_¬

i was thinking whether reenk was shifting his votes around to make himself shady and protect the god father. and his reasoning just made me think even more that he's scummy. if you wanted andres dead a long time ago, why not vote for him?

unvote: taka
Vote: Andres

i suggest that we make it a tie with andres and WE

[Reenk Roink]

Unvote: White eyes
Vote: Andres

[Askthepizzaguy]

I will feel absolutely terrible about this if I am wrong, guys.

Make sure the reasoning I am using holds up to scrutiny, and Reenk, for gods sake man if you're innocent give a proper defense.

*looks at QJC*

It's up to you, dude. Reenk wanted to destroy you, then changed his vote. Is it Andres or Roink?



*just saw Reenk's vote. I think we let him vote for Andres and see what happens.

[taka]

i am soo tempted to vote reenk just for his constant vote changing without reasoning.....

[Askthepizzaguy]

I think that's the point, Taka.

Look, if Reenk is the Godfather, with such a brilliant gamble, let him have it!

It's Andres he's protecting... I think... even with a vote for him, he's trying to get you to vote for HIMSELF!

We do have an hour or so. Let's make sure the Godfather dies this round.

[taka]

assuming there was 2 scums and we get one this round, we get another lynching round right?

and yes pizza, im resisting temptation lol

[White_eyes:D]

I am only going to be on for about.......half an hour.....there doing internet maintenance at my house (I am at my sisters) but if anyone has any reasons why I should vote for this last round......tell me now.....I won't be here to see what happens....

[Quintus.JC]

Reenk wanted to destroy you, then changed his vote. Is it Andres or Roink?

am soo tempted to vote reenk just for his constant vote changing without reasoning.....

Same here, but that would be pretty pointless now that Reenk has no heat on him, and that would only cause Andres to be lynched for sure.

Reenk is getting so much attention, if he's the GF then I salute him. But he looks more like a grunt/townie than the GF.

i suggest that we make it a tie with andres and WE

Unvote: Beefy
Vote: White Eyes

[Askthepizzaguy]

A tie, for the purpose of trying for a double lynch?

Given the choice between 100% being lynched and 50%, I believe even the Godfather would willingly and unflinchingly accept the flip of the coin. I doubt GH will allow the double lynch.

However, perhaps the tie itself could prolong the round, and narrow it down to Andres and another person. You're sure White_Eyes looks scummy? He just showed up... let me look at him.

[taka]

the more i think about it, i feel that both reenk and andres are probably scum (assuming we have 2 mafias) i think we should get rid of andres first, and then if he isnt the GF, i suggest Reenk afterwards.

only point i dont understand about reenk is, Andres wasnt in the firing line in this round (ie no votes on him), so why is he being the way he is?

assuming that beefy is innocent, and quintus doesn't feel scummy to me neither. i think the other half (andres, reenk, WE) are definately more suspicious, but WE maybe less.

[taka]

i dont think we get double lynch, its just extended time really

edit
and im unsure about WE... i just wanted the extended time

i feel like im starting to contradict and confuse myself lol

[GeneralHankerchief]

In the event of a tie, I haven't decided what to do yet. However, I definitely know that there won't be a double lynch.

[Reenk Roink]

Unvote: Andres
Vote: White eyes

[Quintus.JC]

@Taka, ATPG

If you think Reenk is guilty then I’m willing to vote for him, but I’m not jeopardizing Andres since I think he is innocent.

What ever you lot say I simply cannot see Reenk as the GF, but certainly a grunt.

[Askthepizzaguy]

at least the final lynching will be decided by townies, rather than opportunistic possible mafia!

I appreciate the fact that we're at least thinking about all the suspects, and we are ready to lynch the guy, if we could just deduce who he is. I don't have a vote, and rightly so. It's YOUR game, brothers... you choose.

If we can even nail the henchman this round, and if the Godfather couldn't recruit as I think he could have, we could nail him next round.

As such, I believe Reenk should be the backup lynch, not WhiteEyes. But I am not defending him... just pointing out that Reenk is objectively acting scummier and not explaining himself to us.

Who are our two picks? Most likely Godfather, Most likely Henchman?

They should be the tie, if there is a tie. And I don't think with both mafia being able to vote, we should let it BE a tie. They can save him!

[taka]

WE, if you're on, i suggest you vote andres, reenk is deffinately being awkard

[Askthepizzaguy]

That settles it. Reenk is not a townie, folks. Otherwise he would add to the discussion and justify his votes.

Or if he is a townie, he's got a lot of explaining to do.


He just UNVOTED ANDRES after claiming he's unassailable. For pete's sake, his vote and accusation on Andres was a bluff all along.

[taka]

@Taka, ATPG

If you think Reenk is guilty then I’m willing to vote for him, but I’m not jeopardizing Andres since I think he is innocent.

What ever you lot say I simply cannot see Reenk as the GF, but certainly a grunt.

exactly what we're saying, i think reenk is grunt trying to save the GF (andres)

and his vote off andres just then make me feel that its even more true

As such, I believe Reenk should be the backup lynch, not WhiteEyes.

my intentions are the same

[White_eyes:D]

Unvote: Andres
Vote: White eyes

Last straw Reenk........Vote:Reenk your constant vote changing....has made me vote...I can't help but feel your just pissed at me because I won't vote for Andres.....

[Askthepizzaguy]

If Reenk Roink is mafia, he is either a VERY ballsy Godfather, or an obvious henchman.
Andres looks very much like a Godfather, not a townie or henchman.

Do you want to nail the guy who is likely one kind of scum or the other, or the one who seems to ME to be the likely Godfather?

White Eyes, Taka, and QJC are the only living townies who seem to be adding positively to the discussion. Reenk seems like a desperate mafioso covering up something.

Do you kill the henchman this round, or take a shot at the Godfather?

Your choice, but I pick Andres.

[Reenk Roink]

I hope it's painfully clear that the theory of there being two Mafia is not a good one now, and if there are two, the tandem is among QJC, WE, and taka.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I don't trust anything you say, Reenk. You had multiple chances to act like a proper townie.

Unless you can give an EXCEPTIONAL reason why we should trust you, I put a huge amount of doubt on your credibility.

[Csargo]

This is hilarious. Go Reenk Go!!!

[Askthepizzaguy]

I do give Reenk full marks on entertainment value, sportsmanship, and excellent villainy.

He's certainly doing his best to confuse us. But that points to scum, not town, at least in MY book.

A worthy adversary, to say the least.

[LittleGrizzly]

Reenk by your constant vote changing you make it difficult to see who is working together and who is not...

You complain about Andres for days whilst appearing unhelpful and then when you finally get a chance to lynch him you change your mind...