Better for a townie with a mediocre role to die than someone with better powers. I accept conditionally, if a bunch of people want me dead, then I will duel. I find your reasoning for this duel to be unusually stellar, by the way.
My mouth usually gets me lynched rather quickly. So there is zero chance I will survive this game.
There's always a chance the usurpers will want me dead nice and quickly. Letting me live hasn't worked out too well in certain games. You'd like to extinguish (presumably) two loyal settlers for what amounts to a peeing contest.
Suit yourself.

But frankly, I don't see the logic in this. And I don't think it's particularly good townie strategy. This is similar to everyone being a mediocre vigilante. As you know, those with vigilante powers are wise to refrain from using them unless they have good reason, because vigilantes do tend to cause as much damage as the mafia does if they kill every night.
Oh, and I've been r'ping a spineless peasant FOR FUN since well before I got my role, since the very first Good Men versus Men list.
Bookmarks